you have no known resource except for a footman something that has been rejected or deleted. and only 1 it would seem which leads me to believe that you tried rather a simple edit and then got rejected and never again posted another one because you were so dismayed. This has two effects, first it makes me doubt how much you know in terms of modelling. If geomerging is all you know, then i am afraid that pretty much amounts to nothing. secondly it tells me that you are rather a quitter. of course it boggles my mind why you didnt quit while you were ahead and not post the above post. did i hurt your ego? because getting the judging position is not about ego
out of your 136 posts. Almost all of the model related posts, you were requesting something. i have only found 1 post that resemble some sort of critique
Dude Great Idea!
This will make a awesome Villain body for my maps!

Oh yeah and 5/5
Your join date is Mar 2010, you have been here less than a year so it would seem that your idea of a "good critique" is clearly not yet fully developed.
calling the above critique "accurate" is like calling a shotgun a long range accuracy weapon because at least one of the pallets will be bound to hit the target. we need a judge that has the mental capacity to go beyond the obvious "this is good/bad" judging. you havent shown me anything to convince me, or in fact ANYONE, that you have what it takes to be a that sort of a judge.
lastly, yes i can and will say out loud what i think of your judging skills because that is why i am the host. i am here to keep an eye on the thread while making decisions that needs to be made so it doesnt bother the higher-ups like pyritie on petty things like looking for judge or dealing with angry contestants.