Moderator
M
Moderator
00:32, 11th May 2010
Kimberly: I will approve this as it appears to be of good quality, but LOTS of room for improvement. Tested ingame and seems to work very well. However, I still suggest you work on your shading/highlights. The light sources are quite uneven and the highlights on some areas are rather odd making it look flat and abit plain. Although its good you have included team colour in this one, its still abit TOO subtle.. I tested it ingame and I could barely tell the 2 fighting same-skinned opposing aboms apart.
As a personal suggestion, why don't you post your skins in the texture forum section to gather more constructive feedback on how to your improve your skins, it may offer abit more resourceful critic/feedback there than here and possibly improve your technique greatly.
UPDATE FROM KIM: Hi, sorry for this obscure change, but I had a talk with another Skin mod and it seems we had agreed you apply the teamcolour properly (so its noticeable/distinct) ingame before approval, as its rather unfair of me to approve of this skin after breaking that agreement with other mod. I hope you understand and that you can easily and quickly change this, contact me when you have done so.
-Cheers, Kim.
Kimberly: I will approve this as it appears to be of good quality, but LOTS of room for improvement. Tested ingame and seems to work very well. However, I still suggest you work on your shading/highlights. The light sources are quite uneven and the highlights on some areas are rather odd making it look flat and abit plain. Although its good you have included team colour in this one, its still abit TOO subtle.. I tested it ingame and I could barely tell the 2 fighting same-skinned opposing aboms apart.
As a personal suggestion, why don't you post your skins in the texture forum section to gather more constructive feedback on how to your improve your skins, it may offer abit more resourceful critic/feedback there than here and possibly improve your technique greatly.
UPDATE FROM KIM: Hi, sorry for this obscure change, but I had a talk with another Skin mod and it seems we had agreed you apply the teamcolour properly (so its noticeable/distinct) ingame before approval, as its rather unfair of me to approve of this skin after breaking that agreement with other mod. I hope you understand and that you can easily and quickly change this, contact me when you have done so.
-Cheers, Kim.