Pointing System for Map Reviews

[RaijinSpark]

ok, christmas vacation is on and i got 3 weeks to online for 20 hours a day i can spend some of my time reviewing maps via points like (terrain 20 points, Units 20 points etc..) but still doesn't have one yet now maybe you could help me create some criteria on each map i review?..

here's what i have in mind so far, feel free to suggest, add or remove some..

-Terrain:25 pts
---Place of Doodads: 10 pts
---Tileset: 5 pts
---Creativity: 10 pts

-Heroes:25 pts
---Balance: 8 pts
---Model/Icon used: 5 pts
---Skills/Abilities/Spells: 7 pts
---Voice or Sound of the hero: 2 pts
---Name and Title: 3pts

-Units: 25 pts
---Place of units: 10 pts
---Units: 10 pts
---Model for units: 5 pts

-The Game: 25 pts
---Sound: 5 pts
---Gameplay: 10 pts
---Quest/Objectives/Goal: 10 pts

-Other
---Loading Screen: 5 pts
---No Lags or Freeze: 5 pts
---Credits Given: 5 pts
---Minimap: 5 pts
---Descriptio: 5 pts

Overall Total: 125 Points

0-40 FAIL MAP
40-65 Lacking
65-75 Bad
75-85 Average
85-95 Good
95-110 Recommended
110-120 Highly Recommended
120-125 Director's Cut

Request:
Can anyone make me a 150x150 image with hive's boarder with the text "DarkHorse08 says: this map is Recommended" inside it thank you..

P.S: I'm not really sure that i posted this thread in off-topic but meh,

 

[Xarwin]

You don't simply review everything via criteria, but by playing.
After all: Fun > Quality.

 

[Vosty]

Fun > asthestics > performance
Yeah, but this looks nice though.

 

[Xarwin]

Giving so much points will scare people for reviews, for doing something wrong or missing something that became essential and which shouldn't be essential at all.

 

[Vosty]

Hey, have you ever seen one of Septimus's old reviews. They are twice as big.

 

[Linaze]

Good reviewers don't need nor use silly point systems to review maps.
Besides, if you really need to use a point system, make sure it's good (unlike yours).

 

[Aeroblyctos]

If you are experienced enough you can just make one big text about the map. Tell it's good and bad sides and in the end give a point from 1 to 5. It's actually easy if you just have good english and you know what to write.

The points are of course other way to express, it's easier for people who aren't that good with english and don't write good review texts. Just remember to not make the points too complicated and accurate.

Always, fun/enjoyment => quality like Xarwin said. Always.

 

[PurplePoot]

I hope that this is a joke. Its criteria don't even accommodate a large amount of maps.

 

[Paladon]

i got 3 weeks to online for 20 hours a day

I hope that's a joke as well.

 

[Linaze]

20h / day, I mean whoa, that means, once you've eaten and all that shit, that you'll get like 30minutes of sleep. That's so cool!

 

[RaijinSpark]

when there's no classes i start 4:00 AM until 12:00 PM what's joke with that?

 

[Belgarath]

if thats 4 am to 12 am then that's really sad. like.
extremely sad.

 

[Ralle]

That's like 20 hours. Anyway. Is this thread going anywhere?

 

[Joe-black-5]

Guess not, since the original purpose of this thread was fulfilled (showed users a system, they rejected)
:/ closing would be the best thing to do now

 

[RaijinSpark]

let's just say i need a review template?

 

[Vengeancekael]

lol wanna see mine?

 

[RaijinSpark]

sure =)

 

[Pyritie]

Guess not, since the original purpose of this thread was fulfilled (showed users a system, they rejected)
:/ closing would be the best thing to do now

Pretty much