Moderator
M
Moderator
17:43, 29th Mar 2009 by bounty hunter2:
Proper resource crediting X (Please mention each person by name.)
Proper description √
Proper author name √
Doesn't crash √
+ Two approval votes
Firstly, I urge you to post the resource creators by name. Just mentioning them as a group isn't proper crediting. But the model choice was great, that I must admit.
To continue, the terrain was done quite fine. Actually it was great. The tree choice should have been better but it still doesn't ruin it.
The spells were basically remakes of regular warcraft ones, with not so good tooltips and some typos. Recheck and fix them please.
The main building collision size is too small, I could go into it, increase it. I don't like how the swordsmen seem randomly placed aswell, you should make them symmetrical it gives you a better feel when starting the map.
Perhaps you should add gates to the entrances, it would be better I think. In later versions perhaps add secret heroes, more waves etc. Remember this is a single player map, thus its size doesn't matter.
With this I conclude my short review. I find this map satisfying, however still lacking more features, and thus it is Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating.
Proper resource crediting X (Please mention each person by name.)
Proper description √
Proper author name √
Doesn't crash √
+ Two approval votes
Firstly, I urge you to post the resource creators by name. Just mentioning them as a group isn't proper crediting. But the model choice was great, that I must admit.
To continue, the terrain was done quite fine. Actually it was great. The tree choice should have been better but it still doesn't ruin it.
The spells were basically remakes of regular warcraft ones, with not so good tooltips and some typos. Recheck and fix them please.
The main building collision size is too small, I could go into it, increase it. I don't like how the swordsmen seem randomly placed aswell, you should make them symmetrical it gives you a better feel when starting the map.
Perhaps you should add gates to the entrances, it would be better I think. In later versions perhaps add secret heroes, more waves etc. Remember this is a single player map, thus its size doesn't matter.
With this I conclude my short review. I find this map satisfying, however still lacking more features, and thus it is Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating.