If this is supposed to be an discrete toad eye item, so, firstly figure out that it is an spherical and semi-soft thing, and the cordy thing is coming from behind of it's shape. So, currently the thing on image looks stright and flat. Try to give it more shape via shading (and remove this wierd bright highline around the eye).
Possible some easy sfx will also improve the feeling of image (this empty space confuses a lot).