Pet Melee Defense v3.7

[Moderator]

-- Earth-Fury --
Date: October 31st 2007
Action Taken: Approved
Rating: 4 / 10
Reason(s):
[*] Generally seems to work and function correctly

 

[Kaitech[SanD]]

Recommendation: Approve, just
Rationale: It is a very new idea

Pros:

[x] Easy to mass
[x] Quite a fast TD

Cons:

[x] Very hard to play, especially with gray's spawn
[x] Next to impossible to win on air, with all these melee units!

 

[Shanesgp]

Thanks for the feedback I knew about the air bug for sometime but I keep trying to fix it in the wrong way.oh and could you tell me whats wrong with gray spawn so i can fix it?

Everything should be fixed please send suggestions and feedback.

 

[hbk82]

question: how do i sell units?

 

[Shanesgp]

Sell Units

Currently you cannot im working on it for 3.0 but its different than normal mauls so its hard to make something to sell them.

 

[P4C-M4N]

The description is messy. Use the BB Code to improve the description.

 

[light bolt30]

Great to see an update from 3 years ago! Here's a list of BB Codes to add colour to that description, put those changelogs under hidden tags and add some screenshots incase people will judge you for that.

 

[Crave.]

NECROMANCY^^^
Anyway, this seems like an innovative idea, although it may be unbalanced due to you using melee units and all...

 

[P4C-M4N]

The description is still the same.

 

[Shanesgp]

The description is still the same.

eh sorry bout that I was scraped for time, fixing the old description now.

 

[Shanesgp]

Well its simple but it sure looks better

 

[x3GlikE]

testing map tell ya how it is,

 

[Yabooer]

The description is messy. Use the BB Code to improve the description.

Great to see an update from 3 years ago! Here's a list of BB Codes to add colour to that description, put those changelogs under hidden tags and add some screenshots incase people will judge you for that.

Hah, these guys and their need to point out every little flaw with a map, too bad this was approved a while ago when there was no rule like that, he doesn't need to change a thing.

 

[P4C-M4N]

Now it's much better!

 

[Mumbis]

Ok, I tried out the cat race, and I failed, was a little hard on my own hehe

It was a quite new idea to me... never seen a maul where you use units, i've seen alot with heroes and towers(of course) but not with units, so it was quite fun for as long as it lasted though i'm not the greatest maul player, so.. as I said above, I lost quite fast
but i'll give it 4/5 in "fun factor", but it wasn't completely original tho, since the terrain looks the same as all mauls (The pathing), but still, the idea to use units instead of towers and/or heroes was new!

Races

There weren't alot of races to choose from in my opinion (compared to other mauls) but my guess is that your not completely done with all the races yet
Found some things that I think is kinda "wrong" ... well their not wrong, but they don't fit kinda.

Worker

For example, a cat base... and then you train a crab to train your cats? That made me kinda annoyed
And a murloc to train anti air? x)
This is just my opinion, but I don't think it fits

Units

There were nothing wrong with the models and icons of the units you "built" or "Trained", the models fit the description,
but, the bear sound that they had was also a bit annoying, though it's easily fixed aswell.

The terrain was okay, not like all other mauls, just green grass and NOTHING else, you had trees everywere and some logs and stones etc, that made me happy that someone for once thinks about the terrain! 5/5 on that!
but I found something that was a bit annoying, not a big problem at all, just a little annoying imo:

Animal Handler

The Animal Handler could chop wood, easy fixable, just remove the Harvest ability and no one can get annoyed by it laters
And also, he was able to go into the other players areas to build "Animal Cages", which I think atleast isn't meant to happen?

Approved! 4/5!
Half original idea, good terrain detail (for being a maul) and imported models that looks attractive,
This is something I would recommend to maul players!

Hope it was to somekinda help to you!
And hope my english isn't to bad (not my main language!)

/Mumbis

 

[Shanesgp]

Thank you for the feedback Mumbis I am fixing all the issues and some other things right now and should have a new version out in an hour or 2.

 

[Mumbis]

No problem
just send a message to me if you want me to try something specific on the map!

Yours,
/Mumbis

 

[Cweener]

Hmmm updating a three year old map...
Interesting.

Well since things have gotten only harder on maps, you can always ask for a re-moderation, if you're curious if your map still would get approved nowadays.
Buttttt I wouldn't do that till you get all the little things fixed up.

 

[Shanesgp]

Hmmm updating a three year old map...
Interesting.

Well since things have gotten only harder on maps, you can always ask for a re-moderation, if you're curious if your map still would get approved nowadays.
Buttttt I wouldn't do that till you get all the little things fixed up.

If you review it, i'd be happy to fix any problems you may find,im just waiting for people to critique the game before I update again.

 

[Shanesgp]

3.6 is finally in the making here is some things to except
1.Newish map layout
2.Harder Gameplay
3.A new race, Dogs, whose talents include;slightly faster run speed,slightly above average attack speed,moderate damage and DOT bites.

 

[Mumbis]

@Shanesgp

3.6 is finally in the making here is some things to except
1.Newish map layout
2.Harder Gameplay
3.A new race, Dogs, whose talents include;slightly faster run speed,slightly above average attack speed,moderate damage and DOT bites.

I'll happily review the next update if you want me to

 

[Shanesgp]

@Shanesgp


I'll happily review the next update if you want me to

Thank you it would be out already but my computer decided to auto-update last night for some reason and i lost 3 hours of work on the map

 

[MR.Tricky]

The dog race units can't be sold(all of them i think)
kangaroo race's joey unit can be sold twice it's cost, and the others have increased sold amount that its cost(joey[buy=10/sell=20)(kangaroo[buy 50/sell 65])(i forgot about the others)
that is all....
it is a great map btw

 

[Shanesgp]

The dog race units can't be sold(all of them i think)
kangaroo race's joey unit can be sold twice it's cost, and the others have increased sold amount that its cost(joey[buy=10/sell=20)(kangaroo[buy 50/sell 65])(i forgot about the others)
that is all....
it is a great map btw

Allright ill get right on it sorry for the delay i've been busy