WW3 Battle of the Gods V2.57

[Moderator]

22:52, 8th Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

 

[mouseman89]

improve description please, will test it later.

 

[light bolt30]

Fix up description; how to play, special features, credits, storyline, etc. Also add screenshots and a custom preview screen if you want to attract more people.

 

[Zenonoth]

Your map is really good, If you mind..I'd like to suggest improving the terrain, also I had a little bug, when I used the Workshops' Research ability it spawned many Medivhs instead of bringing me gold or lumber, I don't know if it's meant to be like this, anyways..4/5

 

[Spoontoobig]

Europe doesn't look like this! :> And where is Lithuania ?! :///

 

[Hawk]

Is this Europe? This defently don't look like Europe...I think on THW there is alredy Europe terrain somewhere.

 

[Shimitar]

Alright, time to answer some comments:
1. I will work on description when i have free time.
2. Interesting, ill look into that bug. It is supposed to give you lumber. Also, i said in description that i made terrain while still a novice at mapmaking, so its gonna take some time to remake all that.
3. To the two last comments, yes this is Europe. i know the geography isnt right. See explanation above. Besides, i made this map not for geographic or historical accuracy, but for gameplay.

Edit: Spotted the error, its the wharehouse thats supposed to have that ability, the comercial factory simply grants gold every minute or so.

 

[Tau Empire]

Well World War 3 is no easy task to make but here's what I got right now when playing this game

1. Grammar Errors
2. Icon Error (Main Battle Tank)
3. Raw Material is Lumber but it still says Lumber on top...
4. Make the team names work atleast (You can't have 2 USA and 2 Great Britains...)
5. Make some national (exclusive) units like Abrams Tank, Leopard 2 MBT, Paladin Mobile Artillery etc...
6. You can't say you cannot find any models for your map cause I see many models that can be placed in your map.
7. I was hoping with a title like Battle of the Gods there would be some kind of magic into it like Age of Mythology or something o well.
8. Rename some of the research... how can you research Modern Technology seriously?
9. Put some oil spots at least before I wasted my wood and gold on oil ships.
10. Already said but change Lumber to Raw Materials (by going in the Gameplay Interface menu under the Advanced tab)

Grammar Error list: Chineese Japaneese (Chinese, Japanese) Wharehouse (Warehouse), vaerious (various)

If you need help with anything just ask.

 

[Tleno]

You should actually add some immports to the map. Those marines, esspecially with change RB colours are ugly, you could immport more of infantry models for the variety.

 

[Shimitar]

There actually used to be oil spots but i removed them to add income.

 

[Fingolfin]

It is funny how this map sets in the future, yet the world depiction kinda looks like taken from a map of the middle ages

Anyway, that abrams tank model is awesome. But that is propably the only good thing i can see from this map so far, the trolls blend in really badly, and what's up with "research tower"? That doesn't make sense.

 

[Shimitar]

1.See explanation above (again) for map.
2.You dont have the latest version, i made a new one replacing the models ofmany units, such as trolls.
3.I needed a name for a third research building, and i dont see whats wrong with the name. All youve done is jugde looks. WHy dont you try gameplay?

 

[Tleno]

Well, here's the gameplay issue: All the units don't seem to be so original. Actually they just have different damage/attack speed, hp and model. And cost. And you can win a game just by sppamming a lot of one type. And ideas how to make more differences between different units?
Oh, and here's the research names:
-Research Facility
-Research Center
-Research Complex

And terrain is really bad.

 

[Shimitar]

1. Units tend to balance each other out. RPGs are great against a tank army with their high damage, but their low hp makes them weak against massed riflemen. Massed riflemen are in turn easy to slaughter with an army of machinegunners.
2. Alright, i will take those names into acount and forget them imediatly.
3. You all seem to enjoy bringing up comments that were already said/answered. I started this map when i was a novice at mapmaking, its gonna take a while to remake it all.

 

[Fingolfin]

balance is not all about damage, you should start using things like armor types and attack types, unless you do already.
Their values can be edited through "advanced>gameplay constants".

 

[Ironside]

Information:


As a Reviewer of the Map Reviewers Group, I joined the THW Cleaning Event.
I end up writing a fast review, or just posting the end state of the map, rating is not always included!


Current State for this map: Rejected


I will contact the moderator to Approve/Reject the map, depending on what you recieved.