Moderator
M
Moderator
19:27, 19th Jun 2009
hvo-busterkomo:
Coding: 5/5
The coding looks great. The spell is MUI and leak free. I prefer to avoid arrays when unnecessary but it doesn't matter, really. The system includes snippets of JASS where a GUI equivalent doesn't exist. The configuration was fine, but you could have used a bit more creative examples of usage.
Originality: 2/5
Not original, really. There are better jump systems available, negatively impacting this system's usefulness. Even your test map looks like a complete copy of Dynasti's.
Documentation: 0/5
Documentation is non-existent.
Overall = (Coding * 0.50) + (Originality * 0.30) + (Documentation * 0.20)
Overall: 3.1
Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating.
BPower: Considering the type of indexing we use nowadays, also
the high quality system we have. This one should no longer be used.
hvo-busterkomo:
Coding: 5/5
The coding looks great. The spell is MUI and leak free. I prefer to avoid arrays when unnecessary but it doesn't matter, really. The system includes snippets of JASS where a GUI equivalent doesn't exist. The configuration was fine, but you could have used a bit more creative examples of usage.
Originality: 2/5
Not original, really. There are better jump systems available, negatively impacting this system's usefulness. Even your test map looks like a complete copy of Dynasti's.
Documentation: 0/5
Documentation is non-existent.
Overall = (Coding * 0.50) + (Originality * 0.30) + (Documentation * 0.20)
Overall: 3.1
Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating.
BPower: Considering the type of indexing we use nowadays, also
the high quality system we have. This one should no longer be used.