Rejection Reasons

[wereguy2]

When a resource is rejected, I think that the moderators review should be displayed at the top of the page instead of "This resource is not available".

 

[Kwaliti]

It is, but only to the uploader.

 

[wereguy2]

Exactly

 

[En_Fuego]

If you let people see rejected shit, then that defeats the purpose of 'rejecting' it.

Right?

 

[Pyritie]

If you let people see rejected shit, then that defeats the purpose of 'rejecting' it.

Right?

This ^

 

[takakenji]

yeah but we should have a comment why,

 

[En_Fuego]

Ask the maker then...perhaps the moderator leaves something the maker deems embarrassing? If you want to know, ask the maker. If he/she wants to tell you then he/she will.

 

[wereguy2]

Argh, no. I didn't say that the resource should still be available, I said that the moderators reasons for rejecting it should be on display.
But yes, that is a good point, Fuego.

 

[Zombie]

Author's concern, imo. Only the uploader is able to make improvements of the submission and having any other people objecting to the rejection (moderators of the section discounted) is totally unnecessary.

 

[Miss_Foxy]

Or maybe add an option for the maker to weather he allows it or not...

 

[Pyritie]

If it's rejected, it's for a good reason. If they want everyone to be able to download it then they'd better make the changes we suggest require.

 

[wereguy2]

having any other people objecting to the rejection (moderators of the section discounted) is totally unnecessary.

True, though this works the other way. I once saw a wonderful model that got rejected and was trying to find out why for like an hour before someone told me it had WoW anims.

 

[Zombie]

Why do you need to know why it was rejected? I could only repeat my previous post.

 

[wereguy2]

I don't need to know, I would like too, though.

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

by displaying the rejected models, we could stop different people from submitting similar resources. just enable display and disable download.
of course the above theory only works if the people actually bother to look through the resources section before doing anything.

 

[wereguy2]

That's not a bad idea.

 

[Rui]

When a resource is rejected, I think that the moderators review should be displayed at the top of the page instead of "This resource is not available".

A resource is rejected for a reason, I don't see why you would want to know exactly why. You can always ask the author, as someone already suggested here (I think).
I don't mind having the moderator comment show for everyone, but it depends on how much work it takes, and if Ralle is up for doing it.

 

[wereguy2]

I doubt it would be very hard.

 

[Mr. Bob]

Um..When my crap gets rejected, (usually for stupid things... but nevermind that) I can't even find it by filtering out "my rejected items". I can only get to it by clicking on the automated PM. Don't know if it is a bug or if it is intentional.

Anyway, if something is rejected...it is a reject...simple as that....

 

[wereguy2]

Oh yeah, lol, that leads onto another thing, the incredible bugginess of the resource filtering (namely things like My Approved Rejected etc Stuff).
But that is off topic, and I can't be bothered making a thread about it.

 

[Pyritie]

Um..When my crap gets rejected, (usually for stupid things... but nevermind that) I can't even find it by filtering out "my rejected items". I can only get to it by clicking on the automated PM. Don't know if it is a bug or if it is intentional.

Hm, I don't think that's intentional.

 

[D a w n]

by displaying the rejected models, we could stop different people from submitting similar resources. just enable display and disable download.
of course the above theory only works if the people actually bother to look through the resources section before doing anything.

this would have to be disabled for skins and icons because they could be used ingame :>

 

[wereguy2]

The screenshot cant.