Most difficoult tileset?

[Arrr]

I just posted this new thread to ask you all wich is, in your opinion, the most difficoult tileset to make a map with...
That's because at the time I'm tryin' to make a new melee map, based on Icecrown Glacier, but it's very difficoult to make good terrains with it, expecially citys/ruins.
So I wanted to ask you, what do you think is the most difficoult tileset?

Last Thing: Respect to all terrainers who work with such tiles like Icecrown Glacier/Northrend

 

[sonofjay]

Icecrown/Northend ahhh I remember the days when I'm just starting, yup this one is a pain in the ass to terrain I usually combined other tileset for IG. Too bad my old melee maps are all lost when wcunderground closed.

So yeah my list is:

Hard:
-Icecrown
-Cityscape
-Dalaran/Ruins

My favorites:
-Village/Fall
-Ashenvale
-Sunken
-Underground
-Barrens

 

[Arrr]

Oh, so I'm not the only one having problems with Icecrown

 

[Ken-E]

If we are taking melee playable only. Then Outland is the hardest in my opinion, it's very tricky mixing those tiles without looking repetitive and I find it hard to have make good use of the doodads.

 

[sonofjay]

That is why I used custom tile on Outland, actually it is pretty good, but as you said, its really tricky.

 

[Arrr]

mmmm... I'll take this as a challenge

 

[sonofjay]

Good luck my friend. I'll probably go back on using custom resources for my next melee map. Its been a while since I last did a thing with my dark tiles.

 

[Arrr]

Working on it

 

[Remixer]

Thanks for the respect :#
Hardest:
- Dungeon
- Underground
- City tilesets

Favorites
- Sunken
- Ashen & Felwood
- Ice Crown Glacier
- Barrens

 

[NightSkyAurora]

I think it depends on what kind of map you wants to make. All the titles work the same, only the texture looks diffirent. For example I won't say City Scape is a hard title set, but it only looks weird to play with tiles everywhere. On the other hand, City Scape works brilliant to make castle-like maps.

 

[Filmting]

Rough order, hardest to easiest, for melee maps. My opinion, meaning how hard a time i have with.


Dungeon
Underground
Black Citadel
Outland
Lordaeron Summer
Cityscape
Dalaran
Dalaran Ruins
Lordaeron Winter
Lordaeron Fall
Village Summer
Village Fall
Icecrown Glacier
Northrend
Ashenvale
Felwood
Sunken Ruins
Barrens