Please read this.
I will no longer rate any resource submissions, as people get way too emotional over them. We had appeals because one of zbc's icons received a deserved DC, reasons being he was too new etc.
It is way too tiresome to try and find an average level that will satisfy everyone, so I will simply pull the plug of the source.
Oh, and I want to add that I did not moderate the example you chose. Every moderator has a different way of doing his job, everyone makes other decisions. Once a resource has been approved, there is no need to re-moderate it, unless it has been updated in the meantime.