Mini-Contest: Wc3:WoW Logo Competition {FINISHED}

x5.gearbox · Sep 6, 2007

Craka_J said:
Nice work DragoonZombie! The font quality is perfect and can't even tell that it was C&P'd.
I want to see more Frozen Throne logos like Saitek's logo!
Perhaps a Warcraft I or Warcraft II styled logo? Worth a try for everything to see how what looks good with what.
~Craka_J

How does TFT logo make sence? Your not making Northrend, thats where TfT is based upon.

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

Good point. I suppose that'll be the logo when ever we add Northrend. If we add Northrend atleast.
~Craka_J

iron_warrior · Sep 6, 2007

I think he just wants to blue color. No idea, though.

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

Me? No. I liked the icey TFT logo because you need TFT to play WC3:WoW. Bah... I'll make up my mind when September 28th comes.

~Craka_J

iron_warrior · Sep 6, 2007

Ahh, ok, I thought it was the blue because the WoW box is blue.

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

The WoW box is blue?... oh yeah! lol

So what happened to all the constant updates with the logos? Improve the logos until they meet complete perfection! And if you believe that you are finished, then I guess it wouldn't hurt to make a wallpaper. If you want, you can use a/the screenshot(s) hosted on the website here.
~Craka_J

iron_warrior · Sep 6, 2007

I made a few different updates to my logo, but none of them I really liked. I had one with the Azeroth planet behind the logo in huge, but it looked too...big. Another had fire instead of glow, but it didn't look right, either, so I didn't bother posting either of them.

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

Oh. Well here's a new rule to diverse the not so good and good. Place your good logos in your post as you would usually do, and post the ones that you think aren't so great in a "[ box=OK logo]<logos>[/box]"
This idea should work out fine!
~Craka_J

DragoonZombie · Sep 6, 2007

I could try to make the same logo with Frozen Throne, but I can't find a huge TFT logo. The RoC logo I used was 3000x1433 px big.

/Edit:
added the new logo, now in TFT Style. I chosed the biggest logo I could find, but I think its ok.

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

Hmm... not sure if I like "The Frozen Throne" text showing. Fill in that part to blend with the bar. The rest is great though!
~Craka_J

DragoonZombie · Sep 6, 2007

ok, removed the "The Frozen Throne" text.

Do you have anymore suggestions? If not I would like to make these 2 my finals

View attachment wc3_wow_logo#6 Final1.bmp

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

Fantastic work! I like what you have so far

Only problem is the "WoW" is not centered perfectly. I think it should be alligned with the III
~Craka_J

DragoonZombie · Sep 6, 2007

do you mean each letter on one of the bars?

Craka_J · Sep 6, 2007

Not ON the bars literally. Leave the WoW letters where they are, just scoot them over to the right a bit until the O is alligned perfectly with the middle I in the III. Get what I'm trying to say?
~Craka_J

x5.gearbox · Sep 7, 2007

Since you seem to like ice i'll try to make one with ice.

Craka_J · Sep 8, 2007

Hmm... post one with the icey III so I can compare the two together and decide which looks better.
~Craka_J

DragoonZombie · Sep 8, 2007

ok I aligned the WoW perfectly to the middle bar, but it actually moved just a inch from before ... I wouldn't have noticed that lol

Craka_J · Sep 8, 2007

What can I say? I'm a perfectionist at time.
And now it looks better. Good work.
~Craka_J

JoshT · Sep 10, 2007

A logo competition eh? I would compete, but I'm too busy.
Say, how is the logo supposed to look like.
Describe me the logo that you imagined would be perfect :grin:

Craka_J · Sep 11, 2007

Well the majority of the contest entries so far are pretty much a good thing to base what yours should look like, replicas of what other people made won't be accepted and get you disqualified.
~Craka_J

War3_Editor · Sep 17, 2007

this is my real image size logo->

achoozoo · Sep 17, 2007

thats actually wicked, simple but effective i mean it includes the main symbols of wow and wc3 and the log and yeah gw man and yes i do realise that its pretty much a copy and paste fade job but you have to admit its petty good

Craka_J · Sep 17, 2007

Looks more like a Wallpaper to me than a logo to be honest.
~Craka_J

thisruoy · Sep 18, 2007

Wow logo

Heres my entry
I got the background from wow logo and put a reign of chaos logo inside it
then got the "world" from WOW logo and put it under
I put wrath of lich king on the second one.

Ken Christopher · Sep 18, 2007

Are you still accepting new participant? I would like to give it a try.

Craka_J · Sep 18, 2007

Yes. Feel free to enter the contest. The contest ends on September 28th!So hurry up!
~Craka_J

Jumbo · Sep 18, 2007

thisruoy imo it shouldnt just say "world" it just looks a bit wrong, maybe remove it totally or add the "of warcraft" or "Wow".

iron_warrior · Sep 18, 2007

thisruoy said:
Heres my entry
I got the background from wow logo and put a reign of chaos logo inside it
then got the "world" from WOW logo and put it under
I put wrath of lich king on the second one.

I suggest re-arranging the words a little, and sticking with a constant style of border, since the copy and paste is very obvious there.

Not too bad, though.

Craka_J · Sep 18, 2007

I'm gonna have to agree with Iron_Warrior on that one. The images are easily noticable that they're Copy & Pasted and you can notice the differences between the quality of each image. For exampe: The "III" is a lot blurrier than the images on the left and right.

I've added you both to the list of the competitors in the first post on this thread. Good luck to the both of you, and the rest of the contestants of course!
~Craka_J

PS: Warning! 10 more days left until contest ends!

x5.gearbox · Sep 19, 2007

This is my entry, I also made one with Ice but the Ice letters are flaw unless remade since they are translucent so it shows the border of TFT. Unforunatly, that logo is blurry since I couldn't find a good picture of WoW: WotL, at the time.

The boarder is from the WoW logo
The text is from the Warcraft: RoC logo
The III is also from RoC

Craka_J · Sep 19, 2007

Very nice entry x5.gearbox. I take it that this is your final entry or are you planning to improve or add on to the logo some more before you consider your logo 'complete'?
~Craka_J

x5.gearbox · Sep 20, 2007

Craka_J said:
Very nice entry x5.gearbox. I take it that this is your final entry or are you planning to improve or add on to the logo some more before you consider your logo 'complete'?
~Craka_J

I'd work on it more but I'm out of time. So yes this is my Final entry.

Gilles · Sep 20, 2007

Ahh, I looked through all of them, it's so damn hard to decide.

thisruoy · Sep 20, 2007

Well obviously its CNP
Also i dont really like the title Warcraft 3: Wow
its too long?
how about just Warcraft 3 World

Ken Christopher · Sep 20, 2007

Here's my logo for the mini contest.

I do not know whther is the size correct or not. If not, I will remake the correct size's logos.

I think they are not that good.

Craka_J · Sep 20, 2007

Wow! Another great entry! >.< It's becoming more and more difficult to decide! Which is a very, very good thing! Keep the contest entries coming!

[Edit]:
Also, please note that I would very much apprecate it if you registered on our (Wc3:WoW) official forum for Wc3:WoW at http://z4.invisionfree.com/war3wow/
If you do this, I can give a part of the reward of all three winning entries a title for winning X place in the contest and if you're first place winner, you also get a custom username font color. The top three winning contestants also get put in the Closed Beta team! First place winning contestant gets THREE free passes in the Closed Beta, meaning that the first place winner will not be required to report bugs, suggestions, or ideas. Though it is very much appreciated if done so.
~Craka_J

Ken Christopher · Sep 21, 2007

To Craka_J :

Alright, I will register up to help the team.

thisruoy · Sep 21, 2007

Too much filter make the logo look bad..

Ken Christopher · Sep 22, 2007

@ thisruoy

Are they really bad?

iron_warrior · Sep 22, 2007

StyxaneZ said:
@ thisruoy

Are they really bad?

I think he simply meant having too many filters decreases the overall look of the logo. Not that it was "bad."

Craka_J · Sep 22, 2007

Thanks for registering on the forum!

And as the filtering goes, I don't notice it very much. But if you can improve it's quality at all or something, please feel free to do so!
I can't really tell what the difference is between the two attachments you added though, SyxaneZ.
~Craka_J

DragoonZombie · Sep 22, 2007

ok, I registered on the forums too now.

These two are my finals and entrys:
RoC Style
TFT Style

War3_Editor · Sep 22, 2007

is this okay?>>

if not, ill go back to my original one.....

iron_warrior · Sep 22, 2007

That comes back to the too many filters part...I think you went nuts with what...invert, plastic wrap...

The original is the best.

Craka_J · Sep 22, 2007

Yeah the other one was better.
~Craka_J

thisruoy · Sep 23, 2007

MY FREAKING EYES!
sorry..
1st ones way good

DragoonZombie · Sep 23, 2007

I thought "World of Warcraft III" isnt allowed Oo

Craka_J · Sep 23, 2007

It's not. btw Dragoon, your entries are very good

Loving the TFT version!

~Craka_J

DragoonZombie · Sep 24, 2007

Craka_J said:
Title can not be "World of Warcraft III" due to legality issues.

You wrote it yourself. ^^

/Edit:
ops I thought you disagree xP

Angel_Duster · Sep 25, 2007

Well i think im screwed but i hope i could get some beta testing or somthing for my one i made but wasnt alloud, but from the messgae i read about you said, i know it is it seemed as you dont realy care much, so i am going to repost it,

FULL CREDIT TO BLIZZARD FOR MAKING TO LOGO I Only Edited It It Belongs to Blizzard.

Mini-Contest: Wc3:WoW Logo Competition {FINISHED}

Attachments

Attachments

Attachments

Attachments

Attachments