Something that manages to please a larger number of people is objectively better.
Yes, it's better in that it pleases more people but that doesn't equal great quality. Please...
And no, having 30 votes with that as average is not enough.
There are few projects which actually are lucky enough to get even that many votes. Members don't vote that often and most people that download don't even have an account. Others just give +rep or leave a comment and that's it.
Otherwise every project with at least one guy who likes it would be hosted because it's amazing to him/her.
I wasn't referring to that. Besides, I don't think I heard of such a thing. When something is made public, it gets various opinions because, you know, more than one person exists on this planet.
I am sure you can find some weird psycho that finds killing enjoyable, that does not make killing great does it?
Depends on the terms we're discussing. In terms of insanity and killing it might be great, I wouldn't know. I don't have that passion.
Listen, food is also great by your example because it satisfies people but don't forget the crappy food that tastes good, is maybe cheaper and is not healthy at all.
f a whole lot of people (hundreds of thousands) can enjoy something, it's obviously good. Even if not for me personally.
Not for you? Well, in the end it matters to you, not to them. If they like it and you don't, you don't gain anything. If they like hitting their heads on the wall, does that make it good?
Also, I and many other fans like the Warcraft movie. That doesn't make it a great movie.
I don't know about you, but I cannot see any other active project that would be able to
fulfil this task.
Exactly. What I'm trying to write is, that all active projects should be looked over and eventually inserted in the Hosted Projects forum/list if deemed fit.