Moderator
M
Moderator
19:34, 3rd Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Approved
Update: re-moderating with rating and review
ap0calypse: Approved
Update: re-moderating with rating and review
Reasons: Other: If you have any complaints or questions directed towards a moderator, make a thread here: Map Resource Moderation If you think the moderator's judging is unfair or you have overall complaints, make a thread here: Admin Contact Comment: Terrain : There isn't much to say about the terrain, since it looks magnificent. Gameplay : The terrain is magnificent, however the map lacks a lot of things, first off, not a lot of custom spells at all, for example the silencer doesn't have any custom spells. Another thing is that there aren't a lot of events. Items : Because of the new system, you have removed all the items and implemented just 2 for testing. They're ok, but the item descriptions are a disaster, it's just so long and believe me, no one will read it, it's just unreadable. Other : First of all, there's too much text in the screen and the color selection is bad, I mean like 3 sentences with 3 different colors? Also, don't use the red color. Another thing, heroes gain exp too slowly, making it a bit boring. Bosses come too soon, the heroes are not ready yet, thus they can't kill it so fast. The help quests are also not readable, use custom colors and shorten the sentences if possible. Also, when some players are missing, the leaderboard is just empty, just decrease its rows. Also, the silencer is not a good hero at all, his spells are not custom and he's more of a dota hero and herovshero map. Bugs : Sometimes the bosses get paused permanently. Hiveworkshop : You have written an acceptable description for the map and you are not breaking any rules. Overall : I guess this is a neat map, yet there are a lot of things lacking and originality-wise, not so good. |