Ok, go to game stop right now and buy Condemed : Criminal Origins and Condemed 2: Bloodshot!
Not rly well known, but got awesome freaky reviews from Game Informer
I'm hard to scare but the first time you play, unless ur fearless bring a nightlight and have mom check ur closet for phsyopathic murderers and walking mannequins
SH is mentally fucking
RE 1 was scary, but after that it was only rly ZOMBEH RUSH!!!!!!
Never played Fatal Frame or Fear, but saw gameplay footage, Fear is gory and mentally fucking at the same time
Bioshock is so screwed up ull end up sitting in and encclosed room in 5 years crafting horned goblins from newspaper whispering 'soon... we.... feast....'
Diablo is suspensful, i have the first but dont have 2 or 3 so i can only say... YES THE MUSIC IS SO FREAKY IN IN DIABLO ONE!
my analysis from Orc the horror guy (dun dun duuuuun)