Random Melee

[Moderator]

00:58, 18th Jun 2010
VGsatomi: rejected. The generated start positions are often faulty, causing players to be defeated at the initialization of the map.

 

[Aesthetics]

May I ask if you made the terrain generator?

Or did you get it (or the basic concept) from http://www.thehelper.net/forums/showthread.php?t=65722

Just curious, sorry if I offend you.

 

[Cyper95]

this is a ALTERED melee then

 

[Death_X]

No, I did not make the terrain generator. I did not know there was something like this already around.

I'll update the information and set it to altered melee.

 

[Cyper95]

btw does ai work??

 

[Death_X]

Yes, AI works (builds buildings, trains units and goes attacking your city)

 

[Cyper95]

ok i will be testing in a moment then prepare for a review xD

Review:
spawns: spawns are abit close to each other lawl it was insane
else everything was nice 4/5 vote for approval

 

[Death_X]

Thank you , I dont know how often you tried the map but it even generates different weather (summer, fall, winter).
I thought about adding some more tilesets to it (e.g. cityscape). Also i have not restricted the camera bound. That will be done in RC3 i think.

 

[Ironside]

THW Description: Very short (+1)
Map Description: Very short (+1.5)

Even tho you made a terrain generator, i've restarted 6 times, everytime i'd give it 1/10. (+1)

Due to bad terrain i left the game immediately, i'd say very bad.
I also noticed 2 times from 6 trys, it happened that player 2 was inside black land. And also in 1 run it happened: yellow and teal were completely by each other- their gold mines were around 400 range away.
They coulden't even do nothing, they were simply fighting for the base all game... (+0)

Bad placed (+3)

They are random placed, have no drops... (+3)

No drops (+0)

As all the other: just random placed... (+5)

0%-49% = 1/5 vote for rejection
50%-60% = 2/5 but i vote for reviewed
61%-70% = 2/5 but i vote for Aproval
71%-80% = 3/5 vote for aproval
81%-92% = 4/5 vote for aproval
93%-100% = 5/5 vote for aproval

Total: 14.5/70
= 20.7%/100%




Vote for Aproval?= No
Vote for Rejection?= Yes
Vote for Reviewed?= No

 

[kaalimato]

The spawns are waay too close. Mine and my enemy's townhall was literally touching eachother... We had a brutal militiawar.

 

[Cyper95]

lol militiawar= 1337 as hell just get a hero and its loads of lvls

 

[Master of Eagles]

What is the black area in the map?????? it seems you have used outland black terrain but why????? And why the map needs SO MUCH TIME to be generated???????

 

[DeadByMoon]

Good work! Nice, very nice!

 

[DeadByMoon]

This is a ggod melee map! respect!

 

[Mirkerus]

I like the idea but generated maps are extremely bland and many times happened that some player was just missing.