"In overall it is a boring map with some issues. The terrain needs major fixing as well. You need more custom items, spells... Try again, improve and update the map maybe something does come out of this. The large 3.5 Mb size doesn't help it at all."
THAT AINT FAIR! its his first map so you gotta give him some credit -_-
there is originality in it sometimes cos otherwise nobody would rate it.
give him a break will ya?
Being a newbie doesn't give a excuse of making a poor map. I had seen a maze map being make by a newbie, which is his first map and it was rather impressive and it was very well done in terrain, trigger and everything else as if it was develop by expert map maker.
So, using the excuse of "Hey, it was my first map" and "I am newbie in WE" is strictly unacceptable.
When I was new at mapping, I get a rather harsh critique as well and doesn't like it; but I soon discover the usefulness of those critique which gradually improve my mapping skill. Try view my map, you would notice most of my map have gone through a tremendous improvement.
A comment that said "Hey, great map", "5/5", "Superb" and etc etc are useless and pointless as they tend to make you more lazy and doesn't give any effort at mapping. This kind of comment are more likely to be an ass-kisser comment.
At here, you might sometimes receive compliment. But at wc3campaigns.net, they won't kiss your ass by praising your work if it was really awful. They tell nothing, but the truth. At here, a few of us tell the truth like they does as well.
I am reviewing this resources and would give feedback soon.
1) Poor terrain, you know your terrain is poor thus you must strive to improve it or get a person to help you.
2) Coding not that good, most of it could be optimize for better performance.
3) All unit seems to be massive spam.
4) Some hotkey doesn't working.
Overall rating was 1/5 and mini moderator vote was
REJECTED