Pirates route

[Moderator]

Orcnet

11:38, 27th Oct 2013

---

Pirates route (Tested Version 1) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "The idea of establishing your own free space is fair deal, creep difficulty though needs a little tone down throughout the game this will give more free hand hunting for players than bolstering armies just to creep out a spot or so." Terrain "The terrain doesn't have that Pirate appeal on the map, I suggest you make it more swamp-looking and more jungle spaced theme going on, because a Pirate can't hide his treasure on a wide range of ground right?." Management "Overall map can be useful." Total Score: (Gameplay[x/5] + Terrain[x/5] + Management[x/5] / Total Score[15] * 50 + 50) Rate Score Percent Letter 8/15 77% C

 

[taavidude]

good map!

edit: the only problem with the map is that computers are too dumb to use the ships or those flying goblin things, i cant remember their names right now XD and i think the monsters is some places like the nearest gold mine are pretty strong.
i would rate 4/5

 

[Theoden of KoMe]

Pirate Rote is an ordinary melee map made by sigelang and posted on the Hive

Idea/Concept:
I could start talking and talking and make a wall of text but I wont.Nothing original its just an ordinary melee map.

Idea 10/20

Terrain:
A big main island and some smaller at its surroundings.Kind of strange that the smaller island are the star locations.Nice beaches and doodads placed well.Maybe you need some more work with the middle part of the island cause I cant stand looking at it

Terrian 14/20

Gameplay:
Starting in an isolated island gives you a lot of time to expand and gain money and manpower.Small creep camps always help for 1-2 levels.I played it full house.Was a bit laggy but nevermind.Game goes smooth till someone makes a full scale assault to another.Then the big game starts

Gameplay 16/20

Rate and comments

You get 40/60 that's 3.5/5]

[/box]


Review Template by Hell Master

 

[BLazeKraze]

Pirate Rote is an ordinary melee map made by sigelang and posted on the Hive

Idea/Concept:
I could start talking and talking and make a wall of text but I wont.Nothing original its just an ordinary melee map.

Idea 10/20

Terrain:
A big main island and some smaller at its surroundings.Kind of strange that the smaller island are the star locations.Nice beaches and doodads placed well.Maybe you need some more work with the middle part of the island cause I cant stand looking at it

Terrian 14/20

Gameplay:
Starting in an isolated island gives you a lot of time to expand and gain money and manpower.Small creep camps always help for 1-2 levels.I played it full house.Was a bit laggy but nevermind.Game goes smooth till someone makes a full scale assault to another.Then the big game starts

Gameplay 16/20

Rate and comments[/box
You can always Improve everything.Please just remake the middle island cause I don't like it at all.

You get 40/60 that's 3.5/5]

Review Template by Hell Master

The size of the island is enough because they are far to each other , They can cut all the trees so the tendency the base become larger . And your problem is the middle Island , I think the middle has no problem, I placed the doodads very well . Your reason is "I don't like it at all" , this is invalid reason . You need to tell the good reason .

edit: the only problem with the map is that computers are too dumb to use the ships or those flying goblin things, i cant remember their names right now XD and i think the monsters is some places like the nearest gold mine are pretty strong.

The computer can't buy a goblin shipyards but they can bought a airship . I already played this map 3 times and I don't encounter a problem regarding in that issue, They attack my base by using goblin airships . The Ai know that thing .



-----BTW thanks to all of your feedbacks . ---------

 

[Rheiko]

@Theoden

Terrian 14/20

Terrain*

Rate and comments[/box
You can always Improve everything.Please just remake the middle island cause I don't like it at all.

You get 40/60 that's 3.5/5]

[color="silver"]You can always Improve everything.Please just remake the middle island cause I don't like it at all.

You get 40/60 that's 3.5/5[/color]

 

[Orcnet]

Map approved!