This again? I stated my opinion to SF in the way not to start another debate, I didn't say your way is wrong my way is right. And now you got at me like I'm absolutely wrong while you guys are absolutely right. Believe me I have tons of thoughts to oppose your statement. But I will just wrap them all as short as possible: you are not a map maker. Try to place yourself as a competent mapmaker which cares a lot about rating, you want to achieve the best rating thus you worked so hardly, you even bother gathering a team for your map and passion. Then when you submit your map, you simply don't achieve your goal. And even worse, you see other less good maps got equal or better rating, what do you feel? I believe you won't understand this well, that's the problem.
I understand why that campaign is great and absolutely requires tons of hard works, judging from the terrain and the details of the story, it's just very obvious. When I say terrain, maybe you will think "so the beauty got your (Quilnez) heart." No, visual never got my heart, I say the terrain is so great is because I also judge the scale of the campaign, making beautiful consistent terrain for such huge-scaled is really not easy. How the author told the story very detailed is just another great plus point. (I don't want to start a debate, but really, Arkain is mostly otherwise.)
You guys judge based on your rational thought as a gamer "how this and that should probably be in your personal-ideal standard". While me that have already made some maps, I also bring my experience into my judgings, I judge maps from map maker's point of view. I understand which is actually hard to make in the map, which is actually a great addition in a map, which is actually requires lots of works in a map, and more importantly I understand well how a quality map should be. You simply judge based on your personal taste, and maybe also by considering other non-map maker users' too, but that's basically the same. I'm not saying that I know better than you, I'm not the truth, I just know more, so I got more references on my judging more than you. Maybe you also think that I think I deserve the moderator spot more than you, no, absolutely no, because I only play and review good maps
Believe me I got tons tons more of thought which I'm really intrigued to spoil here. But I will just get this as casual as possible.