I dont understand how you can judge a map that you have only played for 5 mins!
You dont say anything about heroes or anything, only that the first world mobs you meet are peons, and that you dont like peons so the whole map stinks? dude.. seriously.. I like suggestions and comments.. but your comment is based on a mob.. and it dose not sound like you have tested the map more than 1 min.. so how can you judge my map by that? ^^
If a map is awful, the beginning of the gameplay for about 5 minutes would show the sign of it.
If a map is awesome, user would play till the end.
1) Description - Description at hive site seems to be fine, but could be elaborate much further and a screenshot would not hurt either.
However, I definitely said it was a complete opposite for the map. It does not give a approriate information about it.
Without a proper information inside the game, it clearly violate the site rules for not having a decent description about it. Infact, I do not even know what is the mission objective at the beginning of the game. No information of where to go and what to do.
2) Terrain - The terrain was ugly as well, it lack of proper tiles variation usage and destructible/doodad. It was alright to use blizzard cliff as long as you did not spam the tiles and decorateb with some destructible/doodad (Which you certainly did not do so).
This make the entire terrain ugly and unprofessional especially for rpg genre.
3) Credit - There is no proper crediting for those custom resources you use. Stating that custom resources are taken from this site are not a proper crediting.
Without a proper crediting, you have violate the site rules.
4) Icon/Tooltips/Hotkey - I have to said you did a terrible job over here. You import a massive amount of custom icon without the passive icon, this make your entire map look terrible.
To top up with, it does not contain a proper hotkey as well.
Tooltips was lacking as well, it only show what does level 1 does but not the rest of the level. This give user a tough decision to decide which spells to learn. To make it worst, plenty of typo errors as well.
5) Replayability - Extremely low. No mission objective and the beginning of the game was just a hack and slash game. I play till Tauren Warrior and the result still the same, even the revival does not have any timer being shown.
1/5 (Unacceptable).
This map lack of proper polish and dull.