defend carlisle

[Moderator]

18:13, 27th Feb 2009
Rui: The people who commented don't seem to have liked this map. Here on the Hive, we do not appreciate of low quality maps either. Use EpicWar if you really want to have your map up for download.
Rejected.

 

[xenoche]

Those poor models...

I am sad to see such nice models in a map that is of this low caliber.

If this is your first then its alright, you can learn a lot by going to the maps section of this very site and clicking the little 'recommended maps' button, searching defense maps.
Notice the nicely built terrains and custom made units, items and pace of the game itself.

Your terrain is awful. Where was the castle? All I saw were blizzard city cliffs that look shocking at best. See that little icon next to the title of this post? That looks more like a castle than anything in your map I'm afraid.
I played solo and I could simply attack-move to the enemy boss, who was for some reason, imprisoned in a room blockaded by a extraordinarily liberal use of boulder towers, and I won. (In harsher words, completely skillful-less).

wow...

 

[APproject]

Horrible terrain. My impression is like, no doodads - no destructibles. Bad spells description. No Quest objectives. Never relised who's the leader of your enemy, also couldn't find the unit that supposed to survive. Not imported unit models's portraits. Inbalance. Horrible heroes' names and proper names. Awful description of map in hiveworkshop.

Afterall, this map is cheaply made. Pay more attention to small details and other trifles including enviroment or decent units.

I give 1/5.

To increase the rating of mine, you must work on this map at least 3 times longer than you started creating it and ended on this. However, I don't think you'll try to improve this map.

 

[Chief_Of_GxBxL]

Alright, I'm interested to find out if this is one of your first maps or not. If it is, I do agree with the first comment in saying that you should look at other maps. Here is what I thought while playing this game. You should consider these to make your map really better.

1) There is no castle. Just a bunch of cliffs.
2) Is it necessary to have 10+ fountains, especially in spots you can't see them?
3) Re-do your monster names
4) Near the final boss, there shouldn't be an absolute mass of towers. It's just a bit laggy and annoying.
5) Try limiting the amount of heroes down to 1 per each human player. They level up too fast, which makes it too easy to kill the final boss.

So in general, just spend more time on your maps. Learn from this wc3 modding site, and just experiment and test. Ask questions and things like that.