Modeling Competition 4 Poll!

[Deleted member 126647]

Vote for your favorite mech.

Supa-'s Centaur Robot

Mechanical Man's At-Te

Kofi_Banan's UHI-0

Good luck all contestants, thanks for participating.

 

[Mini-Me]

Hard pick. Wasnt really impressed by any of the submissions. I'll go with Kofi_Banan's UHI-O. It was the only model of those three that I could imagine in a map.

 

[anetherond]

I think noun of the entries is good. But I vote for the best, I guess.

 

[Pyritie]

I thought RDZ submitted his...

 

[SuPa-]

He canceled his submission. It's a shame a lot of people didn't finish :C

My animations are rather plain and messed up, especially on the attack animations because the feet moved in sync with the attack, when they should have moved before the body and arms went forward. My walk animation also goes pretty slow (and doesn't look like how a horse walks but I didn't intend it to) And on the attack animation with his right hand the elbow pops out

Kofi's model is OK, but the texture's pretty simple. Also the animations are rough and there's no decay. I haven't tested it in-game but the death animation's bugged in Magos. Also some of the parts of the texture look CnP'd

Mechanical Man's robot has a decent model and texture, and the animations for what they are are OK. The only I problem I have is that it doesn't move in about half of the animations

I really don't know which of the two I'm gonna vote for :-/

 

[ragingspeedhorn]

Very sad as some good models were in the thread, ahh well. Of the current ones I prefer Kofi_Banan's.

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

the centaur robot has the best skin, the at-te has the best model, but the soldier has the most practicality. i choose the soldier

 

[SuPa-]

"The model must be textured, either in-game textures, or custom textures. If custom, made by yourself."

I sense a disturbance in the force (CnP)

 

[Kofi_Banan]

It's crapy i know , made in PhotoFiltre and Gimp 2.0 . Where is disturbance.

 

[Pyritie]

Then again, it's the end result that counts.

 

[Rao Dao Zao]

Let's not turn this into an "end justifies the means" discussion.

 

[donut3.5]

I didn't really like any of these..
The texture's on the AT-TE and soldier were.. not exciting.
The mesh on Supa-'s didn't really look mechanical, it looked a bit curvy.
However, after viewing the animations, I ruled the AT-TE out. Many of them barely moved, which disappointed me. The soldier's feet moved oddly during a few animations.
In the end, I chose Supa-'s model mostly because of the cool texture, and also the animations looked the most natural.
--donut3.5--

 

[DwarfZealot]

rdz why didn't you submit yours?

 

[Massive_attack]

*sigh* Well i promised i would vote for SuPa, plus he's is the only one with truely working anims, even if he is bashing the other modelers about it. Also: give mechanical man a break he did his best !

 

[SuPa-]

your promised you'd vote for me? dun remember XD

And I wasn't bashing the other modelers, mainly giving critiques (but I did go all HKCJHA&#CDHLO*& at Kofi (Shados told me too ))

 

[Mechanical Man]

Those static animations were made on purpose, as the vehicle is massive and and recoil of guns can't affect it. And where did you see these kind of units move when not walking, I mean if you look at other games tanks (c&c) and other similar vehicles does not move at all when standing still, maybe unless they have a radar dish, flags or something. My inspiration was the game star wars: battlefront (as I didn't see the newer movies), where this machine is immobile when not walking.

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

"The model must be textured, either in-game textures, or custom textures. If custom, made by yourself."

I sense a disturbance in the force (CnP)

Leave your rule-breaking suspicions and your constant campaigning for the admins. This is unbiased voting time.

 

[ragingspeedhorn]

The lights are typical GIMP work which kinda leaves out CnP I think.

 

[WILL THE ALMIGHTY]

Where the fuck is RDZ's submission?

EDIT: Oh. Dang. Couldn't finish mine though.

 

[SuPa-]

He canceled his submission

The top gray thing of the texture looks like CnP and the bottom left gray thing looks like CnP, which was then recolored a dark green

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

Those static animations were made on purpose, as the vehicle is massive and and recoil of guns can't affect it. And where did you see these kind of units move when not walking, I mean if you look at other games tanks (c&c) and other similar vehicles does not move at all when standing still, maybe unless they have a radar dish, flags or something. My inspiration was the game star wars: battlefront (as I didn't see the newer movies), where this machine is immobile when not walking.

Obviously, large heavy mechs of such have a right to not move when not walking.

 

[Reager]

My vote goes to Mechanical Man's At-Te since in my opinion its the most well done.
Centaur's animations are weird and Kofi_Banan's robot seems to be made out of wood.

 

[Jaakko]

Only three submissions? :/ I have to say that looking at the pictures I didn't have a favorite.

 

[Mechanical Man]

Obviously, large heavy mechs of such have a right to not move when not walking.

Actually, is moving when walking. :/

 

[Pyritie]

Oh. Dang. Couldn't finish mine though.

Whatever happened to yours? I could use a little smallish drone like yours...

 

[Arab4life]

well i have to agree that the submissions are pretty terrible, which is why i have decided to vote for blizzard, whose clockwork goblin was the best by far...

Too bad blizzard didnt enter, which is why i give my vote to Mechanical man, the AT-TE looks the best in my opinion, the centuar looks freakin aneroxic or however it is spelled, and the soldier seems to be made out of cubes put together with some sort of cream cheese can gun.

 

[tomwil]

I dont like Supa's it looks like a bugged mannequin from cheap shop ,lack of details and good idea. Mechanicals work is very impresive , accurate to the original SW unit. Kofi's model has very low quality , i only like the concept a bit.

 

[Xatoga]

Def voting for Mechanical Man's. AT-TE = Star Wars, and to vote against something from Star Wars would be a sin Plus, it is a great model really, and people, it'd not like it should bob up and down while standing, its a huge machine, it doesn't need to breathe...

As for me, I didn't finish my animations in time, since they kept exporting wierd, even when I did zero joints right and everything. I've gotta go back and read up on finalizing better I believe.

 

[SuPa-]

Did you comment "Linear" on every bone?

My vote goes to Mechanical Man (I especially like the walk) I really gotta give you a compliment for the walk animation because my model has FOUR legs and I was two lazy to do a sequence of movements and instead made both the front legs move at the same time and both of the back legs move at the same time. You have SIX which is omg pwnage

 

[Cavman]

Though I like SuPa's style, and Koif's Idea, I ahve to say my vote goes to Mech-man.

 

[Xatoga]

Did you comment "Linear" on every bone?

Wait huh? That could be it What does that do/how do you do it?

 

[SuPa-]

Xatoga, under the "joints" tab it lists every bone

select them one at a time and press the "comment" button for each one and type "Linear" (without quotations of course) on the first line. do this for EVERY bone, it'll probably fix the problem

 

[Massive_attack]

Ah well i see then, and i promised that to you when you made my helmet, some time in chat i believe.

 

[TheSecretArts]

actually, i win, but Gmax won once more.

 

[RED BARON]

Voting for either supa or mecman, cant realy deside... like the attachment for the arms on supa's and the style of mecmans. (No comments to anim)
Hmm think I vote for supa.

Raaly a shame that so many didnt finish, I do realy hope that both WILLTHEALMIGHTY and Jigral post there sometime

 

[InStars]

I voted for Kofi_Banan's UHI-0 ,cuz all the other models are too weird (weird bad).
A mechanical centaur and a tank with legs... ...Come on!

 

[SuPa-]

Xatoga, you get your animations fixed?

InStars, it's not a "tank with legs" I think.

 

[Mechanical Man]

InStars, never seen Star Wars?

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

I voted for Kofi_Banan's UHI-0 ,cuz all the other models are to weird (weird bad).
A mechanical centaur and a tank with legs... ...Come on!

You honestly don't know what AT-TE is?

 

[InStars]

InStars, never seen Star Wars?

I have seen few star wars movies ,but i never liked ''the tank with legs'' idea

 

[Deleted member 126647]

Kofi_Banan is the official winner of Modeling Competition #4!

2nd place goes to Supa- and 3rd goes to Mechanical Man.

Congratulations!

 

[Wolverabid]

Congratulations Kofi_Banan!

GJ all modelers!

Prizes to be awarded within several days.

 

[WILL THE ALMIGHTY]

Whatever happened to yours? I could use a little smallish drone like yours...

Lazyness in rigging and animating. Feel free to ask to continue it if you want, but maybe I'll finish it eventually.

 

[Mechanical Man]

InStars, are you Latvian? I would ask you some things.