Moderator
M
Moderator
20:22, 13th Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Approved
ap0calypse: Approved
(5 ratings)
Map Size: 0x160
Playable Map Size: 0x160
Barathrum's Review (Map Reviewer)
Description (Includes THW description, map description and Loading Screen):"
THW Description: I accept it, as it's a template anyway. (3/4)
Map Description: Template, not needed (X/3)
Loading Screen: Template, not needed (X/3
All together for these 3: 3/4
Terrain:
It does the job, but as many said above me, it's too small, you could also add some Important Mountains and rivers (6/10)
Gameplay:
Since it's a template, I'll rate it's use.
The template could have some use, but in most it woulden't be useful, maybe it would do for some Risk maps. (7/10)
Quest menu, Hints:
Quest menu: Not needed (/5)
Hints: Not needed (/5)
All together for these 2: X/10
Aditional Information:
Score Board:
0%-49% = 1/5 vote for rejection
50%-60% = 2/5 but i vote for either rejection or approval
61%-70% = 2/5 but i vote for approval
71%-80% = 3/5 vote for approval
81%-92% = 4/5 vote for approval
93%-100% = 5/5 vote for approval
Results:
Map Rating: 2/5 (Lacking)
Total: 16/24
= 67%
Vote for Approval?= Yes
Vote for Rejection?= No
Ratings5 (Highly Recommended)
4 (Recommended)
3 (Useful)
2 (Lacking)
1 (Unacceptable)Final Notes
I'm giving you 2/5, if you do some minor changes, I'll give you 3/5.
You can hardly place 2 units on hawaii as it is already :/Hawaii is not one island...
Good point: no, you can't.CWeener said:anyways, you wrote you didn't know whether people would want height or cliff tool for mountains...
could you even do mountains justice with the cliff tool?
This is excelent, the most accurate world map i have ever seen, but as has been constantly said, make it much, much bigger. best world shaping i have ever seen, keep it up.
"Any fool can criticize, condemn, and complain and most fools do."
~Dale Carnegie