Terrain Contest 6 - Poll

[frostwhisper]

This thread is one big whiny TL;DR. Don't think any of us judges give a fuck about what you say

 

[HFR]

I wish I could be a judge, them I'll consider the theme until TEH END!!!

 

[Celaquil]

When do the poll end? And when do we see the judges decitions?

 

[frostwhisper]

Sewn.

 

[HFR]

The poll ends in 5/1/3969. About the judges, well, I think Gilles already chose his favorite...

 

[Wolfhelm]

This thread is one big whiny TL;DR. Don't think any of us judges give a fuck about what you say

I wasnt whining, i suppose you dont agree with my logical, rationaly thought out argument with valid points. If so you fail as a judge and your oppinion is worthless to me.

 

[Pyritie]

I honestly can't tell whether that was sarcasm or not.

 

[HFR]

Frosty's or Wolf's comments?

 

[Belgarath]

"This poll will close on 05-02-2009 at 11:41 AM"

 

[frostwhisper]

Too much, imo. It should close in no more than three days.

Oh and Wolf, my opinion may be worthless to you, but it will decide whether or not you'll get your rep gems and shiny icon.

 

[Wolfhelm]

True, but what i was trying to say is that there should be certain artistic liberties in the terraining and the theme should be judged on how mythical somthing appears not weather it fits the judges idea of what is ancient mythology or not. As long as it represents somthing in actual ancient mythology.

If that make sense to you then i do value your opinion otherwise it just seems like the judging is flawed.

 

[Celaquil]

The theme stated Ancient Mythology >.> Not REAL LIFE Ancient Mythology, thus this will make something that is a myth in a fictional world, take Lord of the Rings, Warcraft, Starcraft.. Any game, story, og fictional thing, as long as it is ancient valid. >.>
You shouldnt be so determined to wether or not it did exist in hour world when it was not said that it had to be in the contest.

 

[Belgarath]

Awesome, so, my depiction of the temple from Lost (as I imagine a part of it) is actually according to the theme

 

[frostwhisper]

Shit. I thought it was real life mythology. Many people got fucked. Sorry.


... >

 

[raid1000]

Shit. I thought it was real life mythology. Many people got fucked. Sorry.


... >

there is no such thing as real life mythology

 

[frostwhisper]

Ehm. Look! It's a flying rep gem!

_*hides*

 

[Belgarath]

Well now, I think I'll call this unfair + corrupted judging and declare myself the winner, eh?

 

[HFR]

No. Because there's other people who made "fantasycal" mythology... Like ArticInferno, me and Wolfhelm...

 

[frostwhisper]

How cute. People are advertising their work in the poll :3

 

[Wolfhelm]

Well now, I think I'll call this unfair + corrupted judging and declare myself the winner, eh?

No! Dont vote for yourself sombody might get there panties in a bunch!

 

[HFR]

I don't trying to advertise mine (and other people's works). I'm just trying to keep the integrity of the contest in the theme rating.

 

[~Void~]

The theme stated Ancient Mythology >.> Not REAL LIFE Ancient Mythology, thus this will make something that is a myth in a fictional world, take Lord of the Rings, Warcraft, Starcraft.. Any game, story, og fictional thing, as long as it is ancient valid. >.>
You shouldnt be so determined to wether or not it did exist in hour world when it was not said that it had to be in the contest.

No, it's real life ancient mythology. Like greeks, romans, norse, etc. That's what the theme was intended to be. I'm really sick of this "well it could've happened in my made-up fantasy world" because that completely defeats the purpose of having a theme.

You all should be glad I'm not using the old judging system, because most of these entries would be getting 0s for theme accuracy.

 

[HFR]

Wow, we were pwned... Anyway, why making the poll lasting so long?

 

[Wolfhelm]

This could go in circles forever - Real Life Ancient Mythology is imaginary these places could look like anything there is no right or wrong way to make yarrgissil or vallhala or atlantis cuz there is no standard description of them - as long as its a giant tree or mythical fortress or a underwater city / whatever it is your intending to represent.

Its not our fualt the theme was so vauge.

 

[~Void~]

I figured it would take longer than this.

 

[HFR]

Well, 7 days for the end, so, I only have to wait...

 

[frostwhisper]

these places could look like anything

The Colloseum, Greek ruins, Aztec ruins, Mayan ruins, Great wall of China and Giza Pyramids all disagree with you. And those are some collosal motherfuckers.

The theme was a very good one. You just failed at working with it.

Well, 7 days for the end, so, I only have to wait...

Gee, thanks for letting us know, Captain Obvious.

____

Void... I really suggest this thing gets closed before those 7 days pass.

 

[Wolfhelm]

The Colloseum, Greek ruins, Aztec ruins, Mayan ruins, Great wall of China and Giza Pyramids all disagree with you. And those are some collosal motherfuckers.

The theme was a very good one. You just failed at working with it.



Gee, thanks for letting us know, Captain Obvious.

____

Void... I really suggest this thing gets closed before those 7 days pass.

No - your just plain wrong. Those places are not MYTHOLOGY they are actual places. Vallhala was a mythical place that people belived existed much like modern day heaven. Its not real its mythology.

 

[HFR]

Actually, these places are just old ruins, not mythological places. This I must admit.

And frostywhisper, I have Obviousness Powers!. The year has 365 days!

 

[~Void~]

The Colloseum, Greek ruins, Aztec ruins, Mayan ruins, Great wall of China and Giza Pyramids all disagree with you. And those are some collosal motherfuckers.

The theme was a very good one. You just failed at working with it.



Gee, thanks for letting us know, Captain Obvious.

____

Void... I really suggest this thing gets closed before those 7 days pass.

I can't do that in this section. It's up to Gilles.

 

[frostwhisper]

Then I'll go gilles this place up.

 

[Gilles]

Void, let's gets some result up.