- Joined
- Jan 17, 2010
- Messages
- 6,110
Puzzle & Mystery
Contestants are challenged to create Puzzle mini map for Warcraft 3 game that will be full of Mystery.
Contestants are free to pick and work on any map type (defense, RPG... without cinematic and terrain/template maps) as long as they bring mystery feeling into it.
Show us unique riddles, cool puzzles and awesome gameplay.
Concept (Base)
5/10
You may have followed the Puzzle Theme,
but your map lacks mystery unfortunately.
Concept (Puzzling)
23/30
The maze was really fun to navigate through,
and its difficulty is decent enough. Some ideas
were cliche, so you lost a few points here.
Concept (Mystery)
5/30
I see absolutely NO mysteries in this minigame.
Unfortunately, this has greatly put an impact on
your score.
Going Green
10/10
With a filesize under 100KB, this thing would get
a 9.5/10, and since you made great use of the
limited space, I'm giving you a full score.
Playability
9/10
You have one bug: Dead spiders can still kill me.
The game is 100% lag free, so I'm giving you a 9/10.
Aesthetics
4/10
The terrain was very plain thus causing the
environment you were trying to create very "generic".
Total Score
56/100
Concept (Base)
10/10
Your map perfectly follows both the "mystery" and the "puzzle" theme. There's
nothing more I could say. 10/10!
Concept (Puzzling)
27/30
There were several puzzles in the map. Most of them were fun. They were
presented excellently and they contributed to the sinusoidal flow that I
enjoyed while playing. Also, what contributed to your score was the fact
that all the puzzles were different.
Concept (Mystery)
25/30
The mystery was as good as it gets for Warcraft III. It was presented very
well, everytime a new question is answered, my questions grow exponentially.
Good Job!
Going Green
5/10
You could've utilized the empty space better, but I can't give you a low score
because the kind of terrain you invoked required you to spread out, so I'm going to
give you a passing score.
Playability
10/10
No bugs, No lag
Aesthetics
9/10
The terrain was amazing, you smartly used the priests particle emittors to pose
as a light source, and the darkness helped the theme. Unfortunately there were
some grammatical errors in the cinematics..
Total Score
86/100
Concept (Base)
10/10
Your map was by far the best when it comes to following the themes
of mystery and puzzles
Concept (Puzzling)
25/30
The puzzles were simple, but since they were presented so well, you
deserve a good score.
Concept (Mystery)
30/30
The fact that I had no idea what was going on .. it increased your score..
After the Goblin appeared, I had way too many questions.. then, suddenly,
a golem appeared and I was like .. "WTH". Also, the spiders in the 2nd room
were very misleading.. that added a few points to your score because the more
you mislead us, the greater the mystery.
Going Green
3/10
You used 3/10 of the map, so I'm giving you a 3/10.. lol
Your random use of imports (The creature) gave you a score less
than 5/10 too...
Playability
4/10
Your map has no lag, but unfortunately, since it cant be won (or finished),
you're losing points here..
Aesthetics
10/10
Your map was the best among all the others in the field of aesthetics even though
you had grammatical errors.
Total Score
82/100
Concept (Base)
5/10
Your map followed the "puzzle" theme, but .. well, there's no mystery...
Concept (Puzzling)
15/30
Puzzles were present, unfortunately, they were static and very simple.
After playing the map once, you'd know where everything is and you can
win very easily.
Concept (Mystery)
5/30
...There was no mystery...
Going Green
7/10
You used the map space excellently, but unfortunately, the map file size could've
been much smaller, so that's -3
Playability
8/10
Your map has no lag and no bugs, but what's stopping me from giving you a full
score is your spawn system. If you continuously spawn units, you can create
tons of lag for users with weak PCs.
Aesthetics
6/10
The terrain really needs to be improved.
Total Score
46/100
Concept (Base)
10/10
Your map followed both themes very well
Concept (Puzzling)
28/30
Puzzles were practically everywhere man.. My favorite was the "Trashed Floor".
That is just pure genius in the field of originality. Excellent! Or as we say
in Lebanon: "Momtaz! Ilal amam!"
Concept (Mystery)
18/30
There was some sort of mystery going on. Unfortunately, it wasn't clear.
Going Green
9/10
The map space was fully utilized, but the file size could've been less by just a smitch.
Playability
10/10
Your map has no bugs and no lag.
Aesthetics
8/10
The terrain needed a 'slight' improvement and some errors (grammatical) need to be fixed.
Total Score
83/100
Concept (Base)
10/10
The puzzle theme was followed and a mystery was present.
Concept (Puzzling)
29/30
Your puzzles were amazing. They're so creative, and they actually required
some time and thinking. Excellent!
Concept (Mystery)
15/30
Well, there was no mystery, but there was fear and anxiety for what's
going to happen.
Going Green
9.5/10
The map space was utilized perfectly and the file size was very good.
Playability
9/10
There were no bugs, but at one point, I felt the map lag epicly for about a second
while walking through the hall right after the spawn point. This happened everytime
I played your map, so I'm assuming something huge is being initialized. Here's a
tip: Leave all the heavy stuff for map initialization.
Aesthetics
9.5/10
Your terrain was perfect, but you mispelled "Unlocked" and you had a few grammatical errors.
Total Score
82/100
Concept (Base)
2/10
No comment.. You didn't follow any of themes..
Concept (Puzzling)
3/30
No puzzles, no nothing..
Concept (Mystery)
3/30
No mystery, but the green effects helped the environment and mood I guess..
Going Green
10/10
The map space was utilized perfectly and the file size was good.
Playability
10/10
No lag was present and no bugs were found..
Aesthetics
5/10
The terrain was plain.. It needs some improvement.
Total Score
33/100
Concept (Base) | Does the mini-game follow the contest's theme? | /10 |
Concept (Puzzling) | Is the mini-game cohesive, regarding the puzzles? How well were the puzzles presented? | /30 |
Concept (Mystery) | How well is mystery presented, how good secrets were? | /30 |
Going Green | How well does your map make use of limited space, be it file size or terrain size. | /10 |
Playability | Is the map bug/lag free? | /10 |
Aesthetics | How well does the map look and overall feel of the 'environment'? | /10 |
Concept (Base) 7/10
Concept (Puzzling) 26/30
Concept (Mystery) 26/10
Going Green 4/10
Playability 10/10
Aesthetics 8/10
Overall 81/100
Concept (Base) 6/10
Concept (Puzzling) 15/30
Concept (Mystery) 15/30
Going Green 7/10
Playability 5/10
Aesthetics 4/10
Overall 52/100
Concept (Base) 8/10
Concept (Puzzling) 25/30
Concept (Mystery) 28/30
Going Green 7/10
Playability 5/10
Aesthetics 6/10
Overall 79/100
Concept (Base) 8/10
Concept (Puzzling) 28/30
Concept (Mystery) 28/30
Going Green 9/10
Playability 8/10
Aesthetics 9/10
Overall 90/100
Concept (Base) 7/10
Concept (Puzzling) 28/30
Concept (Mystery) 25/30
Going Green 9/10
Playability 10/10
Aesthetics 8/10
Overall 87/100
Concept (Base) 4/10
Concept (Puzzling) 10/30
Concept (Mystery) 10/30
Going Green 10/10
Playability 10/10
Aesthetics 7/10
Overall 51/100
*Note this is a grate map but just doesn't fit the topic.
Concept (Base) 7/10
Concept (Puzzling) 25/30
Concept (Mystery) 15/30
Going Green 10/10
Playability 8/10
Aesthetics 6/10
Overall 71/100
((Votes / Total votes) * 30) + ((Judge 1 + Judge 2) * (70 / 200))
mckill2009 (Maze Raider) = 45.21923077
KayS (The Core of the Mirror) = 66.07307692
eubz (Great Dungeon Escape) = 35.83846154
DeathChef (Forest Assasins) = 30.93846154
Ahimtar (The Plagium) = 59.00769231
-Kobas- (Hunted) = 67.89230769
Figueiredo00 (Catacomb of Elend) = 67.68076923
- -Kobas-
- Figueiredo00
- KayS
- Ahimtar
- mckill2009
- eubz
- DeathChef
