[Stuck in an island idea] What do you think?

[newbchu]

Hi there ladies and gents out there in hive.

Me and a buddy are creating a dual horror survivor map and ideas came out and We Want Your Opinion! (any criticism or comments I don't care be truthful eg. It's a SHIT IDEA!)

What are your opinions at the start of a story where two protagonists sunk their ship and end up in a cursed island (as in cults and sacrifices).

or

Two protagonists are police officers and was given orders to search lost citizens in a cursed town assumed by the rumors which was spread amongst centuries even now.

Its' a Battle between Island or Town.
Truthfuly I think island is too over-rated.

 

[Drunken_Jackal]

The first one. Cursed island sounds nice. It like the movie King Kong. Maybe there would be some flesh eating cannibal tribes and mysterious creatures lurking in that said island.

 

[cleavinghammer]

The island. That said, it doesn't have to be an island, any location cut off from the rest of the world for whatever reason (storm, blizzard, landslide) will do.

 

[Kanadaj]

Island, and we shouldn't forget that policemans sent to a dangeroud mission would get top equipment (oh yeah those idiotic zombie killer policeman maps around here-if u're sent for a dangerous zombie killing mission, would they let you go without a tank? ) But if you are lost on an island, you can make any story, from the one you have to make a way to survive - either getting rations to eat, or cutting your way to the exit, to the one of learning some secret magic on the island and having to use it against your will to escape-whew, I just had a crazy good idea... I've got to make a map out of this sometime Well, after I finished my current ORPG, but still have to make 6x50 skills

 

[Defias Kingpin]

the island idear sounds like the best option since town / horror has been over used alot

 

[rysnt11]

Definitely island !

 

[Skycraft]

What about a town on an island?
That's a cool idea.

 

[Paillan]

ISLAND OF COURSE!!! look much more real an acording to warcraft world (warcraft reality and real life ( in real life they are this cults and sacrifices))