(9 ratings)
Well before Shadow comes to review this map, i will give it a 5/5. I already tested it with Pyraeus and i can say that it's pretty darn good. Soo yeah, it's good even though it's a huge improvement to Blizzard's campaign It's also fun!
- More innovative changes because it's too similar to the original map
Don't want be rude, but this map should be simple,what could be add in this map since Blizzard has made it for teach the players how to play the campaign... don't have many things to do in additional. He just made this for have all the maps in 2-player, and for story as well.
Anyway, good map xD
Nice map, though it resembles a lot the original one. Here is my review anyway:-
- In the initial cinematic, I see the circle of power and the banner. Not good
- What is the importance of dismount to Thrall if it doesn't give any advantage? It's a nonsense ability
- In the final cinematic, Nazgrel is once hidden by a tree and sometimes he comes at the borders of the camera
- I know it's for 2 players, but if I play single, why can't I control Nazgrel and his troops?
SUGGESTIONS:-
- Hide the circle of power and the banner in the initial cinematic
- Let dismount give an advantage and disadvantage when used, like increased movement and/or attack speed but lesser HP
- Let player 1 control Nazgrel and his troops in case the map is played solo
- Nazgrel should be clearly seen in the final cinematic even if he isn't the main character
- More innovative changes because it's too similar to the original map
OVERALL RESULT:-
To conclude, this map is far too similar to the original map. I'll give it 3/5 and vote for APPROVAL!
Don't worry, you've not been rude.
Anyway, here is a list of new things that could be added:-
1- Instead of Forked Lightning, a custom ability would be better
2- The terrain could be improved with some custom trees and plants
3- Custom creeps like Gnoll Overlord, Murloc Pillager, Forest Troll Shaman etc...
There are much more new things that could be added, that's why my rating is 3/5
What's your problem Mr.Shadow??? I don't care about your defeat comment. It's still a 5/5 rating. IT IS INTENDED TO RESEMBLE THE ORIGINAL MISSION BUT WITH A MORE INTENSE GAMEPLAY!
All right guys, you convinced me to raise my rating to 4/5, but not to 5/5 Mr.Heinvers
Wow, a remake of a tourial. FREAKING ANWSOME!!!
This should be useful for any 2 newcomers to Warcraft who want to learn together. If you guys know any 2 new guys to Warcraft, send them this.
Edit: Shadow Fury's review wasn't that so useful, I have to agree with the other guys.
It's meant to be very similar to the original one, but with a few touches and a dash of two player madness.
Also, giving a map a "custom" something doesn't make it all that better. You keep on going on and on with the custom stuff.
No offense though, I just really, really disagree.
Everyone makes mistakes but please do avoid so in the future. Cheer up there, Shadow Fury. Mistakes is a part of reviewing and you need just to accept that and to learn in it.
There are 2 players map around here in hive which has been rated as 4/5 like of TheSpoon's campaign but maybe there are much more work in here.
And also, there are nothing more of a change that can be acceptable here without actually making everything SO custom which defeats the purpose of creating a 2 player map of a campaign but still maintaining its lore and contents at some ways.
But maybe terrain improvements are possible with imported files and such..
To be honest, I did not judge the map through how long it is being played but on the bugs I can found on the game but maybe I could also consider what you said.
Thanks for that long wall of text. That can help me improve in some ways as a moderator to be honest.
Look spaorc. I gave my rating of what I thought this map is worth after playing it! I haven't crossed other people's opinions. So before criticizing me look at arguments I brought! No offense but skip the Mr. part!
What's your problem Mr.Shadow??? I don't care about your defeat comment. It's still a 5/5 rating. IT IS INTENDED TO RESEMBLE THE ORIGINAL MISSION BUT WITH A MORE INTENSE GAMEPLAY!
You really can't blame a guy rating a map with a high mark even though you think it should only receive low mark even though you even made solid points because the guy rated the map base on his taste. Actually you shouldn't even bother arguing because its pointless and take this from a guy who is part of a forum where a single stuff receives hundreds and thousands of user ratings and trying to argue with their rating be it base on their taste or constructive criticism is simply futile.
I personally understand your opinion. You must know that i'm not a person that keeps fueling the fire even after the flame has been put out.I apologise if I disrespected the personal opinion of anyone in this thread.
I believe you are right. I am just bothered by the fact that people throw high ratings here and there. That way high ratings loose their purpose and weight. That way a great map becomes equal with a map in which no more than 3-4 hours have been invested.
I apologise if I disrespected the personal opinion of anyone in this thread.
The Hive Workshop Official |
Map Reviewer: Daffa the Mage Map Name: 2P Exodus 01 Map Author: Blizzard Entertainment/Pyraeus PresentationMax Score : 70 [+30 Bonus Pts]Description fulffills all of the requirement for a map. Models/Skins aren't credited for each person, only THW, Blizzard and WC3C are mentioned, please credit each person you use their models or skins. [-3 Pts] Score: 67/100 TriggersMax Score : 80 [+20 Bonus Pts]In beginning, even by typing a-easy I still get easy mode (I think) and the game begins. You need to ensure people only type -easy and nothing else to ensure no random issues happened, same applies to AForce and AVision commands. [-10 Pts] Some of the triggers are leaky, but since this one is based on Blizzard Campaign Map, I won't really put it into issue, but I recommend clean them to make the map run faster and smoother, some of them are blizzard mistake, but all of them should be purged however. [-40 Pts] The rest are pretty much good, no issues with Gameplay, map also seems to be lag free in my case. [+5 Pts] Score: 35/100 Object DataMax Score : 100No issues found Score: 100/100 GameplayMax Score : 50 [+50 Bonus Pts]Pretty much the gameplay are similar to the original campaign map, there's nothing much of a difference however, I was expecting some more content than the current. 2P and Nazgrel + Warlock addition seems good enough for me however. [+5 Pts] Score: 51/100 Final Score: 63.250/100 3/5 Vote for Approval Contact: (Visitor Message) / (Private Message) / (Map Reviewers) |