• Check out the results of the Techtree Contest #19!
  • Listen to a special audio message from Bill Roper to the Hive Workshop community (Bill is a former Vice President of Blizzard Entertainment, Producer, Designer, Musician, Voice Actor) 🔗Click here to hear his message!
  • Read Evilhog's interview with Gregory Alper, the original composer of the music for WarCraft: Orcs & Humans 🔗Click here to read the full interview.
  • Create a void inspired texture for Warcraft 3 and enter Hive's 34th Texturing Contest: Void! Click here to enter!
  • The Hive's 22nd Icon Contest: Creep Abilities is now concluded, time to vote for your favourite set of icons! Click here to vote!

Mod Suggestion

Status
Not open for further replies.
PurplePoot said:
I'm not saying I disagree at all with real criticism. I'm just saying that the net has a need for a site without it, due to the number of people who do.
Click to expand...

Where there is no real criticism, there is no growth.

I think The Hive could use some right now.
 
PurplePoot said:
I'm not saying I disagree at all with real criticism. I'm just saying that the net has a need for a site without it, due to the number of people who do.
Click to expand...
And as long as the staff and the site's most respected members believe this, no amount of discussion or persuasion will change it. C'est la vie.
 
While that may be true, I don't think it's a reason to shy away from improving the current site, nor does the Hive have any obligation to be "that" site.
 
Mecheon said:
Find me one successful website that does that and we might consider it

Might
Click to expand...

deviantART: where ART meets application!

Gallery directors get changed each year.

It works better there because there's such a huge userbase so there's always someone to fill the position. Here, however, I doubt that'd work because our userbase (the actual useable part) is much smaller.
 
As I see it half of the active users of this site have, at some point, been moderator already.
Considering that, how could the regular users ever respect the mods here?

At wc3c on the other hand, all moderators have been doing their thing for years now. Therefore their opinions are highly valued and respected by all members.
So I guess what I'm saying is that you need less fluctuation and more long-term staffies, people who do it with dedication, not just for the title.
How to find those I don't know :(

With PurplePoot you had someone like that, but you managed to drive him away somehow ...
 
PitzerMike said:
So I guess what I'm saying is that you need less fluctuation and more long-term staffies, people who do it with dedication, not just for the title.
Click to expand...

In the last few days lingering in chat during my free time at work, to ask a few questions about memory space I'd been wanting answered, I found out a lot about The Hive's staff and userbase. A few things I found really made everything so much clearer.

The Hive's active users and staff are mostly teenagers(there are a few I have not asked)-- Not older gents like myself, but 14-18 year old kids in high school. While you folks of that age group may not have come to understand it yet, the teenage years are the most volatile and a time where hormones run rampant. Because of this, kids of that age lash out, argue, fight for no reason, take major offense to the lightest of jokes, try to prove they're better than others, claim their dominant place in groups, or even make stupid decisions under the false assumption that they're right simply because they think they are.

I've witnessed stupid commenting, pointless arguing, fight picking, and all sorts of angsty teenage displays throughout. By both new users, active users, and moderators.

The rate of which teenage e-peen is being thrown around here is absolutely disgusting. And I hope everyone, as well as Ralle, can step back from everything and think about how what I've said pans out. Because if I'm not mistaken in my observations, they hold a large share in the events that have unfolded here and in the events to come.
 
Vegavak said:
In the last few days lingering in chat during my free time at work, to ask a few questions about memory space I'd been wanting answered, I found out a lot about The Hive's staff and userbase. A few things I found really made everything so much clearer.

The Hive's active users and staff are mostly teenagers(there are a few I have not asked)-- Not older gents like myself, but 14-18 year old kids in high school. While you folks of that age group may not have come to understand it yet, the teenage years are the most volatile and a time where hormones run rampant. Because of this, kids of that age lash out, argue, fight for no reason, take major offense to the lightest of jokes, try to prove they're better than others, claim their dominant place in groups, or even make stupid decisions under the false assumption that they're right simply because they think they are.

I've witnessed stupid commenting, pointless arguing, fight picking, and all sorts of angsty teenage displays throughout. By both new users, active users, and moderators.

The rate of which teenage e-peen is being thrown around here is absolutely disgusting. And I hope everyone, as well as Ralle, can step back from everything and think about how what I've said pans out. Because if I'm not mistaken in my observations, they hold a large share in the events that have unfolded here and in the events to come.
Click to expand...

True.
 
Vegavak said:
In the last few days lingering in chat during my free time at work, to ask a few questions about memory space I'd been wanting answered, I found out a lot about The Hive's staff and userbase. A few things I found really made everything so much clearer.

The Hive's active users and staff are mostly teenagers(there are a few I have not asked)-- Not older gents like myself, but 14-18 year old kids in high school. While you folks of that age group may not have come to understand it yet, the teenage years are the most volatile and a time where hormones run rampant. Because of this, kids of that age lash out, argue, fight for no reason, take major offense to the lightest of jokes, try to prove they're better than others, claim their dominant place in groups, or even make stupid decisions under the false assumption that they're right simply because they think they are.

I've witnessed stupid commenting, pointless arguing, fight picking, and all sorts of angsty teenage displays throughout. By both new users, active users, and moderators.

The rate of which teenage e-peen is being thrown around here is absolutely disgusting. And I hope everyone, as well as Ralle, can step back from everything and think about how what I've said pans out. Because if I'm not mistaken in my observations, they hold a large share in the events that have unfolded here and in the events to come.
Click to expand...

Fuck you, cunt! WHAR IS YOUR E-PEEN NAOW!?!?!!!?!

Honestly, I see adults act like twats on the internet all the time, and then I see kids that know nothing but respect and serious business. There are examples of both on this website. Not everyone is a statistic, especially on the internet.
 
I've got to agree with brad. Don't put them all on a single bag.
While most of what you said is true, your attitude towards my action of negative-repping you was immature, considering how insignificant both the 2 negative points you received and the reputation system itself are.
 
While rep may not matter, negrep matters a lot. To get red rep is akin to being blacklisted for a lot of people because it makes people think twice about helping you and so forth. Besides, it's really true what Vega said for a vast majority of the population here (Just check the profiles). Even if it isn't the case for everyone, the majority still condemns the rest. That isn't to say that we should stereotype everyone, since we shouldn't, but there's certainly a predisposition to be had towards certain age groups and a large chunk of the Hive's populace.

On an almost unrelated note, why is Brad only a community moderator and Ghan the community director? If anything, Brad's way more qualified for the position and way more respectable/active/useful, excluding his random outbursts of asininity. *Cough!* :p
 
Rising_Dusk said:
While rep may not matter, negrep matters a lot. To get red rep is akin to being blacklisted for a lot of people because it makes people think twice about helping you and so forth. Besides, it's really true what Vega said for a vast majority of the population here (Just check the profiles). Even if it isn't the case for everyone, the majority still condemns the rest. That isn't to say that we should stereotype everyone, since we shouldn't, but there's certainly a predisposition to be had towards certain age groups and a large chunk of the Hive's populace.
Click to expand...
Although that may be true on wc3c, the vast majority of the time on the hive whenever someone's negrepped, someone else just +reps them to cancel it out.

We're working on making some concrete rules which disallow that...

On an almost unrelated note, why is Brad only a community moderator and Ghan the community director? If anything, Brad's way more qualified for the position and way more respectable/active/useful, excluding his random outbursts of asininity. *Cough!* :p
Click to expand...
We know.
 
Vegavak said:
In the last few days lingering in chat during my free time at work, to ask a few questions about memory space I'd been wanting answered, I found out a lot about The Hive's staff and userbase. A few things I found really made everything so much clearer.

The Hive's active users and staff are mostly teenagers(there are a few I have not asked)-- Not older gents like myself, but 14-18 year old kids in high school. While you folks of that age group may not have come to understand it yet, the teenage years are the most volatile and a time where hormones run rampant. Because of this, kids of that age lash out, argue, fight for no reason, take major offense to the lightest of jokes, try to prove they're better than others, claim their dominant place in groups, or even make stupid decisions under the false assumption that they're right simply because they think they are.

I've witnessed stupid commenting, pointless arguing, fight picking, and all sorts of angsty teenage displays throughout. By both new users, active users, and moderators.

The rate of which teenage e-peen is being thrown around here is absolutely disgusting. And I hope everyone, as well as Ralle, can step back from everything and think about how what I've said pans out. Because if I'm not mistaken in my observations, they hold a large share in the events that have unfolded here and in the events to come.
Click to expand...
Your generalization is indeed correct. Teenagers are often angry, angsty, volatile, and "high-strung". The problem is, for reasons unknown to me, it seems to be becoming increasingly hard to find users on this site who aren't underage. Maybe someday, when Wolverabid and Darky come back, we could all renovate this site so that proper, mature, Adult moderators could come and replace all of us.
 
I'd just like to mention again, that Moderation should not be visible unless the rules have been broken. And even then, you should only be able to tell because the problem is gone. The offender should be notified personally, and punishment dealt. There should be no, "open moderator warfare", and rarely and reason to make it visible to the public. The exception is that if there is a specific thread that multiple people are abusing, then they should either be warned, punished or the thread closed.

EDIT: Also, the teenager this is some times correct and sometimes not. I've seen a lot of crap from people that (claim) to be adults and some good stuff from younger people as well.
 
Pyritie said:
Although that may be true on wc3c, the vast majority of the time on the hive whenever someone's negrepped, someone else just +reps them to cancel it out.
Click to expand...
Well, that's unfortunate. There are other, higher-priority things to be worrying about with the site than rep, though. It's no biggie. :)
 
Dat's a lie. Repzorz are the world silly. Dontcha' know?

But really, neg rep infractions are so usless once you get more than . . . 10 rep. No one notices or cares. If you have no rep and get neg-repped everyone thinks your breaking the rules more than everyone else.
 
The 'examples' you speak of, Brad, are few and far between; more so now, since the few I haven't talked seem to not want to discuss what's been said, only attack my character, or make broad generalizations that don't hold true to the topic at hand.

Rui said:
I've got to agree with brad. Don't put them all on a single bag.
While most of what you said is true, your attitude towards my action of negative-repping you was immature, considering how insignificant both the 2 negative points you received and the reputation system itself are.
Click to expand...

I think you both missed this gem: 'The Hive's active users and staff are mostly teenagers(there are a few I have not asked)'

And while you agree that 'most of what what I said is true', you simultaneously feel the need to bring up an unrelated irrelevant past event trying to discredit me? It is cheap and childish that you can sit there and try to point your finger at what I thought, and still think, was undeserved negative reputation, implying that it might void the opinion I may have on the matter in this topic(where it is quite irrelevant).

And might I ask, Rui, what part of my post was not true?
 
Yeah, really. Plus, people may just act like a twat around you because you are a twat. Think about how you (and/or) the environment you're in influence the way people behave before judging them.

If someone makes some most disparaging remarks about my mother, I'd be inclined to take them up on it. If they were drunk, the same rules would not apply.

There's this thing, a skill mayhaps, called 'Trolling'. The act of trolling is simply making ignorant and highly objectional comments which bait a user into flying off the handle at you. Now, when being trolled, people can become rediculously angry and make many remarks that they perhaps would not have said otherwise.

It's stuff like that that you have to take into account before mindlessly judging the vast majority of our users.
 
PitzerMike said:
As I see it half of the active users of this site have, at some point, been moderator already.
Considering that, how could the regular users ever respect the mods here?

At wc3c on the other hand, all moderators have been doing their thing for years now. Therefore their opinions are highly valued and respected by all members.
So I guess what I'm saying is that you need less fluctuation and more long-term staffies, people who do it with dedication, not just for the title.
How to find those I don't know :(

With PurplePoot you had someone like that, but you managed to drive him away somehow ...
Click to expand...

We have Mecheon, Rui, Samuraid, brad.dude03, and VGsatomi
 
Brad is correct. Take me for example. I know how every on talks about how I "Overeact", but look at most of the situatons, I am pissed a someone else. I'm normally a dick, but I don't yell and flame people unless they piss me off. I could give names, but this is not a snitch forum, so I will end with that.
 
brad.dude03 said:
Yeah, really. Plus, people may just act like a twat around you because you are a twat. Think about how you (and/or) the environment you're in influence the way people behave before judging them.

If someone makes some most disparaging remarks about my mother, I'd be inclined to take them up on it. If they were drunk, the same rules would not apply.

There's this thing, a skill mayhaps, called 'Trolling'. The act of trolling is simply making ignorant and highly objectionable comments which bait a user into flying off the handle at you. Now, when being trolled, people can become ridiculously angry and make many remarks that they perhaps would not have said otherwise.

It's stuff like that that you have to take into account before mindlessly judging the vast majority of our users.
Click to expand...

The fact I made was that teenagers lack experience, and even if they may have a cool head or fair understanding of certain matters, they are all slaves to their innate teenage hormones-- the likes of which cause pointless fighting, arguing, etc, the list goes on.

You should read what you write before you post it, lest you sound stupid, because by your definition of trolling, you're trolling. You're making an 'ignorant and highly objectionable' response by using a sweeping generalization about the entire internet/human race, which isn't even about the topic at hand.
 
Vegavak said:
The fact I made was that teenagers lack experience, and even if they may have a cool head or fair understanding of certain matters, they are all slaves to their innate teenage hormones-- the likes of which cause pointless fighting, arguing, etc, the list goes on.
Click to expand...

Having spent most of the last week speaking almost exclusively to teenagers of vastly superior intellect to the majority of the population...no. Just no.

We are not slaves to our innate teenage hormones any more than you are to your evolutionary imbued sense of fear at the younger generation.
 
Captain Griffen said:
Having spent most of the last week speaking almost exclusively to teenagers of vastly superior intellect to the majority of the population...no. Just no.

We are not slaves to our innate teenage hormones any more than you are to your evolutionary imbued sense of fear at the younger generation.
Click to expand...

Good argument.

If you really wish to be perceived as someone of vastly superior intellect, why not simply display the fact, rather than proclaim it? A phrase involving the words bark and bite comes to mind. And while you seem to have trouble understanding it, the 'majority of the population' did not receive the same standard of education the youth of today have, so it's no mystery as to why they're not as intellectually inclined.

Just as the old man cannot stop growing older, the teenager cannot stop just the same.

Perhaps the next time you respond, you will give it a little more thought.
 
You judge teenagers because of hormones? Okay, well, why would you pick an adult? They'd be busy working all of the time unless they have some cubicle job where they can just sit on the internet all day (like Office Space, well TPS reports first of course).

I think you just need to shutup about things you don't know. Especially when you make blanket statements like "all teenagers have hormones and that's the problem with them" and then you dis-credit someone else for making other blanket statements.

newb
 
En_Fuego said:
You judge teenagers because of hormones? Okay, well, why would you pick an adult? They'd be busy working all of the time unless they have some cubicle job where they can just sit on the internet all day (like Office Space, well TPS reports first of course).

I think you just need to shutup about things you don't know. Especially when you make blanket statements like "all teenagers have hormones and that's the problem with them" and then you dis-credit someone else for making other blanket statements.

newb
Click to expand...

I observed behaviors within a group and explained the common cause linking that behavior together.

To answer your question: I do not primarily judge based on age, but how a person acts. Certain ages have corresponding faults, and should a person of a certain age group show it- it likely may be because of their corresponding age. Such as your response to mine. Such as children begin pretending, teenagers go through puberty, and old men start to forget.

I understand why you're reacting this way, but here's a tip: When you want to argue against what I've said- you argue against what I've said- not how I've said it, how old I am, or your misconceptions of both. If you truly believe what I've said is wrong- then prove it.
 
I think Griffen's mistaken here. Of course there are examples of teenagers that are brilliant, more so than any of us, but that doesn't make them the majority. On the whole, the teenage population is stricken with angst, as observed by people who make it their careers to do so.

Not that what teenagers on the whole are like matters in the least to moderators, but I felt like contributing. :)
 
I seriously hope you are not implying that the solution to this problem is to replace the entire teenage portion of the staff with adults.

Call me ill informed, but I doubt that would work. I seriously do not see the dominant age group as the main problem in this situation.
 
Good argument.

If you really wish to be perceived as someone of vastly superior intellect, why not simply display the fact, rather than proclaim it? A phrase involving the words bark and bite comes to mind. And while you seem to have trouble understanding it, the 'majority of the population' did not receive the same standard of education the youth of today have, so it's no mystery as to why they're not as intellectually inclined.

Just as the old man cannot stop growing older, the teenager cannot stop just the same.

Perhaps the next time you respond, you will give it a little more thought.
Click to expand...

My real actual education was largely done by other teenagers. Thanks to adults the UK school education system of today is in many ways crap compared to years ago. And no, you wouldn't be Oxford student level even if you had had an education of today.

I observed behaviors within a group and explained the common cause linking that behavior together.
Click to expand...

Great, let's all go lock up black teenagers as criminal scum then...

To answer your question: I do not primarily judge based on age, but how a person acts. Certain ages have corresponding faults, and should a person of a certain age group show it- it likely may be because of their corresponding age. Such as your response to mine. Such as children begin pretending, teenagers go through puberty, and old men start to forget.
Click to expand...

This is the internet, your prejudices and collective punishment have no place in it.

I understand why you're reacting this way, but here's a tip: When you want to argue against what I've said- you argue against what I've said- not how I've said it, how old I am, or your misconceptions of both. If you truly believe what I've said is wrong- then prove it.
Click to expand...

You know what happens when people start presuming things about people because of what others did? Injustice. When we treat one person differently because of the actions of another, injustice is taking place, as they are not receiving their dessert, but someone else's.

Rising_Dusk said:
I think Griffen's mistaken here. Of course there are examples of teenagers that are brilliant, more so than any of us, but that doesn't make them the majority.
Click to expand...

Depends on where you are. For me, it be true.
 
Steel_Stallion said:
I seriously hope you are not implying that the solution to this problem is to replace the entire teenage portion of the staff with adults.

Call me ill informed, but I doubt that would work. I seriously do not see the dominant age group as the main problem in this situation.
Click to expand...

It's not about a dominant age group, it's about the traits of that age group that are shown to be a chaotic constant throughout their years in it. This isn't some assumption, presumption or anything near the like- this is widely accepted fact. Teenagers are teenagers, and you couldn't stop them from being teenagers, even if you tried. Hence, problems with moderation, or idiots posting rubbish under their own personal ruse of brilliance, or wrongful defense.

Captain Griffen said:
Great, let's all go lock up black teenagers as criminal scum then...

This is the internet, your prejudices and collective punishment have no place in it.
Click to expand...

Hahaha, what?
 
Vegavak said:
It's not about a dominant age group, it's about the traits of that age group that are shown to be a chaotic constant throughout their years in it. This isn't some assumption, presumption or anything near the like- this is widely accepted fact. Teenagers are teenagers, and you couldn't stop them from being teenagers, even if you tried. Hence, problems with moderation, or idiots posting rubbish under their own personal ruse of brilliance, or wrongful defense.
Click to expand...

It was a widely accepted fact in Germany that Jews were inferior. So that makes it true? No. So stop trying to argue from "everyone knows that..." - it's the refuge of hate mongerers the world over.

That you think you can't stop teenagers being teenagers is just so laughable. Really, go learn some history. Teenager as anything other than an adult is a pretty new concept.

Do you even read your posts before you post them? Do you even read the posts you respond to before you reply to them? These are two key things you need to work on before you post again.
Click to expand...

You need to work on making it logical.
 
Captain Griffen said:
It was a widely accepted fact in Germany that Jews were inferior. So that makes it true? No. So stop trying to argue from "everyone knows that..." - it's the refuge of hate mongerers the world over.

That you think you can't stop teenagers being teenagers is just so laughable. Really, go learn some history. Teenager as anything other than an adult is a pretty new concept.

You need to work on making it logical.
Click to expand...

Teenagers go through puberty, yes? What do teenagers have all throughout their years? An influx of hormones, that's right. Now, what do hormones do? Are you still not following, Oxford?

Pump anyone full of testosterone and they will be more aggressive and exhibit the traits I have stated previously. You cannot prove me wrong.
 
Vegavak said:
Teenagers go through puberty, yes? What do teenagers have all throughout their years? An influx of hormones, that's right. Now, what do hormones do? Are you still not following, Oxford?

Pump anyone full of testosterone and they will be more aggressive and exhibit the traits I have stated previously. You cannot prove me wrong.
Click to expand...

Just because you're nothing more than a wild beast, incapable of overcoming your evolutionary instincts, doesn't mean you should tar everyone else with your own failings.

Man is more than beast.
 
I could make a rather well-made essay about how communism is playing a detrimental factor to this site, and it wouldn't really matter if no one actually presents a viable solution.

So there are too many teenage moderators. Well-mannered, mature adults who frequent this site and are willing to become moderators aren't tripped over every day, and having teenage moderators is arguably better than having no moderators at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

loktar
  • Locked
  • Poll Poll
Community Approved Resources?
Replies
5
Views
2K
General Frank
General Frank
Bob27
  • Locked
Looking for Moderators
Replies
20
Views
3K
Malufa
Malufa
The_Raven
  • Locked
Section Sub-Moderators and a “Rejected” Section
Replies
25
Views
3K
Kerrigan
Kerrigan
InfernalTater
  • Locked
A slight amendment to the resource moderation process
Replies
2
Views
2K
Ralle
Ralle
Xlightscreen
  • Locked
  • Poll Poll
Vote to reinstate mini-moderators!
2
Replies
52
Views
6K
Archangel_Tidusx
Archangel_Tidusx
Back
Top