Hey, didn't know that you writes reviews
The mixing of the tiles is very nice, not great but it's a very suitable mixing of the tiles as it goes through each part of the map. The mixing of tiles of the roads have no problems, that's a very nice point.
Thank you a lot! I think that I'll rework the roads a little soon - I don't like white borderiards very much.
There is some good creativities in the map. There is some very good use of statues, walls, and overall doodads of the map, however it could be used more of creations.
This is not a signs of creativities
But yeah, thank you.
"It could be used more of creations" - please let me know what you mean - more of "man-made" decorations?
I think the spaces for constructions of players are a bit small, but that's however think of me.
This is a small penalty because of the number of Naxxramas enemies that would not allow them to overbuild.
Very good use of trees and mixing them! I cannot find any issues in this state.
I really like it too. As for me really interesting combination of trees, I dunno why I can see it sо rarely.
I really like those obelisks and vents of sewer! That's some sort of good creativity.
Do you really like vents of sewer? After patch 2.2 terrain was reworked, and a lot of space was freed up. For a long time I couldn't think of anything to fill it beautifully, and I didn't think of anything better than these pipes. But I'm really not pleased with the way it looks.
Terrain is way too smooth, try to make some height variations and some natural balances of terrain. There is already some good tools for making them in WE. Also you could use a misc data for increasing the height if you want.
I will try to fix it in 2.9.
P.S.: "Also you could use a misc data for increasing the height if you want." - I'm not sure that I understand what about you are talking, sorry.
Those gates ( you named them stells) around the cliffs are working as some great sort of walls. I mean they avoid the monotony of cliffs and make the cliffs the feeling of some nice decorating doodads even if they are blizz doodads. I think every nice map should use them as they are important imo and you used them. Nice think!
I like it also! I'm happy that you saw this map after "
GREAT COSMETIC UPDATE" patch 2.2, since most of the pluses you noticed were applied in this patch. Thank you!
Well, the fog really fits the map, however you could make it more horrible and dreadful by lowering blue color to 10 or 15, increasing the red color to 100 or 105 and lowering the green color to 80 or 70 to reach a fog combination of more dark red and dreadful that have some green color to fit the map and very few blue, I think fog is just like drawing
. However, that's just my thought.
I know that you are great artist so done without doubts!
Doodads variation is very nice, but you could use more variations if you care. More creative constructions and natural buildings that fit the map in a way. There is no need to do this, just for having more doodads variation.
I'm working on it all the time. With every pach I'm trying to add some interesting doodads, like a destroyed meatwagons and so on.
I think some building doodads are oversized from width view if you have an accurate eye, or maybe my eyes have problems. You can look at building doodads to understand whether I'm right or not. Dunno!
If you noticed, then it is. I will try to discover these problems, but I can't promise anything
:D
I think the messages at the starting of the map are really a great idea! Nice job on them!
Such messages is somethink like "recognizable sign" of my maps, thank you! Maybe later I will ask
@Elf_Lord to voice act for this map too, as for
Sands of Time. But I'm not sure.
I'm not a pro at triggering or coding, so I cannot give you my opinion in this state. I just looked at triggers and I should say they were very nice!
Hah, ok, thanks :3
I like the music of the map. I think it was very nice!
Finally! I've changed the music theme already 3 times, and it seems everyone is happy now.
Overall I think this is a very nice map!
I rate this map
4/5. You can also tell me if you're unhappy with my comment and I'll delete it as you wish.
Thank you a lot
@PrinceYaser! It's really useful review. Of course you must leave this coment even if you will give 1/5 - everyone have own opinion! Thank you again, I will try to fix this issues on comming 2.9 patch!