2Player: Human03

[Moderator]

09:48, 23rd Feb 2014
Hell_Master: Map approved with a rating of 3/5 (Acceptable). See moderator's review for more information:

Review emerges!

I have played your 2P Campaign: Human 03 and I must say, fair and good like your others. Let's get straight to the point and the two things I noted from your previous maps still persists until here namely, the broken color code on the 3rd spell of Captain Falric and also that there should be a slight difference or advantages/disadvantages between the Footman and Axeman which is Axeman has higher damage but medium armor and the Footman has higher armor but medium damage. As an additional as well, you could make the Footman's ability Defend but for the Axeman, I would suggest maybe that serves useful for his damaging capabilities such as Bloodlust for faster attack rates or Enrage, faster attack rates but suffers more on damages, depends on you.

The Abomination boss at the end could have also dropped some items or gave some rewards like gold rewards or item rewards so it could be that worth fighting.

Anyway, rated 3/5 and Acceptable.

 

[PlankingWolf]

The abomination skin might look too high quality for the terrain and other units around it. Otherwise, it's a good map.

 

[Heinvers]

On the contrary. That texture fits well. Already tested this. I'll review it later.

 

[sonofjay]

Maybe since you took the time to use a different skin for the Abo then maybe you can also do that for Jaina and Arthas?

 

[PlankingWolf]

Maybe since you took the time to use a different skin for the Abo then maybe you can also do that for Jaina and Arthas?

The Arthas that you suggested doesn't even look a bit like Arthas. And I think some people like the vanilla feel of Warcraft better than custom crud everywhere.

 

[sonofjay]

The Arthas skin is just quick search on the skin section. He can search a better one. And whats the harm with that? The default Arthas looks shitty anyway.

And Captain Falric's model looks more superior than the main protagonist.

 

[Heinvers]

Agree jay. For now this will remain. And no, the abominations skin is still lowHQ @wolf.

 

[Pyraeus]

The Arthas skin is just quick search on the skin section. He can search a better one. And whats the harm with that? The default Arthas looks shitty anyway.

And Captain Falric's model looks more superior than the main protagonist.

Captain Falric does look more superior, I do agree. That was bothering me as well. However, even if I did implement these custom skins. Falric would still out match them and beat them in looking hotter then the others. It's too bad Chrome or CloudWolf didn't do Arthas Menethil in a professional matter as well. Because one way or another. Implemented or not. Still Falric would look better looking. As for the Abomination. In the other chapters it's a unit. Only in this one is this skin used, because an abomination hero was made.

P.S: I really wish there was a Arthas Version of this - http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/skins-552/cw_turalyon-blp-182157/?prev=status%3Dg%26search%3DPaladin%26d%3Dlist%26r%3D20 - xD

 

[Yousef]

Wow, your maps are always amazing, and I see here captain Luc and Falric, there was a third captain, will he appear?

 

[Pyraeus]

Wow, your maps are always amazing, and I see here captain Luc and Falric, there was a third captain, will he appear?

Yep, the third captain being "Captain Marwyn". He originally appears during Hearthlagen where he will make his appearance.

 

[Binsu]

Review emerges!

I have played your 2P Campaign: Human 03 and I must say, fair and good like your others. Let's get straight to the point and the two things I noted from your previous maps still persists until here namely, the broken color code on the 3rd spell of Captain Falric and also that there should be a slight difference or advantages/disadvantages between the Footman and Axeman which is Axeman has higher damage but medium armor and the Footman has higher armor but medium damage. As an additional as well, you could make the Footman's ability Defend but for the Axeman, I would suggest maybe that serves useful for his damaging capabilities such as Bloodlust for faster attack rates or Enrage, faster attack rates but suffers more on damages, depends on you.

The Abomination boss at the end could have also dropped some items or gave some rewards like gold rewards or item rewards so it could be that worth fighting.

Anyway, rated 3/5 and Acceptable.

 

[Pyraeus]

Review emerges!

I have played your 2P Campaign: Human 03 and I must say, fair and good like your others. Let's get straight to the point and the two things I noted from your previous maps still persists until here namely, the broken color code on the 3rd spell of Captain Falric and also that there should be a slight difference or advantages/disadvantages between the Footman and Axeman which is Axeman has higher damage but medium armor and the Footman has higher armor but medium damage. As an additional as well, you could make the Footman's ability Defend but for the Axeman, I would suggest maybe that serves useful for his damaging capabilities such as Bloodlust for faster attack rates or Enrage, faster attack rates but suffers more on damages, depends on you.

The Abomination boss at the end could have also dropped some items or gave some rewards like gold rewards or item rewards so it could be that worth fighting.

Anyway, rated 3/5 and Acceptable.

Most of the ideas accepted and implemented. Axeman updated. Abomination drops "Gloves of Spell Mastery" for Jaina Proudmoore. As I said before. Color code of the Captain's Command Aura for some reason refuses to work and I tried everything.

Abilities:
To inform you. I plan to also make this campaign somewhat realistic. So the units that can use the defend animation will always have defend on themselves. Custom abilities will be added to each unit, even the footman, in later chapters of my campaign. In chapter five. New abilities will be featured for both the footman and axeman that will divide them. Hope you understand.

 

[Lockheart]

I love your 2P Campaigns. On top there are not so many good 2 P RPGs out there.
Please keep up the good work. I appreciate it a lot.

For now I especially need this post to give the map the rating it deserves imho.

 

[kakuzu]

A very good remake , nice work !

 

[MogulKahn]

Seems interesting and unique. Gonna try it!

 

[Verb8im]

I noticed that on the Main Quest update when you first get it, it says Arthas, Jaina, Falric, and Luc must survive, but when I go into my quest journal, it still has the vanilla Arthas and Jaina must survive, with no Falric or Luc.

 

[Pyraeus]

I noticed that on the Main Quest update when you first get it, it says Arthas, Jaina, Falric, and Luc must survive, but when I go into my quest journal, it still has the vanilla Arthas and Jaina must survive, with no Falric or Luc.

Yes, from all the stuff I fix. I manage to screw up the littlest things. If you don't mind, because you got an good eye. Are you interested in being a "Beta-Tester"? You would test my maps before I even release them, this would help me greatly. Here's some rep, thank you once again.

 

[Verb8im]

Yes, from all the stuff I fix. I manage to screw up the littlest things. If you don't mind, because you got an good eye. Are you interested in being a "Beta-Tester"? You would test my maps before I even release them, this would help me greatly. Here's some rep, thank you once again.

Falric has Steam Engineered Shield on 3rd level. So far its just 2nd level that he doesn't. Haven't tried 4th level yet, so don't know about that one yet. If I see anything else on 3rd level that you said is supposed to be there from the updates that's not, I'll let you know

 

[Pyraeus]

Falric has Steam Engineered Shield on 3rd level. So far its just 2nd level that he doesn't. Haven't tried 4th level yet, so don't know about that one yet. If I see anything else on 3rd level that you said is supposed to be there from the updates that's not, I'll let you know

Good, it will be really helpful. Thank you.