See? Scyth? I believe the "pros" of this site gave me good feedback at my Terrain but uhh... they didnt take a look, nor made a comment on your showcase, maybe thats a sign?
Y'know, I get the feeling I don't like you much. Of course, we'll discuss that when I take a peak at your tilesets
But first, Scythes
1. The position of the crater is a bit eh. Its a good few feet away from the car. It looks like it had a massive explosion under it, then rolled forward a few yards to crash into a wall and another car
2. What the devil are those doodads piled up on front of the car? Cookies? Cause they suck. Seriously. I do like the dirt piled up around it though
3. Fairly generic Sunken Ruins-y as far as I can tell. I'd prefer some more height variation there somewhere as well, or some depth variation. The sea shouldn't be all one level, and see that earlier comment about trees. Want trees in water? Make it a marsh or something then. But a nice ruin with some islets around would look nice, try for something like that
4. This is flat. Seriously. Even for a playable map it could have some height variation or something. Its generic, its flat, the best thing I can say about this is that you changed textures well, but that's it
5. The bar's clipping through the back of the truck
. But aside from that nitpicking, nothing else particularly wrong with this
6. Quite nice actually
7. A few of the various doodads do not go well together. The glowingly silver pipes and the fountain being the worst offenders. Fairly generic though, nothing special
8. The water and the Barrens cliff ruins this, plain and simple
