- Joined
- Apr 11, 2009
- Messages
- 1,456
Did I accuse you of accusing him of doing that? That was a general statement.Pharaoh_ said:Did I say that he is breaking any rules?
Could you elaborate on a)?Pharaoh_ said:And by the way, there should be no 'deadline', because a) that will show people that they are willing to withdraw whenever they feel like it (with no specific reason - "I am bored of giving a review" is not an excuse, really - you were supposed to know what your task of judging was, in the first place), b) you shouldn't apply as a judge, if you are unsure of what it takes to actually judge.
I don't see how a defined deadline for possible judges to withdraw themselves shows contestants their will of doing so. It would merely be a nice "think before you apply" pointer. Getting accepted as a judge is not necessarily binding, so a defined deadline would make sense.