Modeling Contest #12 - Poll

[Pyritie]

The Hive Workshop

Modeling Contest #12 Poll


Welcome to the poll for Modeling Contest #12! Please read through the rules before voting!

• Each user can only vote once in the poll.
• You cannot vote for yourself. If a voter has the same IP as the author then the vote will not be counted and it may result in the disqualification of the entry.
• You cannot create multiple accounts to vote for an entry in the poll. If a voter has been found to be using multiple accounts none of the voter's votes will count in the final result.

Prizes And Winnings

First Place: 50 reputation points and a special award icon. Second Place: 35 reputation points Third Place: 20 reputation points

Pyramidhe@d's Butcher

Dan van Ohllus' Fallen Maiden

Skrab's Joan of Arc

Elenai's Arch Maiden

Xatoga's Ogre Broad

Lord_T's Lady of the Bush

Callahan's Centaur Archer

 

[skrab]

my vote goes to Callahan's Centaur Archer
not much animations but i like the mesh and good use of ingame textures

 

[~Void~]

Touch choice between Callahan's and Elenai's, but I like Elenai's the best.

 

[Lord_T]

You're a quick little dragon, aren't you...

Good luck to all Conestants, once more!

 

[D a w n]

evil LiOneSS^^

but I also forgot about Callahan´s entry because he finished so early :>

oh and good luck everybody

 

[Rising_Dusk]

Callahan's is the only entry that interested me.

 

[Callahan]

Héhé no problem even I forgot my entry too.
A good thing that I figured that out at time.

 

[Just_Spectating]

i voted seriously this time

last time i voted for Xatoga just because i loved it so much

this time i voted for PyramindHe@d as it seemed the most original and had some nice custom anims.

 

[markone]

Piramid, Elenai and Xatoga are best 3,
Elenai made the best model quality, but idea isnt inovative at all
Piramid and Xatoga were both good, i hardly decided to vote for Ogre girl as little better idea!

Great work +rep to all 3

 

[bounty hunter2]

Good job all. All have done a good job. But my vote goes for Pyarmid, as I liked his one the most. Xatoga was original, DVO I didn't like his that much, seemed as if it's a puppet not a being, Joan of Arc was good but kinda boring, Elenai's work was good, however some parts I didn't like... such as the shoes as I mentioned before, however good job nevertheless, Lady of the Bush, nice idea, not so greatly done and Callahan well original but not that good.

 

[Kyrbi0]

(Dang, I actually really like the Centaur Archer... Adds something to the race, looks nice and somewhat unique, etc etc... Besides, it's Callahan!)

Alright, so now it's like "Top 3", and I can't decide... So I'll stick with my original vote (Elenai's Archmaiden), and rationalize with "because it's a hero".

It was a close call between Elenai's Archmaiden and Pyramidhe@d's Butchergirl.

On one hand, the Archmaiden is one of the few models that broke from the obvious limitations of the contest (that of "replacing" an in-game unit with a female counterpart), with a creative "new" model replacement. (sure, you may say it's just a new Jaina, but meh, I'm comparing it to the normal Archmage). I love the new staff, the nice cloak, the sweet ponytail, and how it really feels "Wc3-ish". Awesome.

On the other hand, the Butchergirl was amazing. This was an entirely new mesh. I can say similarly that this was one of the few model entries that broke from the issue of "female units = bigger chest + hair" that I thought was gonna be a big issue. Seriously.
When you announced "Female abomination", a horror story went through my head... But I love it. Sheer genius. From the multiple arms + weapons, to the bloody smock and bony pigtails, the mesh was fantastic. The animations: Wow. I freaked out when I saw her stab herself and pull out her still-beating heart (nice touch, BTW ). Her coquettish Portrait anims were pwn. And the rest were great takes on the standard anims; those just stick out to me.

Anyway, if this was solely a "Modelling" Competition, then I think my vote would go to the Butchergirl. However, as this is a "Warcraft 3 Modelling" Competition, and I think the Archmaiden is the more useful resource (for generic Wc3 modding), I voted for the Archmaiden.

However, Pyramidhe@d; I clap for you.

Seriously, though, skrab and Callahan: I loved your models. Great resources, good jobs, and good-on-ya for fleshing things out (races, I mean).

 

[Ribenamania]

I've my choice between Elenai and Pyramidhe@d
After my hesitation, my vote goes to Pyramidhe@d's Butcher girl.. I love it the most xD
She's sexy, cute, scary and looking good =) Animations are pretty awesome ^^ Yeah..

 

[Xatoga]

I really hope that 'sexy' here isn't literal, as she's a young dead girl. XP

I voted for the beastmaster, kinda ugly looking in an intentional way, i assume, but i liked the animations.

 

[Gilles]

I liked Elenai's, Pyramids, and Callahan's. I didn't care for the color scheme on Callahan's though, and I thought Pyramid's was a little better than Elenai's. He gets my vote.

 

[Just_Spectating]

for the originality


elenai's was so generic. So.. "elenai"

 

[bounty hunter2]

And a girl with a butchers knife isn't

 

[Elenai]

elenai's was so generic. So.. "elenai"

It isn't generic...She has normal plate armour...and isn't a slut.

 

[shamanyouranus]

Elenai's is just so cool looking.

CONSIFERATE!

 

[WILL THE ALMIGHTY]

It's decent looking. Nothing too amazing about it, other than the execution is very good.

We are far from the General Frank here.

 

[raid1000]

OMG piramid is awesome!!!!!1

 

[Pyritie]

Looks like it's going to have to go down to the judges for this one.

 

[Just_Spectating]

at least one of them will have 2nd.

 

[Vincent]

mY VOTE goes too... dumdumdumdum dum
Elenai's archmaiden!
The model looks extremely good, although pyramidhe@ds butcher was really good as well, the model mad by elenai looked really realistic!
good luck on the contest

 

[Rui]

I really can't make up my mind.

Pyramidhe@d's model is pretty interesting. I wonder, however, what uses would it have...
Elenai's "Arch Maiden" is a nice contribution to the already vast world of elven models out there.
Xatoga's female version of the Ogre was... unexpected, to say the least ;P
Callahan, in my opinion, succeeded in the contest's objective more than any of the other contestants -- making a female version of a model. Backed up by an existing screenshot, he didn't have to be too creative.

After some thinking, I've decided my vote will go for Elenai. There are way too few old ladies out there, but I just like Elves, and the Arch Maiden is a model rich with life. It is truly charming.

 

[Just_Spectating]

it was a tough decision.

 

[Elenai]

So...cloooose I really wanna win this one! Cooome ooooon, don't fail me now poll!

 

[Rising_Dusk]

So...cloooose I really wanna win this one! Cooome ooooon, don't fail me now poll!

If I hadn't already voted, I'd vote Pyramid's entry out of disgust.

 

[Elenai]

If I hadn't already voted, I'd vote Pyramid's entry out of disgust.

Oh, don't be so grouchy over a simple bit of silliness. Really..

 

[Just_Spectating]

this looks like a Judging ftw contest

 

[skrab]

OK lets see the Judging

 

[bounty hunter2]

Elenai does have a slight advantage. Oh well good luck once again!

 

[Xatoga]

Aw maaan, one vote out of possible third. Well, GJ to those who've made it. Interested to see how the judges score these.

 

[Vincent]

i like elenai's model cause it looks cool, although the animations are shabby and in-game (although it fits in very well) unlike pyramidhe@ds which looked cool too, had great animations but im not much a fan of undead models, plus in one animation it takes its heart out and puts it back in but later on you'll see it on her right arm @_@?

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

it appears later on? which animation is it?

 

[Elenai]

My animations are Medivh's animations...gotta blame blizzard for that.

 

[Callahan]

Judge result plz.

 

[communist_orc]

I luvz the Oger chick! ^^ very creative

 

[Gilles]

Who are the judges again? LiO and someone?

 

[shamanyouranus]

LiO and DonDustin

 

[skrab]

Judge result plz.

 

[Kuhneghetz]

I also desire the results and reviews from the judges.
For pete's sake, the poll has ended a while ago.

 

[Pyritie]

I've got Lio's judging; I'm just waiting for Dustin.

 

[Callahan]

What's taking so long?
Judge result plz.

 

[skrab]

The whole situation is just funny

 

[Pyritie]

Dustin is taking foreeeeever :/

 

[WILL THE ALMIGHTY]

Forget him, he's lost!

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

why doesnt Pyritie judge in place of dustin. Pyritie is the one who opened the competition and all

 

[Elenai]

It is not very good etiquette for the Host to be a Judge.

I'm about the just see if Anarchianbedlam, or Shamanyouranus will do it.

 

[D a w n]

I just finished

 

[Just_Spectating]

oooo.. Dum dum dum dum dum (Drum rollllL!)