Challenge PrinceOFFame vs Vadim 647

[PrinceOfFame]

Challenge Theme:
texturing



Challenger:
PrinceOFFame


Opponent(s):
Vadim 647


Challenge Duration:
5 days



Proposed Reputation Award:
10



Challenge judging:
Gilles



Map-specific conditions:
Theme:none

File size:none


Imports allowed:none


Optimization/protection:none


Other:none


Model-specific conditions:

File size:none


Polycount:none


Other:none



Texture-specific conditions:

File size:Every


Other:Every


Other challenge conditions:
Details:
Skin must be maked on Model of SH(shadow hunter):

 

[PrinceOfFame]

Skins look like this!

1.Skin is my its name is ShadowHunter:

2.Skin is maked by Vadim 647 its name is DeathHunter:

Shadow Hunter by:PrinceOFFame
DeathHunter by:Vadim 647

 

[Vadim 647]

Accepted

 

[Misha]

Hmm.. neither of you has done much... it think i'll wait a bit more to express my opinion.

ATM i like the darker skin more.... Work moar Prince XD catch him x3

 

[Gilles]

You've already made the skins? I'm confused, what's going on?

I'm not much of a texture judge. I'd suggest asking someone else.

 

[PrinceOfFame]

U know what we maked skins at same night when i maked thread so we maked it in time what we should make it but i making this skin until Monday ;P ...

 

[Gilles]

I'm guessing English isn't your native language.
So you made this thread, you guys made your skins that are posted, but you're still working on yours?

 

[PrinceOfFame]

No When i finish it i will say but i need about half an hour or small......xD

 

[Misha]

Neither skin has been worked on much... =/

well... i think that the green one is (barely) better.
now to wait on challenge judges

~Misha~

 

[PrinceOfFame]

omfg Vadim has just Used Hue and Saturation and bit Smudge and he will win vs my Freehand..No word....xD...It is Truth he have no Freehand everything is Unlife Color ..@!

 

[CloudWolf]

Ill admit, im going to vote for princeoffame on this one, because his skin actually shows some custom skinning. While Vadim's looks nice in game, it appears to me he just used one of those "Brightness and Contrast" filters as theres no obvious sign of any skinning :/ I could be wrong though

 

[PrinceOfFame]

W8 sec

Ill admit, im going to vote for princeoffame on this one, because his skin actually shows some custom skinning. While Vadim's looks nice in game, it appears to me he just used one of those "Brightness and Contrast" filters as theres no obvious sign of any skinning :/

I see how he doned it Changed Skin with Saturation to gray then bright and contrast and Smudge tool for some parts!!!

 

[Azeroc]

Vadim has a little little better looking than the green one, but he has only manipulated with normal bright and contrast , but Prince has made custom skinning, And custom is in 1st place so I make prince to be winner if i would have such power =D


Meh my old skinning editor is somehow broken, Can someone tell some site to DL some skin editor ?

 

[Misha]

....do not get too cheery guys, because both skins are rated 2/5 on my list, and that means Lacking. Thank you ?=3

 

[HappyTauren]

They're both horrible, but prince's one is a bit less horrible of the two.

 

[Azeroc]

Then why the hell this challange was accepted ?

 

[Zombie]

They're both horrible, but prince's one is a bit less horrible of the two.

Qft.

 

[Pyritie]

They're both horrible, but prince's one is a bit less horrible of the two.

This.

EDIT: ah shit, voted for the wrong one. meh

 

[HappyTauren]

Not that it makes much difference, though.

 

[PrinceOfFame]

This.

EDIT: ah shit, voted for the wrong one. meh

Why...He just changed colour with Hue/Satiration and and changed Brightness!!

 

[Ham Ham]

The Deathhunter looks better, but that skin just got collor saturation\light manipulated. Prince's one is not cool as the Deathhunter, but since he really put some real texturing work on it, my vote is for Prince.

 

[Gilles]

Then why the hell this challange was accepted ?

I never actually accepted it. I don't know why people are voting. I still don't really get what happened, and they really didn't go through the right process for approval.

 

[PrinceOfFame]

Pls Gilles We maked Skins After I posted this i didnt know how much Skining will take...So i maked in in 2 hours...xD

 

[RaijinSpark]

Shadowhunter!!

 

[Vadim 647]

Whatever. I made my skin in a hour, because being requested by one to get him some rep in this way, and the one was modyfiying his skin periodicaly & editing the thread.
And basicaly true, it's just several steps of conditional hue\saturation, then one overblend layer to add few highlights, and smudge tool. All this done in Paint.net, a free graphical editor.

 

[Avator]

No wonder. One took 1 hour and the other took 2 hours to make their skin. Sorry to say, but they're both terrible. I'm not going to vote for either, because if you'd upload something like this here, they would get 1/5 from me and probably the moderators as well because nearly nothing is done with it.

To make it even worse, this thread is actually not allowed, because there was no starting date, no format, no real submission, no reward, pretty much no nothing. It's no more then a thread made to post 2 skins for your own entertainment only.

 

[Vadim 647]

I wont upload that to hive. too low quality.
Gilles, if you don't want to accept this, let it be. This doesn't matter for me (just make sure that thread will be deleted )

 

[Gilles]

Okay.

 

[PrinceOfFame]

I think you should say to us is this Acepted or rejected bcs i need This win....xD

 

[Azeroc]

Now... Gilles If you want this to be accepted IT must not be 10 rep reward, Its too high for such very low-quality textures...

I suggest some 5 rep or 3 if this is accepted...

 

[Devine]

I'm challaging PrinceOfFame next. No offence.

 

[Avator]

Come on man... That's not even fun anymore.
Even a teaspoon would beat either of them!

 

[Gilles]

Watch the flaming Avator. Remember that everyone starts somewhere.

This challenge is getting archived. If you want to have a proper one, please follow the rules.

 

[PrinceOfFame]

So we can make new one?

 

[Gilles]

Of course.