Post your map here for an In-Depth Review

Hi! can you review my map =)
Map TMA

 

School likes to bite me in the ass. Oh, and the fact that I've basically abandoned wc3 lately...

 

Achievement TD

If you haven't COMPLETELY abandoned TFT, a review of this would be cool . I'd like to know what you think I need to work on, cause I've kind of hit a blank spot in developing this map.

 

, yeah they do that with more students

 

Dark Revenant. Why do you allow people to submit to you maps that are unfinished? The creators even know they are unfinished and yet still pile you with a list of unworthy material. It is a shame that you are wasting time on this. I suggest you skip unfinished maps altogether, or maps that are less than version 1.

 

Yeah, playing that retarded SPAM CHICKENS game...

Oh and your clan leader noticed me... weird...

 

Question about few things. I am working on a game , and i may get done with it soon (1 or 2 months maybe).
To me a good review means a alot, as i feel it will have a impact on my game.
So i am trying to better understand what you mean with your rating system.

What do you mean by this?

Base Rating

Immersive - Does this mean, like how much you feel you are in the game. Like the environment and everything seems of the same tone (sorta speak).
Like if it were a dungeon game you wouldn't see the energizer bunny runner throw it?
Can you give me any more detail on this?

Optimized - Does this mean there is no noticeable in game? and no major leaks or no leaks what so ever?
Anything else for optimized?

Merits

Small File Size - How small for both merits? How small for one? Does it depend on the game?
Good cut scenes - Is a cut scene something you see as a clip that you watch in game? like a intro clip from a game like Uther party.

Demerits

No Documentation - None in Quest menu? or No Change log .txt file attached in zip?
Bad Imports - No idea what you mean, this mean poor quality imports?

 

while i agree some of these maps he shouldn't waste time on reviewing i don't think that just because a map is unfinished it's unworthy for him to review it. this is the map development forum so none of the maps should be completed if they are in here. if any of them are above version 1 in fact they should not be reviewed here. you've got it backwards.

anyway it sounds like it might be time for someone else to come along and offer to do what he was doing since school has become a lot of work for him lately...either that or we just need to wait until his season of hard work at school is over...

 

Eh i mostly agree with you.

But i think its here because its to when you go to release your game after you done some testing. and just about release it , this is the last step basically someone to run throw out your game to make sure everything is as good as you would like it. and then from what he says , if you agree with him you change your game and then let it fly.

so in other words your both wrong, and i am right (lol just kidding)

 

well and it kindof sounded to me like if he gave the map a good review then you could use that to help make the map more popular...that's what i was really hoping for...

 

cool thread

i hope you want to review my map, dark

Battle Rumble 2.2 - The Hive Workshop - A Warcraft III Modding Site

thanks

 

With my school load and multitude of non-wc3-related mods I'm committed to, I can't find the time for this anymore. I'm sorry.

 

That sucks... schools seem to enjoy cutting more than they should out of peoples' lives. Often.

 

Since the author no longer has time for this, I'll be closing the thread.
~Thread locked