• Check out the results of the Techtree Contest #19!
  • Listen to a special audio message from Bill Roper to the Hive Workshop community (Bill is a former Vice President of Blizzard Entertainment, Producer, Designer, Musician, Voice Actor) 🔗Click here to hear his message!
  • Read Evilhog's interview with Gregory Alper, the original composer of the music for WarCraft: Orcs & Humans 🔗Click here to read the full interview.
  • Create a void inspired texture for Warcraft 3 and enter Hive's 34th Texturing Contest: Void! Click here to enter!
  • The Hive's 22nd Icon Contest: Creep Abilities is now concluded, time to vote for your favourite set of icons! Click here to vote!

[Cinematic] cinematic section seems to be dying?

cinematics

  • i agree the cinematic map section seems to be dying

    Votes: 29 34.9%

  • yer its dying and having a cinematic contest would be awsome

    Votes: 47 56.6%

  • cinematics are boring........

    Votes: 11 13.3%

  • some cinematics are fun to watch

    Votes: 22 26.5%

  • the cinematic map section isent dead what are you talking about

    Votes: 7 8.4%

  • Im going to make a cinematic

    Votes: 14 16.9%

  • it be good to see what you can do with the battle cinematics

    Votes: 12 14.5%

  • you should do somthing with your cinematic series (revenge of the blademaster)

    Votes: 12 14.5%
  • Total voters
    83
Status
Not open for further replies.

millzy

millzy

millzy

Level 15
Joined
Jul 9, 2008
Messages
1,553
i feel that the cinematic section is dying.

i like seeing cinematics mayby the hive should have another cinematic contest.

i sort of feel like putting out battle cinematics like orc vs human then night elf vs orc or somthing like that.

there are like no cinematic series any more
 
"yer its dying and having a cinematic contest would be awsome"...This is my oppinion...yes the cinematic makers should continue their great work...and a contest to stimulate this would be more than great
 
I feel like it was never really THAT alive. Cinematics aren't really a niche that all that many mappers fall into and stay in, and the community isn't as big as it once was.

At the same time, if you can get the interest generated, it would be nice to see more activity. A contest would be nice, though whoever hosts it would want to make sure to present it well and keep it updated nicely to avoid it falling through.
 
A cinematic contest isn't possible, in my opinion. The last "successful" contest had two entries, from me and Hemlock, both of whom have pretty much forsaken the W3 universe.

Warcraft 3 is dying in general. The cinematics are the first to go, I guess.
 
well, True, almost all things galaxy has can still be done in World editor, but its just easier to be done in Galaxy editor.

anyways, cinematic isn't that much popular compared to multiplayer map, since mostly is not interactable, nor is it multiplayable, there is lesser fun in it, and it can never be as Famous as multiplayer maps.

but i see the only fun thing a cinematic has, compared to other maps, its just that they are missing interaction, if we could make choices, or doing the battle scenes with something interactable, cinematic will be a whole new popular genre.
 
Such cinematics do exist.
Here's one for example.

Also the galaxy editor is definitely way better than the warcraft 3 editor. Why?
-Advanced Object editor (Don't whine now, it may look a bit complicated, but you will quickly understand everything)
-Advanced GUI (UI, more unit control,...)
-Better terrain editor
-You can actually elevate the terrain with triggers now
There are just too many pluses.
 
Even so, it's still the galaxy editor and until a huge amount of models appear to provide us with different settings other than space and aliens that's the only thing it'll be.

As for the cinematic you've mentioned, it's older than several of my cinematics, and my cinematics are quite old now.
 
I believe that, with CMarket's series, people were inspired. I remember seeing more original (and somewhat good) work after the Sect of the Holy Mother was completed. Now, I feel that people have perhaps lost that inspiration. The flux of new work has decreased again since then -- of that I am sure.
 
I don't agree that it's dying though, it's just that it's hard to find people who make cinematics only, but I'm sure as the time passes more and more people would come, one of my friends is making one too and plans to post his one soon(:
 
Well, it's not a matter of opinion as much as it is a matter of fact. The cinematic section is dying, there's no question about it. Most, if not all experienced, veteran cinematographers have left and there aren't nearly enough new ones to take their place. Moreover, with SC2 out (not to mention New Vegas, AC Brotherhood and other new, brilliant games) and the lack of anything new and original in the cinematic section people are simply starting to shun this whole field of warcraft mapping.
 
Then I say it's time to make this Cinematic Section liven up again, who's up for the contest, which I bet will make Warcraft III Cinematics more popular than playing any of the above games if we do it well enough(:
 
GhostThruster said:
Cinematics... you realise that they aren't really even that relevant to Wc3? Wc3 WE was designed to make 'normal' maps, not full-scale Cinematics anyways.
Click to expand...

Wrong. Completely wrong, in fact. I'd say something else, but it'd be considered flaming.

The WE has several sections of it's code specifically designed for cinematics. The environment, lighting and camera tab of the GUI, though used elsewhere are mostly for cinematics. The cinematics tab is designed only for cinematics. Cinematics play a large part in the campaign and in map making. They are also the only real source of art in the map making world. While other maps rely mostly on gameplay, some on story, the cinematics rely solely on art, be it terrain, camera work, story or special effects. Usually all those combined.
 
Wc3 WE was designed to make 'normal' maps, not full-scale Cinematics anyways.

Yes, I know what cinematics are and rely on. I myself like cinematics, but I'm just stating the truth. Wc3 was made to hold cinematics in maps, not cinematics as maps. Cinematics are supposed to be short cutscenes, like in the campaign. They're not supposed to be the map itself. It is a user-created art. So, if that's the case, then there wouldn't be much cinematic-makers in the first place.
 
I Guess the editor is too primitive to just continue working with it. The cinematics aren't supposed to be long anyway, and there aren't supposed to be it's own individual maps. But still, from time to time, I stumble across a great Cinematic, such as the series of cinematics "Bloodline" (Watching it since the first one was made), and that's enough reason why continuing doing them. The creator surely is supposed to play around with the editor for like good 5 months before he can make a "Good" cinematic.
Well, If you ask me for my honest opinion, I'd rather start learning making real cut-scenes / cinematics (Such like the ones in the next-gen games), using Maya/3dsmax/whatever.
 
well, CMarket, this might sound weird but I'm still waiting for you to continue lonely Panter ^^
 
It's be great to attract more of Cinematic Lovers though, they'll sure spice up the mapping experience!

PS: @Crapther - I head they will, lets be patient and wait(:
 
I bet is someone got bored enough they would make a full on 1 hour movie with WE.
Though you are right this section is pretty dead now
 
a one hour movie made in WE would suck, cinematic in WC3 are good because they are short and well many other things, but if you make them to long it becomes annoying and boring very fast. thats why people make cinematic series on not just full length movies.
 
Heh, Unfortunately you're wrong Vengeancekael, a friend of mine knows a Blizzard employee who mentions that Blizzard would bring many updates to the World Editor along with a Battle.Net patch, I heard it was pretty nice. So do expect this section to be blooming anytime soon!
 
Miss_Foxy said:
Heh, Unfortunately you're wrong Vengeancekael, a friend of mine knows a Blizzard employee who mentions that Blizzard would bring many updates to the World Editor along with a Battle.Net patch, I heard it was pretty nice. So do expect this section to be blooming anytime soon!
Click to expand...

That's one of the stupidest things I've ever heard. Either your friend is lying or the "employee" is lying. Blizzard didn't update the game itself (by which I mean bring new content) for a very very very long time. Not to mention the fact that even if new content was introduced they wouldn't and more importantly couldn't update the WE in such a manner that it makes things interesting and new again.

Finally, even if all of the above was false, Blizzard would never bring significant content to the cinematic part of warcraft mapping.

If Blizzard knows one thing, it's how to profit in the gaming industry. This move wouldn't bring any profits.
 
Miss_Foxy said:
Heh, Unfortunately you're wrong Vengeancekael, a friend of mine knows a Blizzard employee who mentions that Blizzard would bring many updates to the World Editor along with a Battle.Net patch, I heard it was pretty nice. So do expect this section to be blooming anytime soon!
Click to expand...

This may happen but i think it would be together with a Warcraft 4 if it ever comes.

Cinematics can be good but warcraft 3 is just in my opinion not a good tool to make cinematics in. Besides that cinematics (in my opinion) tend to get boring if they are not made very well with camera and action on the screen.

Also a big minus for making a cinematic in wc3 is that its hard to make it "alive". You would need some voice actors before you can make a really good cinematic and if you can't do it yourself some very good terrainers and maybe even moddellers.

Making a cinematic in wc3 is just... complicated.
 
I doubt they are lying though, because even small changes like increasing the map size limits would be reasonable. Anyways, a cinematic contest would be great to bring out our movie makers(:
 
yeah, i hope so, my RPG cant be played, its over the size limit, so i stopped my project.

someone, tell blizzard!! Please..lol..

and i hope they fixed hashtable.

well, the cinematic section seems to be dying?..

then "its time to even the scales" isn't it mapmakers? :P
 
TheWarchief said:
This may happen but i think it would be together with a Warcraft 4 if it ever comes.

Cinematics can be good but warcraft 3 is just in my opinion not a good tool to make cinematics in. Besides that cinematics (in my opinion) tend to get boring if they are not made very well with camera and action on the screen.

Also a big minus for making a cinematic in wc3 is that its hard to make it "alive". You would need some voice actors before you can make a really good cinematic and if you can't do it yourself some very good terrainers and maybe even moddellers.

Making a cinematic in wc3 is just... complicated.
Click to expand...


Warcraft IV wont ever exist. The continuation of the Warcraft Universe is WOW, and it went so damm well that I dont think theyll even think of Warcraft IV.


@Miss_Foxy na dude, they won't ever update it. Ever. They would be wasting time, for the updates must be free, and they wouldn't gain anything. If Blizzard doesn't gain in an activity, it is not done. Period.
 
Craphter said:
Warcraft IV wont ever exist. The continuation of the Warcraft Universe is WOW, and it went so damm well that I dont think theyll even think of Warcraft IV.
Click to expand...

That's just not true. WoW, while being constantly improved has the same 10 year old engine to work with. Warcraft 4 is quite a possible reality, though we'll have to wait a year or two more for it to be announced alone, and then another ten (as Blizzard has a habit of doing) for it to be released.
 
Craphter said:
Warcraft IV wont ever exist. The continuation of the Warcraft Universe is WOW, and it went so damm well that I dont think theyll even think of Warcraft IV.


@Miss_Foxy na dude, they won't ever update it. Ever. They would be wasting time, for the updates must be free, and they wouldn't gain anything. If Blizzard doesn't gain in an activity, it is not done. Period.
Click to expand...

They did say they'll make an RTS after WoW in order to put the storyline straight after The Emerald Dream though, so we could expect a Warcraft IV sometime later.
Anyways, back to topic, should we make a thread for a contest?
 
ive been working on the Bloodline a little bit here and there.. but im no where near as dedicated as in the earlier episodes. im not as inspired to do wc3 mapping as i was when i started and i find little reason to be, other than the few fans im sorry to say this to.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Aeroblyctos
  • Locked
[Cinematic] My own cinematics
Replies
5
Views
2K
Lord_of_sausage
Lord_of_sausage
Hemlock
  • Locked
  • Poll Poll
Orcish Castery Released
Replies
1
Views
1K
Hemlock
Hemlock
Bob27
  • Locked
[Cinematic] Cinematic Mini-Contest #1
4 5 6
Replies
258
Views
38K
Bob27
Bob27
millzy
  • Locked
Cinematic: no name (yet) looking for tips help and some ideas
Replies
0
Views
899
millzy
millzy
Total_Warrior
  • Locked
[Cinematic] Shark Cinematic
Replies
6
Views
9K
Galagoz
Galagoz
Back
Top