• 🏆 Texturing Contest #33 is OPEN! Contestants must re-texture a SD unit model found in-game (Warcraft 3 Classic), recreating the unit into a peaceful NPC version. 🔗Click here to enter!
  • It's time for the first HD Modeling Contest of 2024. Join the theme discussion for Hive's HD Modeling Contest #6! Click here to post your idea!

Icon contest

Status
Not open for further replies.

Deleted member 157129

D

Deleted member 157129

Got no ideas, but I'd be interested in an icon contest.
 
How about a series of icons that respond to the World of Warcraft forms of magic? For example 4 forms of magic of the contestant's choice.
wowwiki.com said:
Forms of Magic

This information is gleaned from various bits of Warcraft lore, but does not necessarily represent official information.
Two categories of magic exist, arcane and divine. Divine magic contains druidism, shamanism, voodoo, and holy light, as well as other religions. Nature is a subcategory within the divine, but a form of it can also be found in arcane as well. Runes are mystically ancient, it is a type of arcane magic, but accessed by more natural means (see Runemasters and Inscribers).

Arcane

Arcane is the most common form of magic. Used by mages, wizards, and other sorcerers, such as those of the Kirin Tor, arcane magic is ever present in the atmosphere and accessible to any who are capable of drawing upon its energies. Arcane magics were discovered by the Kaldorei and later refined by the high elves of Quel'thalas and the human nations, and are most commonly practiced by mages.WRPG 150-151 WoWRPG 59
Arcane magic comes from the Well of Eternity, which itself draws from the Twisting Nether. Arcane magic is very powerful, but if not used carefully can cause corruption and great destruction. WoWRPG 248-249

Druidism

Another nature-reliant class, druids derive their power from the earth itself, although they do not require totems to channel energy like shamans. They become agents of nature itself, forming a bond with all beings of nature and pulling their strength directly from that bond. Night elves were taught druidism by Cenarius.WRPG 154 Only beings who are directly attuned with nature are capable of adopting the power of a druid.

Fel

The term Fel refers to the magics used by demons, more specifically, the Burning Legion. Fel energy is arcane magic at its most corrupt. If arcane magic is an addiction, fel magic is the embodiment of the drug at its purest form.

Geomancy

Geomancy is a practice of divination and elemental combat native to several humanoid races of Azeroth. It is similar to shamanism in that disciples of geomancy wield the powers of the earth and encourage respect of earth’s spirits. The main difference between a geomancer and a shaman is the method through which the trust of the elements is gained. A shaman speaks directly with the elemental spirits, whereas a geomancer uses rituals, songs, and sacrifices to appease and propitiate the spirits.

Holy/Light

This magic was originally practiced by the Clerics of Northshire, a priesthood in the earlier days of Stormwind. The clerics and priests who practiced it believed their magic came from belief in the Holy Light, a set of ideals the church dedicated itself to. WRPG 155 This form of divine magic is used to protect and heal, and comes from the naaru. Divine magic was later practiced by The Silver Hand, the group of Paladins who developed a melee-based hybrid form of the magic.

Necromancy


Necromancy is similar to the magics used by warlocks, however, instead focuses on the study of death rather than demonology. They are capable of reviving living creatures from death to do their bidding as undead servants.

Runic

Runic magic was created by the titans. Their creation, the dwarves, quickly mastered the mysteries of the runes taught to them. However, as generations passed, the dwarves forgot their heritage and lost all knowledge of runes and their hereditary powers.
Tauren in Kalimdor rediscovered the power of runes. An ancient race as well, the tauren remembered the myths of runecasting and revived interest in this nearly lost art. The dwarves that came to Kalimdor with Jaina Proudmoore's Alliance Expedition learned tauren runecasting techniques. Tauren and dwarves do not share good relations, but they were eager to share knowledge of runes and titan myths.
The Vrykul practice a runic magic that even the most experienced wizards find unfamiliar.

Shamanism

The shaman's power is drawn from spirits, both of ancestors and of spirits found in natural surroundings.WRPG 154-55 Shamanism is also practiced by some of the draenei who learnt shamanism on Draenor. In modern history, shamanism is common among orcs, tauren, trolls and draenei.

Voodoo

Voodoo is a strange tribal mix between the power of arcane and divine magic,LoC 117 practiced by witch doctors and shadow hunters. They often combine reagents in a cauldron to create strange brews that most often result in bizarre transformations when consumed. They are widely known for placing hexes to morph victims into various creatures or placing curses.M&M 55-57 HPG 66-68 The majority of voodoo users are trolls, although other races of the Horde have taken up the craft.
 
Well, I may spam this page, because I may get ideas in the future. For now I have this:
Contestant is choosing a race and creating 3-4 icons, that represent combat abilities which fits for chosen race. Not easy at all as I imagine.

EDIT: Since my work speciality is architectonics, I suggest upgrades for buildings.
It don't have to be corner with fundament border like on Human race icons.
It may be wooden colum/timber join, intersection of roof with/without tiles, barricade reinforcement, intersection of wall and such.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 157129

D

Deleted member 157129

Yeah, actually, like we had a texturing contest for making skins for custom models, why not have something similar where we make icons for skins and/or models that need icons? Perhaps not the easiest thing to judge, though. I also like Pharaoh's idea with different types of magic, and NFWar's idea of making ability icons for a specific race/unit.
 
Level 9
Joined
Jul 23, 2008
Messages
261
I got some ideas about what theme you might wanna go for...

Zombies
Simple idea etc, but why not evolve it further somehow? See who can come up with the best "evolved" zombie icon? For example: A zombie evolving in 3 steps, making a "first level" icon, then a "second level" icon and then a "third level" icon... maybe sounds strange... anyway, could be fun perhaps? Maybe create "spell" icons that must be inspierd by zombies in some way and that somehow fits the zombie theme? The possibilities for "zombies" are alot ;p

Modern War
Modern War icons? Guns, tanks, accesories, people etc etc...

Fable
Everyone might not have played the game, but it's quite fun, atleast the first two of the games, the third one ruined it all imo, but anyway to the point:
Make icons for 3 spells in the game? You could check youtube for inspiration, there are alot of videos there which shows the different spells.
A Very possible theme. Alot of simple spells, but which could be evolved further by the "artist".

Aaand i'm out of ideas for the moment.
 
What about a "Soul Striptease" where people create icons of whatever has been keeping their minds busy lately? :grin:
NFWar said:
How about icons for attachments at model section?
If we were to create icons for attachments, it would need some limitations, as we have tons of sword icons and similar already.

I can't think of any contest theme that offers more useful results than this one.
Mumbis said:
Hmmm, no, thanks. Even though this topic offers some variety, I find it to be pretty boring.
Since we haven't had a Phoenix Trial in what, 6 months, this one should be a bit more special.

It's rather difficult finding interesting topics whose results can be really useful in-game. Creating miscellaneous icons is a luxury, but contests should have useful results.
 
Level 25
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
2,512
Got an Idea:
Take an ability and change the unit/hero it represents
For example:
-Reincarnation
Tauren
reincarnation.gif
-> Skelton/zombie
skill-3.gif


-Mirror Image/Evasion
Blademaster
skill-3.gif

DemonHunter
thumb_BTNEvasion.png
-->
Faceless one
th_timewalk5.png
(not very good looking but you get the point)

Warstomp/taunt/blink etc... all represent a widely used ability but the icon only represent 1 unit.

If done right, it will be a challenge to artists :3 and their imagination

it can be 4 icons
make the icons represent another unit
OR
make the icons represent the general ability
vote on it.
 

Deleted member 157129

D

Deleted member 157129

A so-called "Soul Striptease" wouldn't be very useful at all, at least not in my case and I'm sure I'm not the only one who doesn't preoccupy myself with WarCraft, or even gaming for that matter. For instance, one of my icons would be something relevant to the Machine Head gig I went to this week.

I kind of like Joe's theme, taking an ability and changing the subject involved. It would also yield a lot of useful results.
 
So, will there be some sort of poll or who gets to decide which theme will be hosted?

I think Pyra will go with the theme we discuss the most here.

Edit: I got one.

Let us take a mistical creature/mithological person... E.G. Minotaur, werewolf, farries, vampires.. and create icons for its abilities.
Like minotaur, strenght of a bull, resistant skin, powerful attacks, rage(in some way), or farries; magical rainbows, magic dust,..

Each contestant should pick its own creature, nothing in specific pick anything you like.

I can't explain it better, hope you guys know what I mean?
 
Last edited:
i just want you guys, who will mostly be the ones to join the contest, to discuss and then come up with a consensus on what theme you guys want. what ever the top three choices are will be the themes for the next 3 icon contest. top three or at least some sort of list. so we can quickly host icon contests with minimal delays.

also. dont want polls. i want people who are actual contestants to decide what contest they want, not an arbitrary poll with votes from people who dont give a shit.
 

Deleted member 157129

D

Deleted member 157129

Well, I'd arrange my preferences like this:

Joe's idea of changing the subject of an icon.
NFWar's idea of making a set of ability icons for a race or a unit.
Pharaoh's idea of making a set of spell icons of the chosen category.

Lastly, making icons for other custom resources (skins, models or even spells) could be useful as well, but much less wholesome and probably hard to judge.
 
Well, I'd arrange my preferences like this:

Joe's idea of changing the subject of an icon.
NFWar's idea of making a set of ability icons for a race or a unit.
Pharaoh's idea of making a set of spell icons of the chosen category.

Lastly, making icons for other custom resources (skins, models or even spells) could be useful as well, but much less wholesome and probably hard to judge.

+1.
I'm not too familiar with the original icons of the main game anymore, so I'll have to search the whole MPQ files for fitting resources. :p
This should be fun.
 
Level 30
Joined
Jun 13, 2011
Messages
1,483
i just want you guys, who will mostly be the ones to join the contest, to discuss and then come up with a consensus on what theme you guys want. what ever the top three choices are will be the themes for the next 3 icon contest. top three or at least some sort of list. so we can quickly host icon contests with minimal delays.

also. dont want polls. i want people who are actual contestants to decide what contest they want, not an arbitrary poll with votes from people who dont give a shit.

Great comment :infl_thumbs_up: Nice of you


Well, I'd arrange my preferences like this:

Joe's idea of changing the subject of an icon.
NFWar's idea of making a set of ability icons for a race or a unit.
Pharaoh's idea of making a set of spell icons of the chosen category.

Yes, lets start with the Joe's idea
 

Deleted member 157129

D

Deleted member 157129

Changing the subject of a unit icon would be quite redundant, wouldn't it? It would just mean making a new unit icon. Look at Joe's examples, that's what we're doing.
 
Here are the suggestions

Forms of magic
Requests from the request section
Race related spell icons
Building Upgrades
Unit corresponding ability icons
Disruption
icon that correspodns with existing attachment models
Zombies
Modern War
Remake ability icons for a different hero
Hero contest related icons-Icons relating to the winners of the hero contest.
Reimagining of the vanilla wc hero abilities
Mythological creature related icons

13 themes. that is why i am not having a poll. this is exactly like how elections in those middle eastern countries with 20 different political parties end up as. everyone ends up around, give or take %1, 5% of the votes. Which tells nothing about the majority consensus.

It does look like there are multiple people who seems to like joe's idea but its like 3 people. it is still not a majority and at least one person made a valid argument against it. I will need a agreement from the majority of you.

How about this. you ALL nominate 3 themes from the list, in the order of most like, second like and third like.

So basically, what i will do is give each theme a score tally

if a theme has been chosen as a number 1 choice by a person, the theme scores 3 points.
number 2 choice means 2 points
number 3 choice means 1 point

then i will tally up all the numbers and then see what scored highest. this will give us a good understand on what people want and dont want as well as give me a list of possible themes for the future contests.

This tallying process will be open for the next 2 days or until i get at least 10 people. Post your comment asap and i will have the contest open right after we get an agreement
 
Level 17
Joined
Jul 1, 2010
Messages
721
1# Hero contest related Icon
2# Unit conresponding Icons =kinda sucky, but meeh
3# Race related spell Icon = even more sucky, but meeh

at least, these 3 allow us to be creative..
So all are sucky just cause you don't like them ? Unit icons is the WORST possible idea ever and I think many people will agree...I still vote either for custom unit abilities icons or remake existing unit ability icons of choice...
 
So all are sucky just cause you don't like them ? Unit icons is the WORST possible idea ever and I think many people will agree...I still vote either for custom unit abilities icons or remake existing unit ability icons of choice...

Yeah pretty much! but that's just my taste..... and I respect yours! I just think we had much cooler Icon competitions ideas in the past than now.
 
Level 17
Joined
Jul 1, 2010
Messages
721
What the HELL is your problem!? Stop fucking argueing, it's more than boring.
Focus your energy on the contest or something else for a change... >_>

I'd go with Hero contest related Icons aswell, though I'm afraid I won't have too much time to actually participate.
You mean me ? We'll that's not arguing, that's calling it like it is. I have no problem at least not with you...
 
Ok. just making the poll and clarifying the theme.

Same Abilities, Different Hero.

Choose 4 of the existing warcraft 3 abilities and re-imagine them to fit a different hero.

You can get a non hero specific abilities such as wind walk or frost nova and change them to something more specific to the new hero

OR

You can get a hero specific abilities such as carrion beetle, impale, resurrection or shockwave to be more specific to the new hero.

Please specify what the race and the class of the hero you are drawing the icon for, such as a gnoll mage or a murloc warrior.

everyone happy with that theme and theme description?

Also, i was thinking about 4 weeks. 4 weeks to create 4 icons. i believe that is plenty of time

ideally, the 4 icons would have at least one passive ability and one of them is an ulti
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top