Modeling Contest #11 - RESULTS!

[Pyritie]

Modeling Contest #11 - Chimera
RESULTS

'Sup.



(SuPa-'s score / 2) + (Lord_T's score / 2) + (votes/(total votes))*50 = (score)

Skrab

Mesh [13/15]
-The mesh is pretty decent, though a rather high polycount

Animation [8/10]
-Good use of in-game animations
-Includes many animations, as well

Texture [8/10]
-Includes team color
-Good use of in-game textures

Mechanics [5/5]
-Looks good in-game
-Functions properly
-Has a good portrait

Effects [4/5]
-It has a dissipate animation
-It has an attack sound
-Contains effects in the spell animation
-It has an attack sound

Creativity [3/5]
-It looks like it took some thought, but there are some pretty recognizable aspects to it

Total: 41

Mesh- 13/15
Another nice mesh. Good blend of parts, and an overall likable mesh. The hydra heads are practically unaltered though.. D:

Animations- 10/10
Great! I don't see how any other in-game animation set could have worked here, and they're edited to look very nice with the additional parts.

Texture- 8/10
The use of ingames in nice, but I have a problem with the harsh transition from wolf to scale and from fur to wings,it could have been done better.

Mechanics- 4/5
Works perfectly, with 1 problem.
-1 Wolf death sound plays on attack.

Effects- 5/5
Nice splats and sounds. Looks fine.

Creativity- 5/5
Another interesting concept. Tastes a bit generic, but it's cool.

Final Score: 45

(41 / 2) + (45 / 2) + (22/48)*50 = 65.9166667​

DonDustin

Mesh [13/15]
-Another pretty good mesh
-There looks to be a bit of unnecessary geometry in the face

Animations [9/10]
-Another hefty set of well used in-game animations

Texture [7/10]
-There was an okay use of textures here, though a lot seemed distorted
-The moon necklace, or whatever it is, is in stark contrast to the rest

Mechanics [3/5]
-The portrait is decent
-The dear-like portion of the model seems to be pretty much a blob

Effects [5/5]
-It has blood effects
-It has a dissipate animation
-Includes a death sound

Creativity [2/5]
-There really is nothing much creative about this model in its general theme

Total: 39

Mesh- 13/15
Quite a nifty mesh. The multiple layers of armor visible are neat, my only qualm is the helmet. Looks kinda ridiculous. Virtually seamless blend between torso and lower body.
-1 Kinda High poly

Animations- 9/10
Look incredible ingame, although they look silly and glichy in magos'. Most definately a good use of pitlord animations
-1 Death animation ends in a strange position, some of her is sticking through the ground.

Texture- 8/10
The Texture choice is very nice. It has some UV stretching issues, though.
Nice application of team color.

Mechanics- 5/5
Very nice appearance in-game, and the included icons are quite nice.

Effects- 4/5
Nice particles, an array of event sounds, but the blood effects are badly placed D:

Creativity- 3/5
An elf/stag... It's been done. However, the execution justifies it.

Final Score: 42

(39 / 2) + (42 / 2) + (10/48)*50 = 50.9166667​

Xatoga

Mesh [14/15]
-The mesh is pretty solid, with nothing really wrong with it
-Decent polycount
-UV Mapping seemed rather iffy

Animation [3/10]
-The animations are lacking, very static, and under exaggerated
-The attack animation appears to be looping

Texture [6/10]
-The texture is pretty blurry and undefined, especially on the model
-There is no team color, which could have been incorporated into, say, the eyes

Mechanics [3/5]
-The model itself looks decent enough in-game, despite its many flaws

Effects [1/5]
-As far as I could tell, it didn't have any effects

Creativity [5/5]
-Well, you did pretty good in this field, as I've really never seen something quite like this

Total: 32/50

Mesh- 11/15
A nice mesh. Quite clean, and not too high-poly. Very original.
-1 Seam of the model gives odd shading ingame... Looks like it wasn't welded.

Animations- 4/10
Despite how silly they look in magos, when applied to a gryphon rider, the model looks acceptable.
-2: Looping attack and death animations.

Texture- 7/10
The texture looks nice in-game, and it goes well with the model.
-1 The skin is a bit undefined, and stretches in some places.
-1 No Team color

Mechanics- 2/5
-3 Walk anim is stiff, and death and attack animations loop.

Effects- 0/5
No particles or events....

Creativity- 5/5
Very nice concept, I like it alot... A quadropedal spidercrow.

Final Score: 29

(32 / 2) + (29 / 2) + (16/48)*50 = 47.1666667​

1st - Skrab 2nd - DonDustin 3rd - Xatoga

Also, apparently Lord_T can't count.

 

[LiOneSS]

CONGRATULATIONS SKRAB! <3

yay.

 

[D a w n]

I´m 2nd?? D:
I would have never expected that


Oh and my model is just so high poly because of the weapon (1006 with has 834 without it :/ )

 

[Aeroblyctos]

And where are the models...? I would like to see them also.

 

[skrab]

Huraa!!!!

 

[Devine]

Congratz everyone.
Don, saved by the judges
It's no fail to lose from Skrab.

 

[Mechanical Man]

Well, I was also saved by judges. I managed to catch the last stair, finishing the last in voting session D:

 

[Lord_T]

Congratulations to all Contestants!

 

[s4nji]

If you see carefully on the bottom right side : "Also, apparently Lord_T can't count. "
BTW Congrats to Skrab!

 

[FrIkY]

Congratulations contestants!!!

 

[Lord_T]

If you see carefully on the bottom right side : "Also, apparently Lord_T can't count. "
BTW Congrats to Skrab!

OMaGawd! You're right! I can't count -.-

Lol, It wouldn't have made a difference, though.

D: I feel so silly.

 

[Pyritie]

OMaGawd! You're right! I can't count -.-

Lol, It wouldn't have made a difference, though.

D: I feel so silly.

On one of the contestants (I forget which) you had three categories out of 15, two out of 10, and one out of 5.

You also added them up to 60 for some reason instead of 50. >.=.>

 

[~Void~]

Kinda dumb criteria. Just because a model doesn't have effects doesn't mean it's bad/should lose points. Actually, effects tend to ruin a model (assuming you mean particles and all that).

 

[SuPa-]

Well, "Effects" didn't really make a difference, anyway, but yeah, I don't think it deserves its own catagory