13:15, 9th Jul 2009
Linaze: Do not upload the same map again if your old one got rejected. Now, I see you deleted that one so I'll let this one be and review it later. But in the future, use the update button.

18:21, 9th Jul 2009
Linaze: The terrain is still poor and your map lacks proper credits, you need to list the authors.

22:45, 22th Jul 2009
ap0calypse: Rejected.

The triggers are bad (they leak and are inefficient), some objects haven't been changed, the spells weren't too good (some standard, a few - leaky - custom).

Very bad description, no credits given.

I see that you tried to give credits oO
But you didnt name the creators themself, so pls fix that or your upload is against the rules.

Ok I just had a short bash with your map, here goes

-1st It was pretty well presented but could use a lot more work. There were plenty of grammar and spelling mistakes and tooltips that didn't make sense (0% crit chance anyone?). Fix this Please

-2nd The first hero I tried had all blizzard spells, and the research location didn't line up with the normal location. Its not very original and sloppy work.

-3rd The camera starting location was in the middle of fog, so player would have no idea where to go from there.

-4th Please credit makers of imports by name, either in game or in the description.

-5th The gameplay was essentially a 1 lane AoS. No Item, No Scoreboard, Not even anything stating your objectives. I LIKE simple gamepaly, but there has to be some gameplay there.

I would suggest you remove this and release at a time when it is move polished. Definably has potential the terrain was quite passable but you just need better Object editor and trigger work.

ok, where to start,
1. If it is Warsong Gulch from WOW why are there only 4 players?
2. Make more profesion heros.....
3. again if this is Warsong Gulch why do you need towers, and the other things, it should be just PvP nothing else...
4. make better terain.....

it might be worth your while to have a look at GLB's ctf map to see how it should be done

Try it now,there are over 30 items,over 50 custom spells,about 20 custom heroes.
I have added some lausy multiboard that counts kill and deaths.There are no towers,no attacking troops.
Instead of maximum 4 players there are 12 so you can play 6 v 6,i do not recomend 1 v1 because you will get bored it will be easy to transfer flag 3 times.

This map requires strategy,on example make 2 teams...First one will guard flag other guys will attack to conquer opponents flag,but you can also make rush with all players and take flag quickly but there is risk of losing your own flag.

Yes i had to add some stupid option to flag,if carrier drops flag after 20 seconds falg will be moved to starting location,no mather if its picked after droping.(Because there is no minimap signal and i was lazy to copy trigers my friend gave to me to make hero dummy flag unit)

I think i have done a lot,though this is my first serious map Please give me some more comments and suggestions.
Thank you.

ok, tested this 1 and herre is what I found,
1. The items, I don't get them could do better,
2. You can take your own flag, thats stupid,
3. Needs more heroes and needs better hero desciptions...
Thats it 4 me now will test the next 1 if u make more....