Paired Techtree Contest #4: Creep Attack Poll

[The World Is Flat]

Alright, at the point of desicion, the poll was even on two matters, so we decided to do paired and Creep Attack. Now we need to Decide some things.

Imports 1: (how many)

1) High

2) Low


Imports 2: (What Kind)

3) All

4) All (No non-public Resources)

5) All (Limited Spells)

6) Models/Icons/Skins

7) Models/Icons/Skins (No non-public Resources)


Judging: Public/Judges These are Averages.

8) 50/50

9) 25/75

10) 75/25

11) Only Public

12) Only Judges


If anything has been missed, I will do another poll.

 

[xxdingo93xx]

I'd vote for this ...

Imports 1: High
Imports 2: 5) (all except for spells and systems that actually do all the work for you)
Judge: 9)

I'd say the amount of imports being allowed shouldn't be low because that would limit the possibilities too much. There are lots of useful resources which actually weren't made just like that ... using them would be a wise idea

Ok, 'bout what imports should be allowed - I'd say spells and big systems shouldn't be allowed because the work somehow has to be made by the creators of the techtree and not by the creators of the systems ... Models/Icons/Skins should be acceptable (well, skins overwriting default textures ... I'm not sure).

About the judges - I'd say class before mass. Most people just vote for the techtrees which "look cool" but actually are very very easy to make. Some people work very hard for their techtrees to make something new, this should be respected. Thus I'd say judges' votings should be mightier, however public poll shouldn't be left out.

 

[Malcous]

Imports1 : High
Imports2: All ( except spells/systems)
Judge: 25/75

 

[Stanakin]

Imports 1: High
Imports 2: Models/Icons/Skins
Because making icons and stuff for the race is half the fun for me.

Judging: 50/50 (or 25/75)
Or only public if judging takes half a year again.

 

[Gyrosphinx]

Imports 1: High
Imports 2: Models/Icons/Skins - so that I can use my meagre modelling skills.
Judging: 25/75 - so that it will not be unfair for those who cannot make imports themselves.

 

[Avator]

Do you mind asking why you made it paired in the thread title after a poll where there were more votes for Not Paired? And do you mind me thinking your arrogance caused you to think that you have more to say about it then the majority on this site?

 

[The World Is Flat]

We made the decision before that vote was cast. It had been several Days Since a vote.

EDIT

And no i would'nt mind if you thought that way, it would be incorrect, but i wouldn't mind.

 

[Avator]

If you made that decision before you created the poll, then why did you add it as an answer?

And may I ask who decided that and what the reason was that you decided that?

 

[The World Is Flat]

I'm sorry, i don't follow. It was even when we finalized out descision. after we finalized it, somone voted. I'm sorry if i was unclear, but please do not flame me.

 

[Pharaoh_]

The World Is Flat, I have to agree with Avator here. The votes were 9 for Non paired and 8 for Paired. We talk in numbers here, right? That's why you made a poll. So, let's respect what most voted.

 

[The World Is Flat]

THEY VOTED AFTER THIS POLL WAS MADE.

What if somone votes right now? and changes it for even?

I'm jsut saying, there was a cutoff. I'm gonig to cut this off in a week or so. Because thats when people wanted the contest.

 

[Avator]

Why didn't you just ask for a mod to close the poll?

 

[Pharaoh_]

I was about to cast the same question
Anyway, whatever people agree on

 

[The World Is Flat]

Ok, well the reason was just that i forgot. rofl. Fail on my part, sorry for the confusion guys. (also pyritie LOVES to annoy me )

 

[supertoinkz]

High/All/25-75

also what kind of race?

• Mini race (wat we did lartime)
• Normal Race
• Big Race ( SC, SC2)

 

[The World Is Flat]

Big Race or normal race, because of the pairedness.

 

[Mr.Goblin]

Thanks The_World_is_flat for doing this....

and I do think it should be only judges that votes.. although that we have more time to polish the map.

 

[The World Is Flat]

Well, alot of ppl wanted me to redo the type vote, so i think we should do that.

Any OTHER polls to add to that?