Invasion

[Moderator]

17:28, 12th Mar 2014
Hell_Master: Map approved with a rating of 4/5 (Recommended). See Shadow Fury's review for more information:

Much better than sudden death, this time I can list good points and not only the bad ones. Here is my review:-

GOOD POINTS:-
- Great use of tile variation
- Very well done terrain
- Creep camps are also well done
- Proper item drops

BAD POINTS:-
- The corners are very restricted that letting my entire army reach the Marketplace is impossible
- Tile variation could be better at the corners
- The southern and northern parts of the map have a lack of tile variation by looking at the rest of the map
- Still no screenshots in the description

SUGGESTIONS:-
- Add screenshots as I suggested in your first melee map
- More tile variation at the southern and northern parts
- Improve the tile variation in the corners too
- Widen the playable area at the corners because it's too small and restricted so this severely hinders my army from getting past

Till now, this gets 4/5 and my vote for APPROVAL! Good job

 

[Shadow Fury]

Much better than sudden death, this time I can list good points and not only the bad ones. Here is my review:-

GOOD POINTS:-
- Great use of tile variation
- Very well done terrain
- Creep camps are also well done
- Proper item drops

BAD POINTS:-
- The corners are very restricted that letting my entire army reach the Marketplace is impossible
- Tile variation could be better at the corners
- The southern and northern parts of the map have a lack of tile variation by looking at the rest of the map
- Still no screenshots in the description

SUGGESTIONS:-
- Add screenshots as I suggested in your first melee map
- More tile variation at the southern and northern parts
- Improve the tile variation in the corners too
- Widen the playable area at the corners because it's too small and restricted so this severely hinders my army from getting past

Till now, this gets 4/5 and my vote for APPROVAL! Good job

 

[Ken-E]

Played the map, the design is pretty neat and innovative for a melee map. No major issue here. Could you add description to all your maps; all of them seems to have Nodescription on the lobby.

4/5 from me.

 

[eubz]

Downloading...I'll give you a full review later.
=================================
1. I like the use of tilesets and height variations. The layout is very much balanced.
2. On item drops, you used item tables and I found out there are some that drops specific items.
3. Nothing more I could say but one thing more. There are 12, 500 goldmines guarded by green creep camps. Can you change this to orange, perhaps.

I vote for approval with 4/5 ratings.