Frozen Throne Poll

[Rui]

This is the poll for
Terraining Challenge's Mini-Contest
The Frozen Throne

The objective of this mini-contest was to create the last scene on the final movie (the one looking at the Throne)

Visit the poll of the real challenge here.

View attachment 14257

View attachment 14256

View attachment 14258

 

[Mor)L(unE]

My vote goes to madsen, simply because hes the best

 

[HeretoDLstuff]

I dunno....Madsens looks most like the real thing but I think jaakko's looks better...

 

[Rui]

I clearly vote for MadseN on this one.

KingBob - Pretty good, except for the height of the Throne, but w/e. If not for the sky and the overheight, I might have voted for yours.
Jaakko - The only one who actually bothered with chains, though it turned out to be not-so-ok because of their angle. I never saw a penguin on the Frozen Throne anyway. Bad camera angle. The stairs were cool and all, but you missed the point.
MadseN - Although you could have come up with a glow on the Throne, yours was the best because of the camera's distance and angle. The weather effect and sky also fit quite well. You get my vote.

 

[Jaakko]

You could have commented earlier and I would have fixed those. But I still like the penguin and the chains.

 

[KKRP]

KingBob's is to tall, but good.

Jaakko's is good, a little short though.

MadseN's is the best because of the size and distance it is from the Throne.

 

[MadseN]

My vote went to kingbob, the picture could have been mush better what it really is atm with some more time.

Anyway, god Job ppl

I used a old version of UTM so i diden't have any glow/cloud models

 

[Gilles]

I think I'm going to vote for MadseN, it was tough though. Jakkos was pretty cool!

 

[UchihaSasuke.gr]

MadseN is truly great!Maybe the best!He gets my vote!

KingBob:
Pretty good.The height was too much though!

Jakkoo:The 2nd best.I really liked the sky and the little penguin!

MadseN:Actions speak louder than words...

 

[HeretoDLstuff]

Sry, double post.

[offtopic]You can delet your posts. When your editing you have the option to delet it, after you click "Go advanced".[/offtopic]

 

[MadseN]

great thank you

/MadseN

 

[r0x_yo_s0x]

KingBob got my vote. Seems like his fit the scene the best, but I agree it's a little on the tall side.

The angle setting and the surrounding environment in MadseN's entry look great, but I think the spire is a little too wide.

Jaakko's was very good, but chains (while they are there) kind of killed it. Very nice touch with the penguin, though.

 

[Pitakebab]

Somehow I think Jaakko has the best... It has chains etc.

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

Madsen wins the intarnets.

 

[UchihaSasuke.gr]

Lol,I forgot to vote.xD

 

[FallenDarkness]

Kingbob's is good, much better than anything I could do, it is a bit tall though and I don't like the model for the stairs, they are too... wooden. The steps in the video were like crystal/ice steps, more like Jaakko's.

Jaakko's I liked cause of the chains no doubt, the steps are in more right for it, and the spire is the right height. However then I saw Madsen's.

Madsen got my vote, not because of the camera distance, but because of the atmosphere. It cried Death, Eerieness, and Terror. It makes you feel more like you are at the spire. Not the mention the terrain surrounding it was amazing, I liked the broken bridge, and the fog/mist around it was an amazing touch; even though the Spire was a bit wide.

Overall though, I think they are all brilliant, however I can only choose one. =(

 

[Rui]

You pretty much read my mind. MadseN's ambient was... simply undead.

 

[PurplePoot]

I especially like the details, such as the fallen bridge to the left, in MadseN's.

Jaako's was good too, but especially the chains made me not like it as much - the fact that they were inverted just looked awkward.

KingBob's was very nice in terms of its staircase, but I also have to say that Jaako's and KingBob's seemed a lot more like light and happy places (as far as it goes in that sort of climate), and not eerie and evil places. MadseN's terrain captured the atmosphere perfectly.

 

[NearbyHermit]

Madsen has a good Frozen Throne,more like the real one,but King Bobs is cool because it looks like Barad-Dhur from Lotr,on wich WC3 and LOTR a quite the same

And just for this simple look-a-like he gets my vote

 

[Belgarath]

I say Jaakko's looks the best. It has an awesome atmosphere - the FT not at night and actually just frozen looking; he also was the only one with chains. Also, the way the light shines onto the scene is simply AWESOME.
MadseN's looks a bit too much like the FT, so it's not too new : /
Kingbob's was nice, but all the work was put into the stairs and the bottom of the throne, it seems, so it's still nice, but, yeah.

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

MadseN's looks a bit too much like the FT, so it's not too new : /

That tends to be the point of an emulation. If I was told to play a musical piece made by another person, I wouldn't rewrite it so it sounds better in my opinion.

Just wanted to throw that out.

 

[Rui]

Poll time over. MadseN is the winner of the Frozen Throne mini-challenge. Congrats'.

 

[MadseN]

Thank you Rui Was a fun challenge, can't wait for the next one

/MadseN