Please fix broken Hive post links

Level 13
Joined
Sep 4, 2008
Messages
300
I saw that http links were recently replaced in bulk, fixing a lot of image problems, so I figured now was the time to finally request this other link bugfix. I've encountered it from the day I came back to the site a couple months ago, all the way through today.

There are a bunch of links that I guess broke when threads switched over from having like 20 posts per page to 50 or w/e.

I typically encounter this problem with links within a thread (like contained in a top post) that are meant to link to another post later in that same thread; but the problem seems to be with all links from maybe 2019 or earlier. The problem manifests by the link going to the very top of another page probably about 2.5x further than the link intends, often resulting in going "past" the end of the thread and defaulting back to the last page of the thread. Regardless of the page, the links all just end up at the top of some page, not at any specific post that they're intended to link to.

It makes looking through old contest threads particularly grueling, since the links are useless, forcing you to just look through the entire thread for each final entry (which is even harder if entrants' usernames have since changed).

A couple random examples:
Techtree Contest #13: All the Entry links in the table* in this top post just jump to the top of the last page of the thread
Techtree Contest #11: Same
*table is located near the bottom of the top post

This problem exists all throughout the site, not just in contest threads (example below).


Broken links should be replaced like this:

Broken: https://www.hiveworkshop.com/threads/heavens-fall-melee-gameplay-mod.221137/post-2397186

Can be fixed by converting to this: https://www.hiveworkshop.com/threads/heavens-fall-melee-gameplay-mod.221137/post-2397186

This to me looks like something that can be replaced automatically, so it should be an easy and very impactful fix. 🙏
 
Last edited:
Sounds good. To be honest, I was making fun of myself. If I were Ralle, I would not connect an AI with administrative access and no oversight to Hive. Maybe this was a way for me to vent versus something about my day job.

I concur, would be very nice to have accurate links maintained. I always really appreciated when Hive would snapshot an off-site image and keep images up even when the original source link died. I've been guilty of that a few times on my stuff.

Makes sense to try to maintain simple links internal to Hive just as well.
 
Fixed, thanks for the report. I know there will be more broken links in there.

I just did some searching to find how the links looked if it was on page 1 and fixed that too. Let me know if you find more. I am not afraid of a little production search / replace.
I just tested the Entry links in the contest threads I linked in the OP, and they're still broken.

Example:
Raw link The Xetkin Clan [Red] (from Entry table): https://www.hiveworkshop.com/threads/techtree-contest-13-coloured-mana-optionally-paired.317856/post-3375095
Currently redirects to (Broken): https://www.hiveworkshop.com/threads/techtree-contest-13-coloured-mana-optionally-paired.317856/post-3375095
Should be fixed to this: https://www.hiveworkshop.com/threads/techtree-contest-13-coloured-mana-optionally-paired.317856/post-3375095

(that is, removing the page-7 and #)

Thanks for addressing this!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top