Shores of Andora

[Moderator]

17:03, 9th Apr 2009 by bounty hunter2:
Certanly the authors best melee, with decent terrain and idea, yet having some minor flaws, nearing a recommended rating, yet Approved with a 3/5 (Useful) rating.

You can find my full review on post #8.

 

[Eldrazor]

I can't open the "screenshots" tab.

 

[f0rsAk3n]

Here is my review:

Terrain: 4/5 Comment: Impressive terrain with a great feeling of environment.
Original: 5/5: Very few melee maps at The Hive.
Triggering: N/a Comment: Its melee...
Custom Material: N/a Comment: Well...Its melee
Fun factor: 4/5 Comment: The terrain gives it a certain feeling of playing in a well placed environment.


Overall comment: Great melee map with impressive terrain, excellent use of doodads.

*Make more use of Critters & Birds.
*Perhaps a gold mine in the island in the middle.
*Edit: Fix the Screen shot tab
*Edit2: Post a screenshot from above : P

Great map. Good terrain. I vote this map for Approval and i rate 4.3/5 {Recommended}

 

[bounty hunter2]

Set the creep sight to 200, it's quite imbalanced aswell. You should move the ports from bottom to up, since it takes longer with ships from the bottom then the upper players.

 

[Mechanical Man]

Andorra isn't surrounded by sea as far as I know.

 

[bounty hunter2]

Once lord Illidan raised the naga from the deeps Lady Vashj used her magics to raise the city of Andora. Andora was an ancient scientist city that was used for storing powerful magicical demons and spells. If Andoras powers is discovered demons is realesed.

I guess it's not the Pirenei Andorra.

 

[Grave_Digger_]

Andorra isn't surrounded by sea as far as I know.

No not Andorra Andora, some wierd name i got from a Bomberman Game on Gamecube

Attached images here so it would work...

 

[bounty hunter2]

bounty hunter2's Review on Shores of Andora

Proper description √
Proper author name √
Doesn't crash √

Shores of Andora is yet another melee map made by Grave_Digger_, where you take one of the four melee races and your goal is to kill the rest of the players, alone or with allyes. The map is for four players.

The terrain was very decent. The tilesets were great, they were varied enough and used properly. The dodoads were placed excellent. However the bottom islands have more trees then the upper ones, making it slightly imbalanced.

Talking about balance, the map is kinda symmetrical since there are four islands and four players. Yet as I mentioned two of the islands have more trees. Not just that, but the top islands have a slightly easier acces to the middle island, since it's closer to them.

The creeps used and drops were fine. I just don't like the idea of a creep group dropping two permament items, rather use a tome and a permament, or potion and permament.

The map is fun to play, since the entire concept with ships is entertaining. The middle island can prove to be vital to the conquerors.

To conclude, certanly your best melee, nearing 4/5, still it is 3/5 (Useful) and Approved. Keep up the good work.

 

[Revan(Rom)]

Well---> not really good

 

[Archipelago]

Well---> not really good

I thought it was good. . . What do you think is bad with this? Would be easier for him to imrpove if you tell him what he can improve. . .