War of the Ring AOS v16.1

[pred1980]

Without an AI System its just a boring map. I need bots to play your map. Are u working on an AI System?

 

[Dinodin]

Without an AI System its just a boring map. I need bots to play your map. Are u working on an AI System?

What is AI System?

 

[HerrDave]

An AI system is an intricate bunch of scripts that add bots which simulate players accurately in a map. Unlike how blizzard bots just stand around if there are no goldmines or workers at their disposal.

 

[pred1980]

Yes, an AI is a system which simulates copmuter intelligence. Never heard about it? Do you know DotA? If yes, its possible to play vs bots.

An AI system provides a simple computer AI for arena-type maps like yours. Basic actions for the AI include learning skills, picking up items, buying items, and running away.

In your map i can only play alone vs nobody, just creeps and thats why i said it's boring.

 

[Vengeancekael]

Haha I can't believe you're still updating this.

 

[CafeSaiGon]

is this bug or my warcraft error?

 

[Dinodin]

Haha I can't believe you're still updating this.

Well it's been awhile since last time and I'm not working much with this map anymore. I only make some small updates if there is some bugs that has to been fixed...

is this bug or my warcraft error?

Ehm I've never seen that bug before so I guess it's your warcraft error...

 

[CafeSaiGon]

Ehm I've never seen that bug before so I guess it's your warcraft error...

Do you know how to fix it? (my warcraft III)

 

[Dinodin]

Do you know how to fix it? (my warcraft III)

No I don't sorry. I've never seen an error like that before...

 

[ZiBitheWand3r3r]

Do you know how to fix it? (my warcraft III)

Sure
restart your warcraft, lol
you played some shity widgetized map thats corrupts your game cache

 

[Deleted member 247165]

From what i analyzed in your map,while playing it,it seems to be quite interesting.But!
-you should work more on the design of the map(looks too ugly)
-you should be more creative for skills,use your whole imagination and get them alive using the power of the triggers
-the hero's skills should have a corelation(an example:first skill armor reduction,second skill bonus physical damage) you know to complete each other and make each hero unique and awesome
-you need to add AI(AI means heroes that are controlled by computers,via a multiple system of triggers.(Read the helper of the editor on google to understand how to create an AI)
-excepting those mentioned above,the map is as I said,good
I am rating it 4/5

 

[Valandil]

I love the game I had yestertay playing this combination of Glorfindel skills and item called Elven cape is fantastic making you sileng heroe killer).
But terrain is Horrible. Do you need a Terrainer ? I can help you if you want. Also I can try to make AI... not sure if they will work correctly but can try.

 

[Dinodin]

I love the game I had yestertay playing this combination of Glorfindel skills and item called Elven cape is fantastic making you sileng heroe killer).
But terrain is Horrible. Do you need a Terrainer ? I can help you if you want. Also I can try to make AI... not sure if they will work correctly but can try.

Ehm well yes if you think you can improve the terrain more then it's ok I actually can't see anything wrong with the terrain, I think it looks ok but yes it can better I really don't get what AI System is but if that will improve the gameplay then it's ok if u adding it.

 

[Valandil]

AI meaans artificial inteligence , so you can play whith a computer.
Ok but where I can get the open source map ?

 

[Dinodin]

AI meaans artificial inteligence , so you can play whith a computer.
Ok but where I can get the open source map ?

Play with a computer!? So you mean if I choose to play with a computer then it will randomly pick a Hero and play with it with or against me? Well currently this map often causes people to DC at the start or lag out and I dunno why. It's been happening with this v3.8 version and v3.7 but it didn't happening often with the earlier versions and I haven't made much change since v3.6 I've just fixed alot of bugs and glitches with spells and items and changed the Uruk-Hai Berserker model :-/ So could the new Uruk-Hai Berserker model be bugged or something which makes people DC or lag out at start?

 

[Valandil]

Play with a computer!? So you mean if I choose to play with a computer then it will randomly pick a Hero and play with it with or against me? Well currently this map often causes people to DC at the start or lag out and I dunno why. It's been happening with this v3.8 version and v3.7 but it didn't happening often with the earlier versions and I haven't made much change since v3.6 I've just fixed alot of bugs and glitches with spells and items and changed the Uruk-Hai Berserker model :-/ So could the new Uruk-Hai Berserker model be bugged or something which makes people DC or lag out at start?

Ok if you send me the map I can check triggers and other things like abilities for what makes people dc. But I dont think that can be model, it doesnt make people dc when model is not loaded but only creat green box in the game . So Do you want to send me the open map ?

 

[Gumberbunbder]

I love the game I had yestertay playing this combination of Glorfindel skills and item called Elven cape is fantastic making you sileng heroe killer).
But terrain is Horrible. Do you need a Terrainer ? I can help you if you want. Also I can try to make AI... not sure if they will work correctly but can try.

Is this map like a AOS between Minas Tirith and Minas Morgul? If dinodin gives you the map to edit i could do one of the bases and you could do the other if you wanted. It would be awesome to have like 2 beautiful looking cities opposing eachother.

 

[Valandil]

Dinodin think the map doesnt need any inovation and that terrain is good as it is ...

 

[Dinodin]

Dinodin think the map doesnt need any inovation and that terrain is good as it is ...

I'm not saying it's perfect but not bad either... I think it's just ok. Terraining is not my strongest side so if you can make the terrain better than I would be happy...

 

[E.M.C]

Hmm, where to begin...

Well I found this map to be way too generic, which is a shame since I really enjoyed the custom models, and the thought put behind the lore of the items and characters.

The map is actually decent looking ingame, but it looks awful on the mini map. There is simply way too many trees. You need a third spawn lane, and various shortcuts between the tree walls that intersect with one another. Just take a look at any standard variety AoS map and you'll know what I mean. What also bothered me is that all of the towers are of the same strength when you make your push forward. You should increase the strength of the towers behind gradually.

The map design is clumsy. On one hand, there's a considerable walking distance between the fountain(s) and the middle of the map, but on the other, there's not enough in-game content to justify so many space. There's also way too many space between each pair of towers. What I've also noticed is that even if you kill the barracks in the lane, the monsters keep spawning, which means that all of the buildings in each base are just for show and serve no real purpose. You might wanna work on that too.

Finally, like other people have pointed out, getting the one ring was way too easy. And also quite underwhelming given how mediocre the item itself is. I know it can be upgraded, but I don't see why would any player bother with it since they can simply save the money to get a great item instead (and the one which will not drop upon death).

All in all, 3/10 at best.

 

[Manipulation]

- Your heroes stats are so similarly same thats its insulting.... You base your map on something that has a background story meaning you should try to give stats accordingly.
- Almost all skills deal standard damages which is an old concept.
- everything is too basic

 

[Lord_Marrowgrath]

2009 to 2019 nothing changed on that map. Map needs massive update. It feels boring and old.

 

[Gimli007]

lotr moba great!

 

[OverClocked]

Map looks great but the balancing is terrible.

 

[Deleted member 247165]

Map looks great but the balancing is terrible.

Please try to be less harsh and specify what he should improve regarding balance. This way, he will understand your issues. Instead of leaving an 1/5 and a non-specific comment, you could actually suggest him what should be worked on.

 

[yuriy_valandil]

This map is better than Guardian of Middle Earth !)))

 

[yuriy_valandil]

So you play this in reforged ?

 

[emil23]

after 9.9 got released everything is so broken! worst map ever! every time map is played on battle net 2-3 people are dropped at start! it happens almost at every game! you shouldnt have added 4 new heroes! you copied spells from some outdated map for them thats why there is crash! 3 versions got released and u still cant fix it

 

[Deleted member 247165]

after 9.9 got released everything is so broken! worst map ever! every time map is played on battle net 2-3 people are dropped at start! it happens almost at every game! you shouldnt have added 4 new heroes! you copied spells from some outdated map for them thats why there is crash! 3 versions got released and u still cant fix it

Jeez. Sorry for stepping up for @Dinodin , but like...instead of pointing how "broken" his AoS is, you could help him out with some suggestions and real screenshots I suppose. Not to mention the raged 1/5 rating that you gave him.

 

[deepstrasz]

you shouldnt have added 4 new heroes! you copied spells from some outdated map for them

Any proof of this? Also, rating this one star without actually helping the author improve is null, a waste of time.

 

[emil23]

Any proof of this? Also, rating this one star without actually helping the author improve is null, a waste of time.

i am not native speaker so i used bit wrong words, i actually play with dindoin every day, i got mad at him, he never does anything himself, he excepts other people to edit his map for him for free without any benefits @Tipou helpped him and hes not even thankfull, even here at hive workshop moderator added comment to his profile to post in requests if dino doesnt want to do anything himself.


by copied i actually meant he takes spells from hiveworkshop's spells section, thats allowed, in 9.9 ver he added 4 new heroes and all of them have custom spells which are from spell section he didnt add anything else so some code he copied then pasted is corrupted.

 

[emil23]

Too bad developer doesnt even care to rename version after he releases new version or make changelog of changes. this all tells quality of editing map and developers attitude to map

(i will change rating if u rename version or make changelog)

 

[Gimli007]

I was excited to play this, when i first heard about it like a year ago, but I quickly learn why emil always talks down this map.
Horrible balance issues even with tipou helping him a lot... not tipous fault, doesn't even feel like a moba but looks like one. I guess only tip i can give is balance the game make the jungle safer but less gold cap, and perhaps add a 3rd lane. Just makes me want to log off wc3 to dota 2. I know someone that works AI systems for wc3 and sc2 you should perhaps get someone like that to help or learn it. I would send him your way but terrain and other things need to be fixed.

 

[Sirmarkis29]

Hello this map is amazing! can you upload the version with work with 1.26 o 1.27(better i using this) plzzzzz i dont like i dont play reforged :C

 

[emil23]

Hello this map is amazing! can you upload the version with work with 1.26 o 1.27(better i using this) plzzzzz i dont like i dont play reforged :C

I'm sure there are older versions around. I dont think dindoin will be up to bring compatiblity for old wc3. just serach on wc3 maps com or epic war for some old ver