murlocwarrior.blp

[Moderator]

23:07, 11th Jul 2008
Dan van Ohllus:
[Rejected]
Because you resubmitted the update instead of using the update function.

 

[FrIkY]

I like the idea, but the skin is kinda too monotone, try adding some colors

3/5 - monotone, but it can be useful

 

[Avsky]

I like the idea, but the skin is kinda too monotone, try adding some colors

3/5 - monotone, but it can be useful

Maybe I'll add some markings on the face

 

[pyropk95]

i like the eyes...and the total idea of this...i just dont like the weapon...i wish it looked like a stick...or something, not the color of himself

 

[Devine]

The weapon should be made from wood ... it shouldnt have the same color as the murloc. looks realy good 4/5
way better then your other skins

 

[Hawkwing]

Negative Comments

[-] Dosen't look like steel at all.
[-] Much too monotone.
[-] Parts have been recoloured.
[-] Nothing too freehanded. You followed the ouline and shadows of the original texture. Get creative!

Positive Comments

[+] General Concept is somewhat acceptable.

Comments: It just dosen't look like steel. And even if it is steel you still need to add some colour.

Overall Rating: 2/5

 

[DragonElite]

Negative Comments
It just dosen't look like steel. And even if it is steel you still need to add some colour.

Still it could be useful as Iron since steel is more white and iron greyish.
p.s: Don't try to talk as a mod, cause you aint. (no offense)

 

[Misha]

Still it could be useful as Iron since steel is more white and iron greyish.
p.s: Don't try to talk as a mod, cause you aint. (no offense)

And are you >_0?

BTW, i would call that thing "incinerated Murloc" "cause that's how it looks to me. I think it deserves a chanse to be aproved, but don't mind me. Anyway, VERY good work! 4\5

 

[pyropk95]

incinerated as in fire....wtf...this is ironish steelish...not incinerated it doesnt look to burnt to me

 

[Jack_Sparrow93]

Think that it looks good... could have bean done better

waiting for an update

 

[Avsky]

Negative Comments

[-] Dosen't look like steel at all.
[-] Much too monotone.
[-] Parts have been recoloured.
[-] Nothing too freehanded. You followed the ouline and shadows of the original texture. Get creative!

Positive Comments

[+] General Concept is somewhat acceptable.

Comments: It just dosen't look like steel. And even if it is steel you still need to add some colour.

Overall Rating: 2/5

Man you're really hard to impress

 

[pyropk95]

ya, kinda...but what he says is what to be done...so you should take in advice...but he also compares it to when pros skin...so ya

 

[Hawkwing]

You know why I critique like that? Because I don't want to critique the new people as if they are new. First, second, or third skin is no excuse for it to be poor quality. This is just another reason why I don't rate these skins using the rating system, either. I don't want to affect it.

Avsky, you have great potential and as you continue to design textures you will get better and better. Don't give up.

 

[I34w90_238j]

Yeah make silver effect for it and add some plate edges