Afterlife v5.2

[deepstrasz]

Please show permission from @Xelephant at least.

 

[2noobig4you]

I do have permission as stated.
I remember playing with him last week. He was like "make a screenshot because they won't believe you".
Guess I was naive believing that people wouldn't assume I was lying.

 

[deepstrasz]

I do have permission as stated.
I remember playing with him last week. He was like "make a screenshot because they won't believe you".
Guess I was naive believing that people wouldn't assume I was lying.

Well, simple words aren't evidence. Please try contacting the author then.

 

[2noobig4you]

Let's play a game: You contact Xelephant in order to prove your accusation.
As you have said. Simple words aren't an evidence.

As you might have noticed: I'm clearly annoyed. I didn't put hours of effort into this map just to be called a liar and have this silly discussion. If you have no prove for your claims, don't make them.

 

[tulee]

For edits of existing maps, the onus is on the person to show they have permission. I don't think anyone called you a liar; it is just you are expected to make the effort to show you have been in contact with the original author.

 

[deepstrasz]

Let's play a game: You contact Xelephant in order to prove your accusation.
As you have said. Simple words aren't an evidence.

As you might have noticed: I'm clearly annoyed. I didn't put hours of effort into this map just to be called a liar and have this silly discussion. If you have no prove for your claims, don't make them.

I'm sorry. I have not done anything else but ask for decency following the rules.

Awaiting Update.

 

[2noobig4you]

Has nothing to do with the map but let's continue this debate.

Quoted Map Submission Rules:

2. Rightful Author

In most circumstances, the map must originally be by you. However if the following conditions apply, you may submit an edited version of someone else's map:
- If you are editing an existing map by someone else you must request permission to create your own version. If the author cannot be reached or does not reply, you have permission to edit the map. However, if the author ever replies or comes back, he/she may request your map to be taken down.
- If the author has made it open source, you may upload your radically edited version of the map.

• The map does not contain any license or message from the author denying you from submitting a version of the map.
• In all cases, you must give credit to the original author.

Quote from Afterlife 4.0:

This map is no longer protected, you are free to edit the code for your own gains. Maybe someone somwhere can learn from this small mess i made.

So by Rule 2, 2nd point, you are not even obliged to ask me about permission. Also, I don't see any point saying "you need to have your conversation screen-shotted".

For edits of existing maps, the onus is on the person to show they have permission. I don't think anyone called you a liar; it is just you are expected to make the effort to show you have been in contact with the original author.

What you probably refer to is this:

Quote of Resource Submission Rules:

• Submission of resources consisting of or containing parts of material made by another member of the Warcraft 3 modding community without substantial modification requires proof of the author's documented and verifiable permission.

Which as far as I know does not apply to the map submission rules.
Also you're right. Nobody called me a liar. But saying "I don't trust your words" implies I don't speak the truth, which is the definition of a liar.