Sorry, but this is staying in Pending.
Here are my comments...
[-]Terrain lacks elevation and ground texture variation. It's just rough dirt and grass, it lacks spirit. Bad use of doodads and destructibles.
[-]Cinematics do not pause units or anything. Also, they are plain and boring, not to mention they occur too often, unnecessarily.
[-]The lore is confusing. So first we have captain Jack Sparrow, and suddenly we talk about the Burning Legion? Very bad mix in my opinion. Also, Undead attacking Humans. Too traditional.
[-]Poor work on the Object Editor.
[-]Bad use of music.
[-]Badly edited spells, and heroes that start at level 6... oh god. I could pass the entire first mission with only the 1 hero, which wasn't hard anyway, a Summon Lava Spawn that spawns three Lvl3 Lava Spawns at level 2...
Sorry, right now, my rating is 1/5 (Unacceptable). It just needs much more work.