Fort

[Moderator]

02:14, 3rd Apr 2009
BlinkBoy: It's been a long time since I last moderated a model of yours. You have improved QUITE A LOT, yet there are still some issues. First, the big number of geosets. As you said it's so high due to how you model, yet I shouldn't approve a model with more than 10 geosets because there's an inner limit in the game concerning geosets. If your model is massed in game(like terraining), bad geometry issues may appear due to the traspassing of the geoset limit. My suggestion is quite simple: use the beloved "Attach" mesh tool to unify similar geosets, don't forget to collapse the geosets before.

That's all, approved, take my advice for the next time. If you have any questions please do.

 

[wereguy2]

Yum!
5/5

 

[NeCrO_OwNeR]

Prety good model

 

[anarchianbedlam]

I love you Mr.Bob i really do but i have to remain subjective.
I really like the design, It is a pretty cool looking castle. Some UV could be a lil better, but only if I were to be nitpicky about that.
Quite frankly, I dont care for the animations. The smoke in the stand work looks fine, but for it's death it just kind of flashes red and sinks into the ground, and for the birth, the castle just kind of rises from the dust and dirt. (for example) i would love to see that crane move a little... also, this model is pretty damn huge considering that it has no upgrade animations. I like the level of detail though

This model is perfectly functional yet it could be better. Id love to see what you can do with this

An honest 4/5

 

[wowcraft]

Great model, especially useful for a archery range 5*

 

[JaysProjex]

It could use some minor improvements but overall its a great model! I would give it a 4/5

-I would add a "door" or some "brick windows" to the big tower I would also make it a tad smaller? xD Its a good model though good job mate!

 

[Just_Spectating]

i dont really like buildings that have a bunch of crap already in it because it seems like the peasants should be building each building separately, but this one turned out pretty nice.

Its a bit too square and there is no foundation.

if you try to build this on a hill it would be floating

u should add a foundation.

 

[Mr. Bob]

i dont really like buildings that have a bunch of crap already in it because it seems like the peasants should be building each building separately, but this one turned out pretty nice.

Its a bit too square and there is no foundation.

if you try to build this on a hill it would be floating

u should add a foundation.

The hill would have to be dramaticly steep. And, it is square because it is realistic. I don't care about how is does with the other WC3 models. lol

 

[Videosurfer101]

This can be used for a good many things. I like it, 4/5.

 

[Power]

is good......

 

[Mechanical Man]

i dont really like buildings that have a bunch of crap already in it because it seems like the peasants should be building each building separately, but this one turned out pretty nice.

What bunch of crap?

The hill would have to be dramaticly steep. And, it is square because it is realistic. I don't care about how is does with the other WC3 models. lol

Not really dramaticly steep. It can float already at smaller inclinations if not placed at the right spot. I learned that so now I make only buildings with foundation and I also convinced my co-worker of our project to do this way.

 

[Mr. Bob]

Not really dramaticly steep. It can float already at smaller inclinations if not placed at the right spot. I learned that so now I make only buildings with foundation and I also convinced my co-worker of our project to do this way.

hmmm...k. Well, I have decided not to use this for the modeling comp13. Instead, I am going to make a much better model. This model will indeed include a foundation. It should be done shortly.

 

[Just_Spectating]

by 'bunch of crap' i mean, theres 3 separate buildings in this model put together to be one. i personally dont like it.

 

[Mechanical Man]

But for a larger building is necessary having more separate buildings. Although I don't like too much empty space between them. But I understand, I also like to be able to raise it if grabbing it at any part (I hope you know what I mean)

And 30 kb is not few.

 

[Bloodezach]

That looks freaking great 5/5, 10/10, 2 thumbs up.

 

[willydawiller]

two notes/suggestions

does it work in reign of chaos?

can it be used in terrains ex, the door opens?

i'd think it would be more "real" if the wall wouldnt go around
the tower since the tower looks quite sturdy allready
so it could just like blend into the tower (just my opinion )

 

[Slashbang]

Mr. Bob...your awsum man...

I have always loved your buildings, mostly for their detail and modern-ness (I generally do modern maps and it can be hard to find good buildings.) I always seem to find uses for your dwarf tank pack and same with the Bobs Building pack.

However, yes it is right. Add a foundation.

Good Work as always, have a cookie.

 

[RaijinSpark]

Aw-Zone!

 

[AIagremm]

Super mega awesome!
It kind of reminds me of elven buidings from Alien Nations.

 

[ArneXis]

Pimp 5/5

 

[AIagremm]

Your death animation is long.
And because of that I understood, that this building is like Arcane Observatory, just for the normal people.

 

[Cham[p]ion]

Awesome job. +rep

 

[Mr. Bob]

And they said this was terrible for cinimatics...

lol

 

[HappyTauren]

why can't wc3 render like that...

 

[Mr. Bob]

why can't wc3 render like that...

That would be rather sweet.

 

[Kalashnikov]

cool,looks like it was convertedd straight from age of empires

 

[kommunist]

YEah it's to very good!

 

[xxkevinnlxx]

great +5!

 

[X-OMG-X]

i like your models, and ofc this too
4/5

 

[China-Man]

Lovely model 5/5

 

[Mr. Bob]

lol I look back at this model, and I have to say:

This model kinda sucks... D: