Random Map

[Darth_Schmellus]

Let me know, if you want something to be done with this idea...

 

[WolfFarkas]

The idea is interesting, I remember RA2 or EE had a random map generator tool.

but in wc3 it wont work,

for a balanced play, everything must be placed mindfully,
to much random will end in 1 player have all the mines near, and the other not, like you can see in your screen, thats not a good thing.

players like to practice, memorice the map for the best strategy.
also all the map is plain monotileset green and empty.

Let me know, if you want something to be done with this idea...

my sugestion perhaps would be design a normal melee map, with random neutral buildings
there is an option to make buildings spawn at random in fixed positions, like @mafe map

Brightwater Oasis


that would be a safe way to have game quality.

 

[Darth_Schmellus]

Noted.
I wanted a completely random map, where a player has to adapt to it. Downfall is, that, indeed it can generate unfair settings. This will however average over multiple generations. Will see

 

[WolfFarkas]

Noted.
I wanted a completely random map, where a player has to adapt to it. Downfall is, that, indeed it can generate unfair settings. This will however average over multiple generations. Will see

check @mafe map, you could master your idea of random spawns and have it balanced.

 

[mafe]

I really like the idea, but it might also be rather an "altered melee" than a regular "melee" by the hiveworkshop standards.

While this isnt a review yet, the map currently isnt using th the latest patch data (can hopefuyll be enforced by setting game data to "melee (latest patch)"), which it definitely would need to in order to be considered "Melee". Also, the itemdrops seem to be completely over the top for a "melee" map.

 

[deepstrasz]

Please, do not upload separate versions of the same map when they are not really different. Also your descriptions are lacking.

Random Map
As here, minor work in terms of melee. Also consider what mafe wrote.

Substandard.